Thread: SKYW Stock
View Single Post
Old 11-13-2007 | 06:04 PM
  #40  
Airsupport
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2,356
Likes: 0
From: CRJ
Default

Originally Posted by dontsurf
now you're just wasting time. you can't read, apparently. nowhere in those "beginners" articles did it say "a company buys back stock because it always makes the price go up" or "stock price always goes up when a company buys back its stock". re-read what i said. you obviously didn't read what i said, nor do you know anything about me. anyone that has to look up stuff on "beginner" websites certainly doesn't have experience doing what i used to do for a living. you don't even know what a series 55 is, do you? oh, well, i guess you can look that up on a "beginner" website too.

anyway, my point was and is that there's a couple of guys here who look at skywest inc. buying back stock as such an evil thing, and that's not true. that the only reason they do it is to make themselves richer. that it's guaranteed that anytime a company buys back stock the stock price goes up. none of those things are ALWAYS true. does the stock price sometimes go up if a company buys back stock? yes, it does. but it's not BECAUSE they are buying the stock back. it's not simple causation. if you've ever made a market in an OTC stock, then come talk to me. otherwise, quit being so simplistic. and i'd suggest actually reading the articles you post. i read them, and they are right in all aspects, though not complete, and they clearly point out what management HOPES to accomplish by a stock buyback. what you have to remember is that the stock market runs on expectations...expectations of the investors, of analysts, etc. NOT on expectations or hopes of management of any company. again, if that's all it took to make a stock go up, we'd see stock buybacks every single day. i'm tired of this. i was just trying to educate a couple of people on here that have wildly simplistic views on how the investment markets and corporate finance work. i know you don't know anything about it, and that's fine. no one is born knowing this stuff. but learn a little before you go saying things that make it obvious you've never done this for a living.

The reason I was being simplistic is because you didn't seem to understand that buying back stock can, and usually does in a stable company poised for growth, cause the price to increase. Yes those are beginner websites, once again because after reading your post I was under the impression you knew nothing about stock repurchase programs and therefore needed some reading material to help you understand.

Now I will address your comments. First you are right, some people on this site feel that a stock repurchase is "evil". I however do not agree with that, and apparently you don't either. And I never said that stock repurchase always makes a stock price go up. If a company is sinking and it buys back its stock, it is still worthless (a sinking company would almost never buy its own stock back, they would prefer to send people packing with nothing). I don't feel skywest is a sinking ship, and neither do the investors, (more planes coming on board, better revenue, and good performance bode well for skywest right now) and by them buying stock back they have increased their market value, and in turn have made their own personal stock more valuable.

You don't have to do this for a living to be good at it. I do quite well, and my portfolio would be proof of that. Sorry if you got all huffed up because 2 people on this message board said that buying stock back causes the price to go up, which actually is spot on with the company we were both referring to. Can you argue that we were wrong by saying that when skywest bought their stock back the price didn't go up?? Glad we could have a decent discussion.
Reply