Originally Posted by
Theoden9
Do these company psychiatrists have a good track record? Such that we should trust their judgement? Psychology does not exactly have a great record when it’s been put to the test. I worked with numerous ex-military guys who were new FOs at the regional who had lost the CJO in this way. Every one of them was a GREAT FO, cared about pax, FAs, was likeable etc. I thought to myself “What the hell are the Psych’s seeing?”
Actually, no. Barring people who are actively hallucinating at the time of the interview, psych evaluations have exceedingly poor reproducibility, far less validity.
https://discovery.dundee.ac.uk/ws/fi...IENCE_2015.pdf
https://bmcpsychiatry.biomedcentral....888-019-2171-y
https://replicationindex.com/2022/01...e-in-2021/?amp