Originally Posted by
250 or point 65
FURTHERMORE, I can take a private pilot up to show him a takeoff, pattern, and landing and HE can log PIC if he never touches the controls because Dual given as a private is PIC.
I disagree. What is your authority for such a statement?
1. The sole manipulator of the controls can log PIC (whether or not he/she is PIC) if rated in the A/C. [61.51(e)(1)]
2. An appropriately rated CFI giving dual can log PIC (whether or not he/she is PIC). [61.51(e)(3)]
3. An ATP can log PIC in an ATP operation if he/she is PIC. [61.51(e)(2)]