Originally Posted by Bucking Bar

Carl,

All we & the Court can do is speculate as to intent. The most likely intent was that ALPA figured the deal was the best they could do. Further, the TWA MEC was in agreement at that time. They reversed position later and clearly have a financial incentive to do so. What ever incentive a tax free billion bucks might be ... .

ALPA gets sued because it has a responsibility. Those who have never had that responsibility probably do not appreciate the difficult burden it is.