AA would never agree to A1 due to the effect on revenue management. As a side item, APA would probably throw a fit about regional pilots getting “must rides” for commuting.

A12 is the standard business travel pass for employees who travel for work. You are commuting...not deadheading. A12 is the appropriate pass classification for this travel purpose (actually, non-rev is normal so this would be considered a perk).

Of the many things people can complain about, I’m not sure this is one of them.