Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   Self Selecting (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/142359-self-selecting.html)

ReadOnly7 04-10-2023 11:57 AM


Originally Posted by hummingbear (Post 3621955)
😂 Yes! Clearly cis-hetero-males can’t catch a break & are underrepresented in our labor force as well as union & corporate leadership.

I don’t really GAF. I have my job, and you can hire EXCLUSIVELY minorities, trans, whatever. I just get a yucky taste form blatant intellectual dishonesty. You don’t fight discrimination with DIFFERENT discrimination. I have kids. I try to treat them equally. If one of them gets a bigger lunch….I can’t fix that by only feeding the others at dinner. I’m all for diversity. If I had to fly with ONLY “guns & God” MAGA dudes (which I am NOT)….I would hate this job. Not all of us who call BS on this stuff are racists, homophobes, or xenophobes. Some of us just don’t like BS.

For example……..there’s a poster at one of our domiciles…of a certain individual….”good leading the way”. He’s a disgusting human being with a COMPANY-wide reputation. But….he fits the profile for what the casting department wanted. Tell me how that’s ANY better than casting the beautiful, blond, blue-eyed FA for all the magazine ads in the ‘70s. It’s not BETTER, it’s the SAME. But….discrimination should fix the problem of discrimination….right?

hummingbear 04-10-2023 12:03 PM


Originally Posted by ReadOnly7 (Post 3621990)
I don’t really GAF. I have my job, and you can hire EXCLUSIVELY minorities, trans, whatever.

For someone who “just doesn’t like BS”, you have an interesting way of overstating what is actually happening to a ridiculous extreme.

TriggeredNOTAM 04-10-2023 01:37 PM

I would happily wear a pin that says, “I’m pretty sure I disagree with every opinion you have that doesn’t involve flying. Can I please just read?”

Spartacusbob 04-10-2023 04:42 PM


Originally Posted by hummingbear (Post 3621950)
Part of the miscommunication that’s happening here is that we’re talking about two different things.

First was the MEC statement on non-discrimination, which was the subject of the original post. This was extremely benign & generic and- as discrimination is against the law, anyway- tantamount to me making a commitment to not cooking meth in my basement. Exactly no one should care about this; but I do love the irony that I’m a fragile snowflake for not being offended by it.

The second topic seems to be the existence of a DEBI committee at ALPA. Again, not the topic originally in question, but fine. Now, we could attempt to have the nuanced adult conversation about the social theories upon which DEI is based, gaps in representation, concerns of overreach, etc., that has as yet eluded these forums; but in the meantime, the pragmatic reality is that a large part of this is just litigation insurance. Everyone here should be wise enough to understand that relying solely on “organic diversity”- an interesting term used to describe an industry that’s historically drawn over 90% of its labor from a single demographic, but I digress- opens any group up to potentially damaging & costly accusations. Some of you guys are so fired up on principle that you’d spend your entire war chest in court rather than having the dreaded DEI label attached to anything you’re associated with. Please grow up, take your own advice, & focus on the actual battle at hand- our contract.

Diversity and inclusion are fine. I don’t think a single person here would argue that. Equity is the very definition of systemic racism and while that’s a factual statement, one can decide for themselves, debate, if equity belongs in a community of aviators.

Also, since the union is already formed from the very same people who are vetted and hired by the company, a very intersectionally aware company; I wonder how much value a D and I committee has that my union dues are paying for. Frankly, that’s a fair question. One that was probably answered on the first thread since there are mandates for businesses to have such statements and was probably learned by the original op who was unnecessarily castigated by the childish and small behavior of the op of this thread.

John Carr 04-10-2023 05:55 PM


Originally Posted by hummingbear (Post 3621950)
Part of the miscommunication that’s happening here is that we’re talking about two different things.

First was the MEC statement on non-discrimination, which was the subject of the original post. This was extremely benign & generic and- as discrimination is against the law, anyway- tantamount to me making a commitment to not cooking meth in my basement. Exactly no one should care about this; but I do love the irony that I’m a fragile snowflake for not being offended by it.

The second topic seems to be the existence of a DEBI committee at ALPA. Again, not the topic originally in question, but fine. Now, we could attempt to have the nuanced adult conversation about the social theories upon which DEI is based, gaps in representation, concerns of overreach, etc., that has as yet eluded these forums; but in the meantime, the pragmatic reality is that a large part of this is just litigation insurance. Everyone here should be wise enough to understand that relying solely on “organic diversity”- an interesting term used to describe an industry that’s historically drawn over 90% of its labor from a single demographic, but I digress- opens any group up to potentially damaging & costly accusations. Some of you guys are so fired up on principle that you’d spend your entire war chest in court rather than having the dreaded DEI label attached to anything you’re associated with. Please grow up, take your own advice, & focus on the actual battle at hand- our contract.


Originally Posted by hummingbear (Post 3621996)
For someone who “just doesn’t like BS”, you have an interesting way of overstating what is actually happening to a ridiculous extreme.

Good job keeping it real and flexing some message board thug lyfe

​​​​​​

Originally Posted by hummingbear (Post 3608815)
Perhaps if you considered my smug, arrogant persona a way of irritating forum patrons like yourself you’d find it more amusing? Just a suggestion…


ReadOnly7 04-10-2023 06:46 PM


Originally Posted by hummingbear (Post 3621996)
For someone who “just doesn’t like BS”, you have an interesting way of overstating what is actually happening to a ridiculous extreme.

I didn’t say that is what is happening, Captain StrawMan….. I am using hyperbole to explain how much I DON’T care what is done. But hey, that sort of spin and deflection is pretty common these days.

Snooter 04-10-2023 07:41 PM

My gawd can you all just stop? 4 pages going back and forth about stuff that doesn’t affect you, get a hobby.

hummingbear 04-11-2023 07:46 AM


Originally Posted by ReadOnly7 (Post 3622175)
I didn’t say that is what is happening, Captain StrawMan….. I am using hyperbole to explain how much I DON’T care what is done.

Oh man, you’re gonna laugh but I thought you were inviting me to join you in a straw man fallacy competition


Originally Posted by ReadOnly7 (Post 3622175)

”good leads the way”….as long as that person isn’t a cys/heterosexual/male. Those people are ALWAYS bad.

I have my job, and you can hire EXCLUSIVELY minorities, trans, whatever.

Not all of us who call BS on this stuff are racists, homophobes, or xenophobes.

This is embarrassing for me. Thanks for being cool about it & remembering to call me captain, though.

DownWithNarita 04-11-2023 09:16 AM

Ever notice the people who calls others snowflakes are the biggest snowflakes of them all?

ReadOnly7 04-11-2023 12:17 PM


Originally Posted by DownWithNarita (Post 3622440)
Ever notice the people who calls others snowflakes are the biggest snowflakes of them all?

I haven’t seen that term used on this thread?
sounds racist to me….


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:20 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands