There are many factors to this decision. Theirs was very different from the others.
It'll be hard flying, compared to button-pushing in a modern RJ. But it beats sitting on reserve for 6 months, or commuting somewhere inhospitable.
1st Year pay is about 5K better than the competition. Everybody is giving the same sign-up bonuses, except for Envoy whom just got desperate.
The number of people moving up/retiring is undeniable, I prefer a smaller list.
Airline Covers about 80% of Health Insurance costs, starting @ 60 days. Real flying benefits, not a program you have to buy from big brother.
There's also better compensation/accommodation during training, etc..
Yes, the recruiter was good. But you have to do your homework too.