Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Spirit (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/spirit/)
-   -   JCBA during a recession. (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/spirit/137614-jcba-during-recession.html)

Halon1211 05-08-2022 06:20 AM

JCBA during a recession.
 
With all indicators pointing to a impending recession, does anybody want to guess what contract negotiations with the new Spirit and Frontier pilot group will look like during a recession?

Will management try to use that as an excuse to low ball our pay rates while they still boast how we are “recession proof”?

Or will they recognize that they need pilots here and try to keep wages and benefits competitive.

nkbux 05-08-2022 06:27 AM

I wouldn't jump to conclusions on f9 just yet...something tells me B6 isn't done playing hardball...either way I think attrition and demand will still be "strong". It will however be a great tool for whoever is managing whatever airline to drag feet and pretend there's no problems

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

FlyGuy2002 05-08-2022 06:34 AM

B6 is done. They can keep trying but he board clearly spoke. And if they somehow accomplish a hostile bid the government will squash it. F9 is our dancing partner, And I’m very thankful for that. Negotiations will be a fight but they always are. Being the Nations 5th largest airline and attrition being what it is, we can, and should score nothing less than a great contract.

CincoDeMayo 05-08-2022 06:35 AM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3418977)
With all indicators pointing to a impending recession, does anybody want to guess what contract negotiations with the new Spirit and Frontier pilot group will look like during a recession?

Will management try to use that as an excuse to low ball our pay rates while they still boast how we are “recession proof”?

Or will they recognize that they need pilots here and try to keep wages and benefits competitive.

Frontier management (Franke) will play the hardest of hardball regardless of the economic climate. It’s going to be a fight. I’ve said it a few times, Spirit pilots need to get off their butts in this fight and join their F9 counterparts and fight for a JCBA worth having. Apathy will not get it done.

CincoDeMayo 05-08-2022 06:54 AM


Originally Posted by Trylabyte (Post 3418992)
Imagine this guy outta nowhere knowing everything and wanting to work did a company that hangs up a sign made of crayon. Just how useless are you in real life?

What in God's name are you trying to say?

nkbux 05-08-2022 06:55 AM


Originally Posted by FlyGuy2002 (Post 3418986)
B6 is done. They can keep trying but he board clearly spoke. And if they somehow accomplish a hostile bid the government will squash it. F9 is our dancing partner, And I’m very thankful for that. Negotiations will be a fight but they always are. Being the Nations 5th largest airline and attrition being what it is, we can, and should score nothing less than a great contract.

Whatever you say brother.. can't wait to face an interrogation from the chief pilots office because we block out late...and than again the next week for calling in sick...be careful what you wish for...it's out of our hands at this point and and I want what's best for the guys that fly the yellow planes. But I'm certainly not "thankful" that our "dance" is chaperoned by Bill Franke

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

sioux8ships 05-08-2022 07:12 AM


Originally Posted by nkbux (Post 3418999)
Whatever you say brother.. can't wait to face an interrogation from the chief pilots office because we block out late...and than again the next week for calling in sick...be careful what you wish for...it's out of our hands at this point and and I want what's best for the guys that fly the yellow planes. But I'm certainly not "thankful" that our "dance" is chaperoned by Bill Franke

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk


Exactly! Filler…

FlyGuy2002 05-08-2022 07:29 AM

I don’t call out sick unless I’m sick. So not worried about that. Know what I’m worried about ? After gate divestitures, and SLI, getting absolutely slaughtered seniority wise. Highly unlikely my QOL would even be in the same stratosphere as it is now with a B6 hookup. I think, as many do , the F9 marriage will be much more seamless and more advantageous long term. I’d suggest You be careful what you wish for. Getting absorbed by B6 could be a huge mess. I’d rather grow organically but I’m thrilled that F9 Is the choice of the 2. And if the merger is such a bad idea then why does B6 wanna kill it so bad.

