I guess we have a bunch of lawyers stating a case on a web forum. Let me know how the web forum courts rule. Then lets see how the real courts rule. They are the ones who matter.

I have also seen numerous doctor pilots with internet articles as case studies. In the doctor world the running joke is a doctor willing to take a position on anything in any manner is easy to find if money is involved. Many credentialed doctors have different opinions on numerous things medical related. They are humans with opinions also. So saying “a doctor says” doesn’t mean anything. Its all about perspective.