I am still not getting answers.

What was the value, if any ALPA assigned to the concessions?

Who requested the 1E9 language ALPA or management?

Who originated the threat of 3B4 avoidance ALPA or management?

Your refusal to answer speaks volumes. We are all aware of the 8% we are missing how much have we retained by not giving concessions? Is 3B4 still in effect?