Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   Let's make something out of nothing... (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/86686-lets-make-something-out-nothing.html)

Shrek 02-28-2015 01:00 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1833234)
See this statement here is why we got a nasty gram that made world news. The new checklist is fantastic in my opinion we need to cross check all that stuff. How many times have you taken off without LNAV selected? I have done it. How many times have you taken off with a discontinuity in the FMC? I have done it. Lets say 10 more words in 5 more seconds and protect ourselves. Being lazy should not be in a pilots job description yet its the norm that I see, and being on property for only a year and a half I'm disappointed. I have had to read MELs to CAs because they thought they knew what it said and didn't want to look it up. Guess what? they didn't know what it said. I have watched CAs and FOs not do the proper ETOPS checks because "It is pointless busy work since we have ADS-B and CPDLC". Guess what? We got another nasty gram.

Lets stop playing the CAL and UAL hatred games and finger pointing and stand up for ourselves, come together, and take this memo as a battle cry against the desk jockeys in management.

NEW HIRES:

By the end of this year we will be 10% of the total pilots on property WE need to help make the change. WE need to speak out on what we think is right and wrong. WE need to hold all of our crew members to SOP even if they don't like it. Most of the pilots we fly with are fantastic but there is a larger majority then I would like that are lazy, complain and refuse to change and adhere to current SOPs.

New Hires, we don't know nor should we care what the old SOP said all we know is what it says now and how we were trained. So do what you were taught to do and don't accept any variations! We can change this culture so lets get on it.

Oh and wear your ALPA pin. Its an easy place to start.

+1
It's not WHO'S right but WHAT'S right.

Shrek 02-28-2015 01:09 PM


Originally Posted by SpecialTracking (Post 1833485)
As long as one side enforces their legacy way of doing things versus the right/safest way.

THIS ^

I have been on the Guppy since NOV 2012. I was hoping that things would change slightly but steadily away from what you are describing. It is a huge red flag that is not being dealt with effectively yet.

If not corrected it WILL manifest itself in an ugly and deadly way IMO in the future.

flybynuts 02-28-2015 05:03 PM

Actually, it's both sides holding on to legacy ways. The kicker is everyone thinks it's the other side and that the other side is wrong or messed up. Just as some say the 737 training is lacking I hear the same on the other new hire platforms. It's a failure of leadership to me.

Shrek 02-28-2015 07:57 PM


Originally Posted by flybynuts (Post 1834373)
Actually, it's both sides holding on to legacy ways. The kicker is everyone thinks it's the other side and that the other side is wrong or messed up. Just as some say the 737 training is lacking I hear the same on the other new hire platforms. It's a failure of leadership to me.

It may be and that sh*t needs to stop ASAP. I don't care which side did or does what now - we need to change as a pilot group for the better. It appears we will have to do it alone until MGT catches up if ever.

flybynuts 02-28-2015 09:19 PM

True. The problem is we all have baggage that can't let us see or focus that clearly to make this point. We can all complain and point fingers while we dig our heels in and prepare for the fight. Not saying we as in you Shrek or towhee but as a group. Howard needs to step up or step out. The politics are getting out of hand.

sleeves 03-01-2015 04:13 AM


Originally Posted by Knotcher (Post 1834107)
So your beef is checking the altimeter twice instead of checking it only once? Isn't it more conservative and thus more safe to check it twice? Do you want more safety or not?

Yes checking it twice is safer. It is usually done at FL180 on the way down. On a fleet like the 737 that is mostly domestic you become accustomed to setting it then. Then you go to a place like AUA and it is not set till FL40. Running the approach check with a second check of the altimeters helps eliminate this error. Besides like someone else said just like between the brief and t/o stuff can change. It is on the checklist twice because the pilot group had issues not having it set. If we were having problems taking off with the fmc and mcp not set properly I am glad a second check of that is included as well.

BeeWatcher 03-01-2015 07:08 AM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1833234)
See this statement here is why we got a nasty gram that made world news. The new checklist is fantastic in my opinion we need to cross check all that stuff. How many times have you taken off without LNAV selected? I have done it. How many times have you taken off with a discontinuity in the FMC? I have done it. Lets say 10 more words in 5 more seconds and protect ourselves. Being lazy should not be in a pilots job description yet its the norm that I see, and being on property for only a year and a half I'm disappointed. I have had to read MELs to CAs because they thought they knew what it said and didn't want to look it up. Guess what? they didn't know what it said. I have watched CAs and FOs not do the proper ETOPS checks because "It is pointless busy work since we have ADS-B and CPDLC". Guess what? We got another nasty gram.