dualinput 05-08-2022 07:32 AM

Over 400 spirit pilots went on strike during the deepest recession since the 30s for a contract against indigo. Hopefully the combined pilot group will have the balls to do the same if necessary.

nkbux 05-08-2022 08:02 AM


Originally Posted by FlyGuy2002 (Post 3419027)
I don’t call out sick unless I’m sick. So not worried about that. Know what I’m worried about ? After gate divestitures, and SLI, getting absolutely slaughtered seniority wise. Highly unlikely my QOL would even be in the same stratosphere as it is now with a B6 hookup. I think, as many do , the F9 marriage will be much more seamless and more advantageous long term. I’d suggest You be careful what you wish for. Getting absorbed by B6 could be a huge mess. I’d rather grow organically but I’m thrilled that F9 Is the choice of the 2. And if the merger is such a bad idea then why does B6 wanna kill it so bad.

So ALPA merger language only applies to F9 not B6...got it...if I were a better I'd guess you weren't here in 2010...God help us all

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

elmetal 05-08-2022 08:11 AM


Originally Posted by FlyGuy2002 (Post 3419027)
I don’t call out sick unless I’m sick. So not worried about that. Know what I’m worried about ? After gate divestitures, and SLI, getting absolutely slaughtered seniority wise. Highly unlikely my QOL would even be in the same stratosphere as it is now with a B6 hookup. I think, as many do , the F9 marriage will be much more seamless and more advantageous long term. I’d suggest You be careful what you wish for. Getting absorbed by B6 could be a huge mess. I’d rather grow organically but I’m thrilled that F9 Is the choice of the 2. And if the merger is such a bad idea then why does B6 wanna kill it so bad.

B6 doesn't want to kill our merger, B6 wants our planes and pilots to try and be a competitive airline in America. It has more to do with them succeeding and less to do with f9/nk failing



Sent from my Pixel 3a using Tapatalk

FlyGuy2002 05-08-2022 08:29 AM


Originally Posted by nkbux (Post 3419043)
So ALPA merger language only applies to F9 not B6...got it...if I were a better I'd guess you weren't here in 2010...God help us all

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

ha great argument. The shear size and level seniority B6 has at MCO and FLL would not bode well for us. I’m 35% in base. Merger policy would no doubt TRY and be fair but there is zero chance many of us would keep the same QOL. The plug at JetBlue in FLL is what 11 years on property or so? 9 years here and top 35%. MCO is similarly senior for them.
now throw in divestitures and route overlap mainly on the east coast the DOJ would surely axe and then what happens to relative seniority ?

F9 doesn’t have a ton of folks on the east coast and with the addition of PHX, TPA I can’t see a ton of folks from either airline chomping at
the bit to run to each other’s bases, keeping many peoples seat, seniority, relatively intact.

and In addition to the bloodbath a B6 digestion could be, I’ll firmly stand by my belief that the smart business move for long term growth potential is with an F9 marriage. Im
happy the Board voted 9-0 against.

FNGFO 05-08-2022 09:21 AM


Originally Posted by nkbux (Post 3418985)
I wouldn't jump to conclusions on f9 just yet...something tells me B6 isn't done playing hardball...either way I think attrition and demand will still be "strong". It will however be a great tool for whoever is managing whatever airline to drag feet and pretend there's no problems

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

Quoted so I wouldn’t have to type it.

ScrappyCocoa 05-08-2022 11:06 AM


Originally Posted by elmetal (Post 3419046)
B6 doesn't want to kill our merger, B6 wants our planes and pilots to try and be a competitive airline in America. It has more to do with them succeeding and less to do with f9/nk failing



Sent from my Pixel 3a using Tapatalk


Not sure why more people can’t see this.

dualinput 05-08-2022 11:55 AM


Originally Posted by FlyGuy2002 (Post 3419058)
ha great argument. The shear size and level seniority B6 has at MCO and FLL would not bode well for us. I’m 35% in base. Merger policy would no doubt TRY and be fair but there is zero chance many of us would keep the same QOL. The plug at JetBlue in FLL is what 11 years on property or so? 9 years here and top 35%. MCO is similarly senior for them.
now throw in divestitures and route overlap mainly on the east coast the DOJ would surely axe and then what happens to relative seniority ?

F9 doesn’t have a ton of folks on the east coast and with the addition of PHX, TPA I can’t see a ton of folks from either airline chomping at
the bit to run to each other’s bases, keeping many peoples seat, seniority, relatively intact.

and In addition to the bloodbath a B6 digestion could be, I’ll firmly stand by my belief that the smart business move for long term growth potential is with an F9 marriage. Im
happy the Board voted 9-0 against.

Complete speculation. Nothing more

FlyGuy2002 05-08-2022 12:04 PM

[QUOTE=dualinput;3419147]Complete speculation. Nothing more[/QU

Where it’ll remain speculative because it ain’t happening. Thankfully!

dualinput 05-08-2022 12:13 PM

[QUOTE=FlyGuy2002;3419151]

Originally Posted by dualinput (Post 3419147)
Complete speculation. Nothing more[/QU

Where it’ll remain speculative because it ain’t happening. Thankfully!

This isn’t over. My employee opinion withheld, as a share holder I want my $33. I’m sure many others feel the same

FlyGuy2002 05-08-2022 12:24 PM

[QUOTE=dualinput;3419157]

Originally Posted by FlyGuy2002 (Post 3419151)



This isn’t over. My employee opinion withheld, as a share holder I want my $33. I’m sure many others feel the same

isn’t over? Now that’s some good speculation right there .


nah . It’s over. And I dont want my $33. Ill
make way more in 10 years with twice the shares of ULCC

and keep in mind many investors will lose out at $33..

turbojet28 05-08-2022 12:30 PM

Ted said on the earnings call that even if they went with JB, it would likely be at least two years before anyone even got their $33/share

Lakeaffect 05-08-2022 01:10 PM


Originally Posted by turbojet28 (Post 3419167)
Ted said on the earnings call that even if they went with JB, it would likely be at least two years before anyone even got their $33/share

If the deal had been accepted, stock price would have gone up, regardless of when JetBlue paid the $33 dollars. We’d be sitting on probably $30 right now.

Lakeaffect 05-08-2022 01:21 PM

[QUOTE=FlyGuy2002;3419165]

Originally Posted by dualinput (Post 3419157)

isn’t over? Now that’s some good speculation right there .


nah . It’s over. And I dont want my $33. Ill
make way more in 10 years with twice the shares of ULCC

and keep in mind many investors will lose out at $33..

Take your $33 and reinvest in a ULCC with no major competition, that would be even greater return on your investment. As a shareholder it’s a no brainer.

DrDHD 05-08-2022 01:56 PM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3418977)
With all indicators pointing to a impending recession, does anybody want to guess what contract negotiations with the new Spirit and Frontier pilot group will look like during a recession?

Will management try to use that as an excuse to low ball our pay rates while they still boast how we are “recession proof”?

Or will they recognize that they need pilots here and try to keep wages and benefits competitive.

ted said during the earnings call there is no pilot shortage and there is no issue with pay.

expect to continue to be the lowest paid a320 operator. Truly see Allegiant surpassing f9/nk jcba pay rates. Mark this post.

Halon1211 05-08-2022 02:12 PM


Originally Posted by DrDHD (Post 3419210)
Mark this post.


This post have been successfully marked!

but yeah even those new start up's are paying more than NK! Kinda sad for us.

IWalkJun12 05-08-2022 03:33 PM

Walked out on Franke once before. Will gladly do it again if needed.

nkbux 05-08-2022 03:34 PM


Originally Posted by IWalkJun12 (Post 3419257)
Walked out on Franke once before. Will gladly do it again if needed.

Amen brother!

