Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Spirit (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/spirit/)
-   -   Does working at a ULCC mean you deserve less? (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/spirit/145734-does-working-ulcc-mean-you-deserve-less.html)

Bluedriver 01-02-2024 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by MtoL (Post 3744758)
As a former LCC pilot, I take your point. There have been points in history where a particular pilot may be better off at a LCC.

Fact is, those times are the exception and not the norm. Your post raised another point. NK and B6 have guys furloughed from legacy carriers. They didn’t just get up and decide to leave.

No doubt, they’ve done very well for themselves, but the fact is that almost all the movement is from LCC to a legacy.

Should LCC guys get paid legacy rates? Absolutely. But it’s going to take time, and in that time, some opt to just go to a legacy and get the money now. All things being equal, they’ll come out ahead. They’re not any better just because their airline has been around longer.

Also true. In the case of NK or JB, the near term JCBA will close the pay gap for narrowbody flying, but won't make up for widebodies (near term anyway) or the retirement wave. But that wave is just that, a wave. The best seniority list spots over the next 20 years have already been filled by youngsters at UAL/DL, and are being filled now at AA.

Like I've said before, this industry is ALWAYS changing.
​​​​​

3inthegreen 01-11-2024 05:01 AM


Originally Posted by panpanpan (Post 3743664)
This is the line of thinking I am hearing from pilots. “We are the highest paid ULCC” as a justification for making less than other airline pilots.

Working at a company that has a low fare business model does not make you worth less as a pilot. You are still responsible for the aircraft and hundreds of lives day in and day out. You had to work just as hard to get an ATP. You can still be violated by the FAA. Why does the company’s business model matter?

You deserve to be paid as much as the Jetblue or Delta pilot who does the same exact job. One could argue that being a Spirit pilot is more difficult with the more densely packed aircraft and higher incidence of passenger issues to deal with. Should you get paid more for that? The argument can be made.

In the upcoming JCBA negotiations great things can be accomplished. Don’t settle for less.


Spirit pilots should make less than Legacy pilots because Spirit pilots ass a whole view themselves as a devalued work group. In 2018, 70% voted to make significantly less than Legacy Pilots. In 2022, 70% again voted to make significantly less than Legacy Pilots. As long as 70% of the group keep saying things like…… “It’s just Spirit!” “The ULCC business model can’t afford it.” “Spirit will never pay what Delta pays!!” “We don’t need to make that money because of our work rules.” Then Spirit management will keep owning you guys at the Negotiating table.

Halon1211 01-11-2024 06:15 AM


Originally Posted by 3inthegreen (Post 3749420)
Spirit pilots should make less than Legacy pilots because Spirit pilots ass a whole view themselves as a devalued work group. In 2018, 70% voted to make significantly less than Legacy Pilots. In 2022, 70% again voted to make significantly less than Legacy Pilots. As long as 70% of the group keep saying things like…… “It’s just Spirit!” “The ULCC business model can’t afford it.” “Spirit will never pay what Delta pays!!” “We don’t need to make that money because of our work rules.” Then Spirit management will keep owning you guys at the Negotiating table.


I look at it the other way around. Legacy pilots don’t get the quality of life that Spirit pilots get.

you have to ask yourself. Does that extra money make you that much happier or would you rather have quality of life?

60av8tor 01-11-2024 06:33 AM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3749454)
I look at it the other way around. Legacy pilots don’t get the quality of life that Spirit pilots get.

you have to ask yourself. Does that extra money make you that much happier or would you rather have quality of life?

Don't know many WB peeps, huh?

And...you're the poster child for that guy's post. "Is the extra $ worth it"

Maybe not to you, but that doesn't mean the entire pilot group should be worth less IMO.

Noisecanceller 01-11-2024 07:31 AM


Originally Posted by 60av8tor (Post 3749465)
Don't know many WB peeps, huh?

And...you're the poster child for that guy's post. "Is the extra $ worth it"

Maybe not to you, but that doesn't mean the entire pilot group should be worth less IMO.


I was thinking the same thing.

Counterpoint though is when you have a mangament group that just says no and the NMB puts you on ice for months and you know you won’t get released where do go?

Tornado875 01-11-2024 07:49 AM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3749454)
I look at it the other way around. Legacy pilots don’t get the quality of life that Spirit pilots get.

you have to ask yourself. Does that extra money make you that much happier or would you rather have quality of life?

This sentiment always makes me laugh, particularly when you occasionally have Ex Spirit pilots at legacies visit these forums and say "Yes, my QOL is much better now, I am making more money and working less" But some of you just put your fingers in your ears and act like they are deluded.

