View Single Post
Old 10-18-2021 | 10:18 AM
  #13  
MosquitoXEL
Line Holder
 
Joined: Jan 2014
Posts: 29
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by TiredSoul
MosquitoXEL
From back in my days as CFI:
We had a nearby Class C airport with a Class D airport tucked under the C shelf kinda in its armpit to give you a visual.
DPE favorite especially with foreign students to do a touch and go at the Class D.
ATC controller would generally cancel radar service and tell you to squawk VFR when handing you off to the D TWR.
Which means you’d be better off doing a full stop taxi back and coordinate with TWR or GND freq for a transponder code outbound.
Otherwise you’d have to stay below 1200’ while contacting C getting a code and explaining which way you want to go while maintaining your 1000’ above the highest obstacle.
So the solution was:

1. Coordinate with C controller to keep the code for your outbound and just having to establish radio contact after release from D TWR, or
2. If for what ever reason you couldn’t make that work ( frequency congestion etc ) do a full stop taxi back to coordinate the outbound and tell the DPE that you can’t comply with his request for a touch and go.

I’ve even had Commercial applicants on stage checks bugger that one up.
Thats why your story kinda sounded familiar.
Best of luck.
Sounds identical to my situation here. I brought this up to my peers and chief CFI at a recent meeting. No one was really sure if a regulation was broken during this incident. However, moving forward I will stress the importance of descending below the class C shelf to my students. It doesn’t seem like a good idea to me to be in class C without talking to ATC. I personally doubt anything will come of this since the supervisor didn’t get my information and I filed a NASA just in case. Lesson learned.
Reply