Sent from my SM-G998U using Tapatalk

dualinput 05-08-2022 04:18 PM

[QUOTE=FlyGuy2002;3419165]

Originally Posted by dualinput (Post 3419157)

isn’t over? Now that’s some good speculation right there .


nah . It’s over. And I dont want my $33. Ill
make way more in 10 years with twice the shares of ULCC

and keep in mind many investors will lose out at $33..

Who holds an airline stock for 10 years. Airlines are a trade. Very few people holding long term make money bc the next downturn is always around the corner.

ReserveCA 05-08-2022 05:09 PM


Originally Posted by IWalkJun12 (Post 3419257)
Walked out on Franke once before. Will gladly do it again if needed.

Give me my chance…….. tomorrow?

Halon1211 05-08-2022 05:39 PM


Originally Posted by IWalkJun12 (Post 3419257)
Walked out on Franke once before. Will gladly do it again if needed.

Just don’t walk-in on Franke…

HanYolo 05-08-2022 11:30 PM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3419222)
This post have been successfully marked!

but yeah even those new start up's are paying more than NK! Kinda sad for us.

Which start up is making more than NK?

CincoDeMayo 05-09-2022 04:41 AM


Originally Posted by HanYolo (Post 3419362)
Which start up is making more than NK?

Avelo

…….

emersonbiguns 05-09-2022 04:45 AM


Originally Posted by HanYolo (Post 3419362)
Which start up is making more than NK?

Avelo. First year only, but we all know it's about the drama.

elmetal 05-09-2022 05:12 AM


Originally Posted by emersonbiguns (Post 3419394)
Avelo. First year only, but we all know it's about the drama.

except over there you can actually upgrade in under 4 years and your movement as a captain isn't 10 vacancies a month.

Oh but wait we're totally gonna upgrade 24 a month, or 48, or whatever other made up number.

We're literally upgrading 10 a month because of attrition and our CEO has the audacity to say there's no shortage and no issue with our pay/CBA.

The cognitive dissonance is palpable. Sorry Ted, time to go.

Halon1211 05-09-2022 05:31 AM


Originally Posted by HanYolo (Post 3419362)
Which start up is making more than NK?

I thought I read in the breeze chat that the “Airbus” 220 Pay rate was paying more than Spirits Airbus rate.

mavsfflife 05-09-2022 06:11 AM


Originally Posted by elmetal (Post 3419399)
We're literally upgrading 10 a month because of attrition and our CEO has the audacity to say there's no shortage and no issue with our pay/CBA.

Of course he says there’s no issue with the pay/CBA. They play the game just like ALPA does. I’d be shocked if he said otherwise.

DEM1933 05-10-2022 09:40 AM


Originally Posted by FlyGuy2002 (Post 3419058)
ha great argument. The shear size and level seniority B6 has at MCO and FLL would not bode well for us. I’m 35% in base. Merger policy would no doubt TRY and be fair but there is zero chance many of us would keep the same QOL. The plug at JetBlue in FLL is what 11 years on property or so? 9 years here and top 35%. MCO is similarly senior for them.
now throw in divestitures and route overlap mainly on the east coast the DOJ would surely axe and then what happens to relative seniority ?

F9 doesn’t have a ton of folks on the east coast and with the addition of PHX, TPA I can’t see a ton of folks from either airline chomping at
the bit to run to each other’s bases, keeping many peoples seat, seniority, relatively intact.

and In addition to the bloodbath a B6 digestion could be, I’ll firmly stand by my belief that the smart business move for long term growth potential is with an F9 marriage. Im
happy the Board voted 9-0 against.


In regard to route overlap, why is it always assumed that the flying would be reduced?
If the separate airlines are selling the seats before merger seems the combined airline would be able to sell the same number combined, maybe more.

CincoDeMayo 05-10-2022 10:45 AM


Originally Posted by DEM1933 (Post 3420010)
In regard to route overlap, why is it always assumed that the flying would be reduced?
If the separate airlines are selling the seats before merger seems the combined airline would be able to sell the same number combined, maybe more.

Because JetBlue said they would divest Spirit flights from the NE in the new “enhanced” offer and they would likely have to divest from south Florida as well. It’s not that they want to, it’s that the government will make them and they have offered to divest already to appease them

dualratedchoppa 08-14-2023 11:57 AM

Reviving this thread speculating a possible recession in the near future. With the big 3 locking in their contracts for the next 4 years the pilot group is insured barring a furlough. American is buckling down and paying off their debts. United is expanding rapidly and Delta is the usual with their balanced approach.

What will happen to our JCBA if recession hits? B6 will feel the hurt if there is a drop in demand and cash flow during the integration. B6 has already spent a significant portion of their assets and taken in liabilities in acquiring NK.

Future proofing is next to impossible since no one has a crystal ball, however one can weigh the risk of staying with NK/B6 and staying for the merger or jumping ship to a big 3 who have locked in their contracts. Thanks for your input.

CincoDeMayo 08-14-2023 01:17 PM


Originally Posted by dualratedchoppa (Post 3682589)
Reviving this thread speculating a possible recession in the near future. With the big 3 locking in their contracts for the next 4 years the pilot group is insured barring a furlough. American is buckling down and paying off their debts. United is expanding rapidly and Delta is the usual with their balanced approach.

What will happen to our JCBA if recession hits? B6 will feel the hurt if there is a drop in demand and cash flow during the integration. B6 has already spent a significant portion of their assets and taken in liabilities in acquiring NK.

Future proofing is next to impossible since no one has a crystal ball, however one can weigh the risk of staying with NK/B6 and staying for the merger or jumping ship to a big 3 who have locked in their contracts. Thanks for your input.

1) Why is there a recession coming? Hasn't that been the chicken little call the last few years?
2) If you think the "Big 3 locking in their contracts" means anything in a recession, you haven't been paying attention or were around in the years 2000-2012.

Sorry but history has shown over and over that whoever is on top today, is the first to be sent to the bottom tomorrow, there is no "future proofing". Welcome to the airlines, it isnt all what some have seen the last 5 years, there is an ugly side to it. Not trying to be nasty to you, but there are way too many pilots who think the last 5 years is the "norm" and are not ready to see what the airlines really are outside of this swan even we have seen the last 5 years.

Excargodog 08-14-2023 02:22 PM


Originally Posted by CincoDeMayo (Post 3682630)
1) Why is there a recession coming? Hasn't that been the chicken little call the last few years?
2) If you think the "Big 3 locking in their contracts" means anything in a recession, you haven't been paying attention or were around in the years 2000-2012.

Sorry but history has shown over and over that whoever is on top today, is the first to be sent to the bottom tomorrow, there is no "future proofing". Welcome to the airlines, it isnt all what some have seen the last 5 years, there is an ugly side to it. Not trying to be nasty to you, but there are way too many pilots who think the last 5 years is the "norm" and are not ready to see what the airlines really are outside of this swan even we have seen the last 5 years.


Ain’t that the truth. Even companies who were top dog for decades sometimes just disappear.

https://i.ibb.co/bW0F7St/IMG-6360.jpg

SlimBob 08-14-2023 06:31 PM


Originally Posted by dualratedchoppa (Post 3682589)
Reviving this thread speculating a possible recession in the near future. With the big 3 locking in their contracts for the next 4 years the pilot group is insured barring a furlough. American is buckling down and paying off their debts. United is expanding rapidly and Delta is the usual with their balanced approach.

What will happen to our JCBA if recession hits? B6 will feel the hurt if there is a drop in demand and cash flow during the integration. B6 has already spent a significant portion of their assets and taken in liabilities in acquiring NK.

Future proofing is next to impossible since no one has a crystal ball, however one can weigh the risk of staying with NK/B6 and staying for the merger or jumping ship to a big 3 who have locked in their contracts. Thanks for your input.

JPMorgan just revised some stuff saying no recession in 2023. Take with whatever amount of salt you want but that's what was published recently. I'm simply saying it's not all doom and gloom right now on Wall St.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:50 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands