Originally Posted by tupues

well no, because then I would have gotten his seat in the back. It’s not like I would have been left behind and the plane would have left with a vacant seat if he hadn’t offered “his” JS.

As the other poster was saying, I’d expect them to fill the cabin first before the JS gets given out by the cpt. Logically, if he takes the JS before the cabin is full then I get his seat in the cabin, and if he offers me the JS and takes the cabin seat then that’s what would have happened anyway. Finally if it’s completely full I wouldn’t have gotten on anyway. It’s not like he will actually sacrifice anything or be exceptionally generous as he actually has no control over this.