I looked again after reading Lag's post and I still do not see that flight. Lag is right for some reason when looking for EWR-PHX all options do not seem to show up, I never knew that. Looking again there is a 2:55am IND-PHX Md-11 on Wednesday 9 November morning at 2:55 am.
The 10:25pm ERW-IND is an Airbus that would get you to Indy for that flight.
Again, I'm not sure what that sequence did not show up in my initial search.