I got to say i agree with comet. I started flying older 172s and when I had to end up changing flight schools the newer shiny 172s felt heavy and clunky. I did not feel the same flight control sensitivity as the older models. So then I want to fly their cherokee which I ended up loving more. Much more comfy.

If you do want a nice responsive aircraft I do recommend you try a diamond aircraft. Damn thing is a glider and does not want to come down without persuasion. Bit awkward at first flying stick but if you can fly a DA40 or DA42 you wont be dissapointed. The DA20 is ok just not very comfy for a tall and big guy like me.