I knew a few guys at both and Atlas. Most left both for United, FedEx, UPS, and Delta, but a couple are still there. Those who are still there, it fits their lifestyle (single guy, married no kids, married with kids and two sets of healthy grandparents nearby).

3.5 years is a long time. Omni and Kalitta could probably get you to other majors faster as you add more ratings and international flying to your resume. They also pay better than Envoy. As long as you have 1000 PIC at Envoy, the only other box checking that can really be done here is LCA.

Where you are at, it's a tough call. Your QOL here will get better each month as you are reaching the top part of the seniority list.

However, since you are senior to me, you should probably take the CJO.