Originally Posted by
rickair7777
In order to give instrument training which is logged as instrument dual received and counts toward the required dual training, you must have a CFII. There is only one exception: A CFI may provide the instrument instruction required for a PPL.
.
Just a stipulation of wording rick but technically that training being given for a PPL if administered by a CFI is considered 'Flight by reference to instruments" which is not instrument training. Meaning that it can not be used to meet the requirments of an Instrument rating, which requires instrument training. Like a said, a mere wording change, but other than that you were correct.