Lets stop playing the CAL and UAL hatred games and finger pointing and stand up for ourselves, come together, and take this memo as a battle cry against the desk jockeys in management.

NEW HIRES:

By the end of this year we will be 10% of the total pilots on property WE need to help make the change. WE need to speak out on what we think is right and wrong. WE need to hold all of our crew members to SOP even if they don't like it. Most of the pilots we fly with are fantastic but there is a larger majority then I would like that are lazy, complain and refuse to change and adhere to current SOPs.

New Hires, we don't know nor should we care what the old SOP said all we know is what it says now and how we were trained. So do what you were taught to do and don't accept any variations! We can change this culture so lets get on it.

Oh and wear your ALPA pin. Its an easy place to start.



Maybe you mistake "lazy" with a pilot pacing himself through a 30-40 year career of strikes, bankruptcies, furloughs, and constant change. There hasn't been a pilot attributed hull loss here since you were suckling on your mother's left one and Howard was getting trip drops for his work with Duane. If you are going to call out pilots don't do so on a public forum. Talk to them in person or go to professional standards. The only new hires that "saved" an airline was the 570 (just ask them)...and yes I do wear an ALPA pin.

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 07:54 AM


Originally Posted by BeeWatcher (Post 1834622)
Maybe you mistake "lazy" with a pilot pacing himself through a 30-40 year career of strikes, bankruptcies, furloughs, and constant change. There hasn't been a pilot attributed hull loss here since you were suckling on your mother's left one and Howard was getting trip drops for his work with Duane. If you are going to call out pilots don't do so on a public forum. Talk to them in person or go to professional standards. The only new hires that "saved" an airline was the 570 (just ask them)...and yes I do wear an ALPA pin.

Im not afraid to speak up and I do talk to them in person. If they refuse to do the ETOPS checks that are required I do them after I show them the proper way to do it in the FM. It has caused some flight decks to be uncomfortable but I'm not going to wreck my 30 year career because you have seen it all and are "pacing" yourself from your 30 year career. Adapt or die isn't that Darwin? Maybe we should ask the flight engineer what he thinks.

Sparta 03-01-2015 08:20 AM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834651)
Im not afraid to speak up and I do talk to them in person. If they refuse to do the ETOPS checks that are required I do them after I show them the proper way to do it in the FM. It has caused some flight decks to be uncomfortable but I'm not going to wreck my 30 year career because you have seen it all and are "pacing" yourself from your 30 year career. Adapt or die isn't that Darwin? Maybe we should ask the flight engineer what he thinks.

The company is looking for flight managers like you...

pilotgolfer 03-01-2015 08:40 AM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834651)
Im not afraid to speak up and I do talk to them in person. If they refuse to do the ETOPS checks that are required I do them after I show them the proper way to do it in the FM. It has caused some flight decks to be uncomfortable but I'm not going to wreck my 30 year career because you have seen it all and are "pacing" yourself from your 30 year career. Adapt or die isn't that Darwin? Maybe we should ask the flight engineer what he thinks.

How long have you been online? Less than a year? You sure do have lots of answers. :rolleyes:

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 08:54 AM


Originally Posted by pilotgolfer (Post 1834675)
How long have you been online? Less than a year? You sure do have lots of answers. :rolleyes:

A year and a half. And all I have is the SOP as it was taught to me. I will fly it whether you like it or not. If I feel like a procedure is unsafe I will email the flight department or file an FSAP.

I want the NEW United to succeed because I have so much invested here. I hope to still be here when all of you are long retired. The people hired now have no affiliation with United, Continental, NY Air, Texas International, Frontier #1, Peoples Express, PanAM, Eastern, Braniff, TWA.......

The experience of the pilots I have flown with is amazing and I have, and will, continue to learn form that experience. But this holding on to the "old" way or not following the SOP because its stupid is not ok with me. The way it used to be done was perfectly safe but its not how its done now.

Don't you think we are doing the new hires a dis service by not following the SOP they have less than 100 hrs flying under? What are we teaching these new guys/gals?