RJSAviator76 01-11-2024 07:56 AM

There is no reason ULCC pilots shouldn't have parity with the similar equipment payscale at the legacies and Southwest if we vote in this TA. None whatsoever.

nene 01-11-2024 09:40 AM


Originally Posted by 60av8tor (Post 3749465)
Don't know many WB peeps, huh?

And...you're the poster child for that guy's post. "Is the extra $ worth it"

Maybe not to you, but that doesn't mean the entire pilot group should be worth less IMO.

This is also sort of a byproduct of having such a young pilot group. When you are in your early 20's you think $30K is like $300K. As you age, gain responsibilities, expenses and toys, you later realize that every $$$ can be put to good use.

Tranquility 01-11-2024 10:42 AM


Originally Posted by Noisecanceller (Post 3749508)
Counterpoint though is when you have a mangament group that just says no and the NMB puts you on ice for months and you know you won’t get released where do go?

You forgot the restraining order too...

60av8tor 01-11-2024 10:53 AM


Originally Posted by Noisecanceller (Post 3749508)
I was thinking the same thing.

Counterpoint though is when you have a mangament group that just says no and the NMB puts you on ice for months and you know you won’t get released where do go?

For sure and understood. Not saying there's an easy way to get there from here. Wish there was for everyone.

60av8tor 01-11-2024 10:59 AM


Originally Posted by nene (Post 3749597)
This is also sort of a byproduct of having such a young pilot group. When you are in your early 20's you think $30K is like $300K. As you age, gain responsibilities, expenses and toys, you later realize that every $$$ can be put to good use.

Very good point. If you've been busting your hump for a decade or two, every dollar less than commensurate compensation feels more like a FU - especially with some of the RJ rates. Probably a much different view if your college, ramen, CFI days are a recent memory, which is happening more and more in the current hiring environment.

11atsomto 01-11-2024 11:00 AM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3749454)
I look at it the other way around. Legacy pilots don’t get the quality of life that Spirit pilots get.

you have to ask yourself. Does that extra money make you that much happier or would you rather have quality of life?

I mean we are in unprecedented times that won't last.....but movement on the narrow body at UAL is much quicker than Spirit and Big Blue.....so new people gotta be askin....aaaaaa why stay here? For QOL that I don't yet have?

Bluediver 01-11-2024 04:29 PM


Originally Posted by nene (Post 3749597)
This is also sort of a byproduct of having such a young pilot group. When you are in your early 20's you think $30K is like $300K. As you age, gain responsibilities, expenses and toys, you later realize that every $$$ can be put to good use.

Think of all those Miata after market parts. The possibilities are endless!

spooldup 01-11-2024 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by Bluediver (Post 3749820)
Think of all those Miata after market parts. The possibilities are endless!

All those miata parts you can put on with your 20 days off and go race during the weekend!!!

Bluediver 01-11-2024 08:16 PM


Originally Posted by spooldup (Post 3749874)
All those miata parts you can put on with your 20 days off and go race during the weekend!!!

Real men race on dirt.

Beech Dude 01-12-2024 01:21 AM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3749454)
I look at it the other way around. Legacy pilots don’t get the quality of life that Spirit pilots get.

you have to ask yourself. Does that extra money make you that much happier or would you rather have quality of life?


Originally Posted by Bluediver (Post 3749924)
Real men race on dirt.

Top post of forum. Good stuff.

Boxhound 01-12-2024 01:35 AM


Originally Posted by spooldup (Post 3749874)
All those miata parts you can put on with your 20 days off and go race during the weekend!!!

Miata?

MAN CARD-----REVOKED!!!

spooldup 01-12-2024 04:22 AM


Originally Posted by Bluediver (Post 3749924)
Real men race on dirt.

your right, let me park the miata next to my subaru and get to a rally event.

dirt, track, anything will be fun with the days off!

checkgear 01-12-2024 04:39 AM


Originally Posted by Boxhound (Post 3749949)
Miata?

MAN CARD-----REVOKED!!!

I hereby rescind your invitation to the Airline Pilot Miata Owners Club

CAirBear 01-13-2024 09:01 AM


Originally Posted by Tornado875 (Post 3749519)
This sentiment always makes me laugh, particularly when you occasionally have Ex Spirit pilots at legacies visit these forums and say "Yes, my QOL is much better now, I am making more money and working less" But some of you just put your fingers in your ears and act like they are deluded.

Exactly. Granted this BS was said by Halon (one of the biggest moron trolls here at NK, but this sentiment runs deep with some NK guys).

I left 10 months ago. I already bid 64% in base/fleet (the 🚌) and have 18 off this month. Currently perusing the ole APC on my Balcony finishing up a week long cruise. My life is completely dog$hit.

DTZ was great and I had a good 4 years at NK, but some of you have to truly start understanding that people’s lives aren’t miserable elsewhere. I absolutely love it where I’m at now.

Halon1211 01-13-2024 09:09 AM


Originally Posted by CAirBear (Post 3750973)
Exactly. Granted this BS was said by Halon (one of the biggest moron trolls here at NK, but this sentiment runs deep with some NK guys).

I left 10 months ago. I already bid 64% in base/fleet (the 🚌) and have 18 off this month. Currently perusing the ole APC on my Balcony finishing up a week long cruise. My life is completely dog$hit.

DTZ was great and I had a good 4 years at NK, but some of you have to truly start understanding that people’s lives aren’t miserable elsewhere. I absolutely love it where I’m at now.

Ahhh…to be you!

18 days off and on a weeklong cruise. I think you sold me now!

Bluediver 01-13-2024 12:14 PM


Originally Posted by Halon1211 (Post 3750979)
Ahhh…to be you!

18 days off and on a weeklong cruise. I think you sold me now!

You’re still in his head lol

Bluedriver 01-15-2024 03:16 PM


Originally Posted by CAirBear (Post 3750973)
Exactly. Granted this BS was said by Halon (one of the biggest moron trolls here at NK, but this sentiment runs deep with some NK guys).

I left 10 months ago. I already bid 64% in base/fleet (the 🚌) and have 18 off this month. Currently perusing the ole APC on my Balcony finishing up a week long cruise. My life is completely dog$hit.

DTZ was great and I had a good 4 years at NK, but some of you have to truly start understanding that people’s lives aren’t miserable elsewhere. I absolutely love it where I’m at now.

Can we finally put to bed the notion that only NK has good QOL, finally?

Thanks for the post Bear.

SoFloFlyer 01-15-2024 09:48 PM


Originally Posted by Bluedriver (Post 3752492)
Can we finally put to bed the notion that only NK has good QOL, finally?

Thanks for the post Bear.

Idk about that one, Chief. My junior buddies at B6 have dog**** schedules and nothing they can do about it. Bear has seniority in BES so he gets good QOL. Hard press to find good QOL for junior pilots at B6.

ag27 01-16-2024 12:10 AM

where are you now? curious
if you don't wnat mention airline, I understand. But at least, mainiline or something?
thx

Beech Dude 01-16-2024 02:15 AM


Originally Posted by ag27 (Post 3752663)
where are you now? curious
if you don't wnat mention airline, I understand. But at least, mainiline or something?
thx

If he's moved up to 64% in less than a year and was previously at NK, then I'd bet yes, he's at a legacy.

Billy Tate 01-16-2024 05:06 AM


Originally Posted by Bluedriver (Post 3752492)
Can we finally put to bed the notion that only NK has good QOL, finally?

Thanks for the post Bear.


This mentality will never go away at Spirit. The pilots here believe it's the only airline where pilots can get holidays and weekends off.

BananaHammock 01-16-2024 05:53 AM


Originally Posted by Bluedriver (Post 3752492)
Can we finally put to bed the notion that only NK has good QOL, finally?

Anyone who truly believes that is just dumb.

The truth of the matter is nostalgia. People who now are very senior doing day trips think back to their former lives. A life where our point-to-point system was one leg a day, 3 hrs of block for 5 hours pay, 5 hours pay for >22 hr overnight or whatever it was before the change, etc, etc. Also, crew scheduling was just so incredibly inept it worked out to their benefit many many times.

Currently, it has almost become more hub and spoke like here. All those one-leg out and one-leg back 2-day trips LGA, DTW, IAH, CLE, etc, etc are pretty much gone out of the bid package (at the moment anyhow, though they declined significantly that past few years). Crew scheduling has also apparently finally learned to read the contract and is exercising their end as you would expect in any normal airline - adding turns at the end of a trip to a reserve pilot, moving days off, etc, etc.

So, yeah can still drop to zero, can still call sick with no "points" or any other kind of repercussion. I guess that's "QoL"...

Billy Tate 01-16-2024 06:13 AM

Spirit RSV is the worst in the industry. We gave up the farm on RSV in 2018

Halon1211 01-16-2024 07:02 AM


Originally Posted by Billy Tate (Post 3752693)
This mentality will never go away at Spirit. The pilots here believe it's the only airline where pilots can get holidays and weekends off.

dumb, nobody is arguing that.

Even though I know you are being sarcastic at least make a valid argument to back up your point.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:01 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands