I agree with that.....except "only". The 2005 West new-hire senior to the US Air guy with 17 years was shakin' what his mamma gave him until it became apparent that the windfall was not actually binding. So I guess we are in agreement. And I applaud the AAA guys in their litigation and not accepting " I thought binding was binding". Anytime a pilot who has sacrificed for a company for almost 2 decades is stapled, it does a dis-justice to the profession. BTW, I think DOH would have been a windfall too. Godspeed AAA!