SpecialTracking 03-01-2015 10:36 AM

Funny thing is 99% of the pilots I've flown with during my career are SOP. Even during all those phase/otj training changes we did our best to follow SOP. So the question begs young Master..., who are you flying with?

Btw, If by association in your post you have no affiliation with any of the legacy carriers, then why the old UAL paint scheme in your avatar?

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 11:18 AM


Originally Posted by SpecialTracking (Post 1834748)
Funny thing is 99% of the pilots I've flown with during my career are SOP. Even during all those phase/otj training changes we did our best to follow SOP. So the question begs young Master..., who are you flying with?

Btw, If by association in your post you have no affiliation with any of the legacy carriers, then why the old UAL paint scheme in your avatar?

I agree that most of the pilots here comply with SOP, but they are not the ones generating these degrading memos we keep getting. I'm done beating a dead horse you all know where I stand at this point and what my opinion is.

As for the avatar. I wanted to fly for United since I started my love for aviation. It was my goal and what I worked for with everything I did. I made it to United and I am proud to be here, and be part of the greatest airline in the world. I am going to do everything I can to keep United a world class airline that I am proud to work for. So my avatar stays because I achieved my dream.

John Carr 03-01-2015 11:29 AM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834691)
A year and a half......


The people hired now have no affiliation with United, Continental, NY Air, Texas International, Frontier #1, Peoples Express, PanAM, Eastern, Braniff, TWA.......


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834772)
As for the avatar. I wanted to fly for United since I started my love for aviation. It was my goal and what I worked for with everything I did. I made it to United and I am proud to be here, and be part of the greatest airline in the world. I am going to do everything I can to keep United a world class airline that I am proud to work for. So my avatar stays because I achieved my dream.

I'm just curious, but what magical thing happened between now and the year and half ago you were hired that dictates people hired NOW have NO affiliation with United? What does the plane say on the side?

Is there something special about YOU that you can claim you are "affiliated" with United?

When you were hired, were you done so under L-UAL or L-CAL staffing criteria?

As in, EWR 756 or 76T?

awax 03-01-2015 11:34 AM


Originally Posted by SpecialTracking (Post 1834748)
Funny thing is 99% of the pilots I've flown with during my career are SOP.

The other question that begs to be asked is: "Do the SOP's that company is pushing make us safer, or just standardized?"

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 11:42 AM


Originally Posted by John Carr (Post 1834777)
I'm just curious, but what magical thing happened between now and the year and half ago you were hired that dictates people hired NOW have NO affiliation with United? What does the plane say on the side?

Is there something special about YOU that you can claim you are "affiliated" with United?

When you were hired, were you done so under L-UAL or L-CAL staffing criteria?

As in, EWR 756 or 76T?

Sorry should have been more specific should have said L-UAL and L-CAL. I was hired by UNITED there is no L in front of the airline I was hired by or the airline I work for.

SpecialTracking 03-01-2015 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by awax (Post 1834782)
The other question that begs to be asked is: "Do the SOP's that company is pushing make us safer, or just standardized?"

I completely understand. Remember, some SOP's are immediate and some are the result of actions initiated.

SpecialTracking 03-01-2015 12:04 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834772)
I agree that most of the pilots here comply with SOP, but they are not the ones generating these degrading memos we keep getting.

"Who" is generating those degrading memos? Think about it for a while.

John Carr 03-01-2015 12:07 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834788)
Sorry should have been more specific should have said L-UAL and L-CAL. I was hired by UNITED there is no L in front of the airline I was hired by or the airline I work for.

So are you affiliated with United?

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 12:32 PM


Originally Posted by SpecialTracking (Post 1834803)
"Who" is generating those degrading memos? Think about it for a while.

The desk jockeys in the crystal palace. So lets stop giving them ammo.

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 12:32 PM


Originally Posted by John Carr (Post 1834804)
So are you affiliated with United?

What is YOUR point? Because you clearly missed my point.

John Carr 03-01-2015 12:34 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834820)
What is YOUR point? Because you clearly missed my point.

Apologies.

Clarify, how is no one hired now affiliated with United?

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 12:40 PM


Originally Posted by John Carr (Post 1834822)
Apologies.

Clarify, how is no one hired now affiliated with United?

No one hired since the merger (now) is affiliated with L-UAL. They are only affiliated with United.

SpecialTracking 03-01-2015 12:45 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834819)
The desk jockeys in the crystal palace. So lets stop giving them ammo.

I'm just going to let this one go. I think your history/experience in these matters speak for itself. What I really want to say is not for public consumption. Fly safe.

cal73 03-01-2015 12:57 PM

http://cdn.meme.am/instances/500x/56010360.jpg

Whats the topic of this thread?

Oh look Squirrel!!

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 01:03 PM


Originally Posted by SpecialTracking (Post 1834832)
I'm just going to let this one go. I think your history/experience in these matters speak for itself. What I really want to say is not for public consumption. Fly safe.

Not sure what I said to upset you, but I'm a big believer in learning from our past. So if I need to learn something then PM me. That goes for everyone. I'm not trying to start a fight in fact I'm trying to prevent fights.

SpecialTracking 03-01-2015 01:24 PM

Master,

I'm not upset and would be more than happy to share a cockpit and buy you a beer on a layover. You're better served by witnessing yourself versus reading an anonymous post/pm on a public forum.

pilotgolfer 03-01-2015 01:24 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834691)
A year and a half. And all I have is the SOP as it was taught to me. I will fly it whether you like it or not. If I feel like a procedure is unsafe I will email the flight department or file an FSAP.

I want the NEW United to succeed because I have so much invested here. I hope to still be here when all of you are long retired. The people hired now have no affiliation with United, Continental, NY Air, Texas International, Frontier #1, Peoples Express, PanAM, Eastern, Braniff, TWA.......

The experience of the pilots I have flown with is amazing and I have, and will, continue to learn form that experience. But this holding on to the "old" way or not following the SOP because its stupid is not ok with me. The way it used to be done was perfectly safe but its not how its done now.

Don't you think we are doing the new hires a dis service by n
ot following the SOP they have less than 100 hrs flying under? What are we teaching these new guys/gals?

MOP,
Can you give me a specific example of an SOP that you have seen violated? You've been speaking in such generalities. I want to know an example so I can put it on a scale of Importance from 1-10. And I'm not saying one SOP is any more/less important than another. I just need a baseline to figure out to what degree the sky is falling.

Are we talking verbiage like Level change vs. FLCH...
Record keeping on the master flight plan...
Stabilized approaches...
MCP manipulation...
A checklist challenge / response
Which FMC page to have up for FP/NFP
What is it?

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 01:56 PM


Originally Posted by pilotgolfer (Post 1834866)
MOP,
Can you give me a specific example of an SOP that you have seen violated? You've been speaking in such generalities. I want to know an example so I can put it on a scale of Importance from 1-10. And I'm not saying one SOP is any more/less important than another. I just need a baseline to figure out to what degree the sky is falling.

Are we talking verbiage like Level change vs. FLCH...
Record keeping on the master flight plan...
Stabilized approaches...
MCP manipulation...
A checklist challenge / response
Which FMC page to have up for FP/NFP
What is it?

Check your PMs. A public forum is not the place to list specific examples. I have been speaking in generalities for this reason.

pilotgolfer 03-01-2015 04:35 PM


Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1834890)
Check your PMs. A public forum is not the place to list specific examples. I have been speaking in generalities for this reason.

I never got it...did you confuse me with pilot64golfer?

Blockoutblockin 03-01-2015 05:28 PM


Originally Posted by pilotgolfer (Post 1834866)
MOP,
Can you give me a specific example of an SOP that you have seen violated? You've been speaking in such generalities. I want to know an example so I can put it on a scale of Importance from 1-10. And I'm not saying one SOP is any more/less important than another. I just need a baseline to figure out to what degree the sky is falling.

Are we talking verbiage like Level change vs. FLCH...
Record keeping on the master flight plan...
Stabilized approaches...
MCP manipulation...
A checklist challenge / response
Which FMC page to have up for FP/NFP
What is it?

LMAO you left out "WHOA Dude really", or "***, I got the jet", or "Are you intentionally trying to **** me off"

MasterOfPuppets 03-01-2015 07:28 PM


Originally Posted by Blockoutblockin (Post 1835006)
LMAO you left out "WHOA Dude really", or "***, I got the jet", or "Are you intentionally trying to **** me off"

HAHA now thats funny


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:08 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands