Originally Posted by Roy Biggins

Exactly. And the fact that ALPA attorneys felt like there was enough there to warrant arbitration tells you it’s a non standard agreement.
Side note: we’ve got actual line pilots (I just flew with one) who think ALPA shouldn’t be doing anything to “upset” this agreement because it’s good for us. I sh!t you not. Rank and file who are ok with management wiping their a$$ with our contract after years of corporate malfeasance. These same guys are ready and willing to take concessions. I wish I was joking. Nice guy, but I had to hide my utter contempt for his views on our career.