Originally Posted by
sleepdoclv
The information that I posted is actually factual and based on information available to anyone at:
Guide for Aviation Medical Examiners
Though mostly black and white, there are some ambiguities which I have taken the time to research and clarify with the FAA. The fact remains that this is not going to go away, many unsuspecting pilots will get caught in the cross-hairs, the qualifications for "high risk of OSA" may not be as difficult to meet as you once thought (
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/...stionnaire.pdf), and many pilots will be at risk for a temporary lapse in the ability to fly. There are basically 2 options: 1) Roll the dice and hope for the best at your AME exam (to land in Group 3 or 4) and go through the motions as they have laid out if not, 2) proactively and truthfully screen yourself (using the same tools provided to the AME), make a plan for seeking diagnosis and treatment if indicated by the risk assessment, and find a way to do it in the least disruptive way possible to minimize down time. That being said, I will under no circumstance advise a pilot to continue flying once a true diagnosis (via sleep study) is found and prior to effective treatment. I will, however, inform pilots that there are many ways to get from point A (risk evaluation) to point B (treatment) and by doing a little research, finding a physician with knowledge and experience in this unique circumstance, and taking control of the potential problem before it becomes an actual problem; the process can be far less frustrating, smoother, more efficient, and with little to no disruption in the ability to fly.
I think it's been quite clearly established that you have violated the TOS on this forum by posting to promote your own business and line your pockets. You may claim an altruistic reason, but it just doesn't appear that way.
I posted that some information you had posted and provided on your website was wrong. I fail to see where you've provided information contrary to my assertion.
In my post #2 on this thread, I provided the reader the complete AME guide provided by the FAA and you discounted this information, yet you post the link to the overall Guide and ask people to drill down to get the information I've provided.
If one goes to the AME informed, there is no "roll the dice" as you propose. If you truthfully don't have reports of apnea symptoms, don't report that you snore, don't report less than restful sleep, and don't have a BMI over 35, you are most certainly in the clear. The STOP BANG sheet you provide does come from the FAA materials, but as everyone can see if you're male, over 50, you would almost certainly think you'd be selected. But you fail to mention that the triage process is much more complicated that the single self-serving form you present. A history is to be taken, clinical observations etc. The FAA specifically references tables to be consulted, and a lot more that you let on. That taken overall overrides the fear mongering you are trying to provoke.
Let's take your point that you think you can smooth the flow by having pilots go to your fly in program and do a sleep study prior to their AME visit. If they do that prior to an AME visit, they have to report it. They will have to provide your complete workup/report to the AME/FAA. Do you think any pilot is crazy enough to do that? For a simple cold, go to a nutritionist and they will find a food problem with you, an ENT will find you need sinus surgery, you'll find a sleep problem is causing the cold, etc. Pilots don't take treadmill stress tests unless they HAVE to. Pilots don't take sleep studies unless they HAVE to. Whether a pilot finds a problem prior to their physical or afterwards, the paperwork and the process is virtually the same. Why put yourself in career jeopardy with you before one has to?
You also conveniently fail to mention that being put in category 5 by one's AME is a process that COULD result in a sleep study, not a process that WILL result in a sleep study. There is a heck of a lot of stuff that goes into the determination of what is needed once a pilot is put in high risk/category 5. Being put in a high risk category by the AME flow chart is NOT a certain need for a sleep study--as much as you would like to convince potential clients otherwise. You fail to mention the Epworth Sleepiness Scale and the Berlin Questionnaire which often provide different results than the "Scary" STOP BANG assessment.
Let's take a look at the process--taken directly from the AME guide:
The AME while performing the triage function must conclude one of six possible
determinations. The AME is
not required to perform the assessment or to comment on
the presence or absence of OSA.
Step 1 -
Determine into which group (1-6) the airman falls.
Applicant Previously Assessed:
Group 1:
Has OSA diagnosis and is on Special Issuance. Reports to follow.
Group 2:
Has OSA diagnosis OR has had previous OSA assessment. NOT on
Special Issuance. Reports to follow.
Applicant Not at Risk:
Group 3:
Determined to NOT be at risk for OSA at this examination.
Applicant at Risk/Severity to be assessed:
Group 4:
Discuss OSA risk with airman and provide educational materials.
Group 5:
At risk for OSA. AASM sleep apnea assessment required.
Applicant Risk/Severity Extremely High:
Group 6:
Deferred. Immediate safety risk. AASM sleep apnea assessment
required. Reports to follow.
Step 2
Document findings in Block 60.
Step 3
Check appropriate triage box in the AME Action Tab.
Step 4
Issue, if otherwise qualified.
In assessing airmen for groups 4 and 5, the AME is expected to use their own clinical
judgment, using AASM information, when making the triage decision.
Some AMEs have voiced the desire to perform the OSA assessment.
While we do not recommend it, the AME may perform the OSA assessment provided that it is in
accordance with the clinical practice guidelines established by the American Academy
of Sleep Medicine.*
*If a sleep study is conducted, it must be interpreted by a sleep medicine specialist.
************************************************** ************************
Group 5 is what MAY lead people to a sleep study. Let's see what the FAA directs for those in group 5:
OBSTRUCTIVE SLEEP APNEA SPECIFICATION SHEET B
ASSESSMENT REQUEST
Due to your risk for Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA), and to review your eligibility to
have a medical certificate, you must provide the following information to the Aerospace Medical Certification Division (AMCD) or your Regional Flight Surgeons Office for review within 90 days:
A current OSA assessment in accordance with the American Academy of Sleep
Medicine (AASM) by your AME, personal physician, or a sleep medicine
specialist.
If it is determined that a sleep study is necessary, it must be either a Type I
laboratory polysomnography or a Type II (7 channel) unattended home sleep test
(HST) that provides comparable data and standards to laboratory diagnostic
testing.
It must be interpreted by a sleep medicine specialist and must
include diagnosis and recommendation(s) for treatment, if any.
If your sleep study is
positive for a sleep-related disorder, you may not exercise the privileges of your medical certificate until you provide:
A signed Airman Compliance with Treatment form or equivalent;
The results and interpretive report of your most recent sleep study; and
A current status report from your treating physician addressing compliance,
tolerance of treatment, and resolution of OSA symptoms.
If you are
not diagnosed with a sleep-related disorder or the study was negative
for a sleep-related disorder
, you may continue to exercise the privileges of your
medical certificate, but the evaluation report along with the results of any study, if
conducted, must be sent to the FAA at the address below. All information provided will
be reviewed and is subject to further FAA action.
In order to expedite the processing of your application, please submit the
aforementioned information
in one mailing using your reference number (PI, MID, or
APP ID).
************************************************** ******
How does your personal physician determine if a sleep study is needed:
History of findings that suggest increased risk of OSA include:
Hypertension requiring more than 2 medications for control or refractory hypertension
Type 2 Diabetes
Atrial fibrillation or nocturnal dysrhythmias
Congestive heart failure
Stroke
Pulmonary hypertension
Motor vehicle accidents, especially those associated with sleepiness/drowsiness
Under consideration for bariatric surgery
Symptoms that suggest an increased risk of OSA include:
Snoring
Daytime sleepiness
Witnessed apneas
Complaints of awakening with sensation of gasping or choking
Non-refreshing sleep
Frequent awakening (sleep fragmentation) or difficulty staying asleep (maintenance insomnia)
Morning headaches
Decreased concentration
Problems or difficulty with memory or memory loss
Irritability
Physical/clinical findings that suggest increased risk of OSA include:
High score on an OSA screening questionnaire (e.g., Berlin, Epworth)
Increased neck circumference (>17 inches in men, >16 inches in women)
A Modified Mallampati score of 3 or 4 (assessment of the oral cavity)
Retrognathia
Lateral peritonsilar narrowing
Macroglossia
Tonsillar hypertrophy
Elongated/enlarged uvula
High arched/narrow hard palate
Nasal abnormalities such as polyps, deviation and turbinate hypertrophy
Obesity (AASM guidelines)
And he will use the information in the AASM tables 2 and 3.
All a lot more complicated that you would lead people to believe. If you have a BMI of 35 or above and don't have hardly any of the findings above, your PCP may determine you don't need a sleep study. If you have a BMI of 35 or above, and you snore or have other major indicators, then you'll get a sleep study. But, in any case, either through what you propose prior to or after the AME visit, the result and process will be the same. So why take a chance on seeing you prior to the AME....it would be foolish!