Regarding RR... I remember it being used for saab guys right after 9/11 because we were all of a sudden over staffed. It hadn't been used since, because we were chronically understaffed. And now, since we're properly staffed, they use it. I hate doing just like you, but it's there. Just because it hadn't been used very often in the past, doesn't mean they can't use it when staffing permits. Sorry man, but I don't buy the people would have taken different paths bit, just because RR wasn't used in the past. Again, it was in the contract, black and white. That's something we'll never get rid of. If anything, perhaps we can just improve the language. It's not something worth fighting for... I'd much rather expend negotiating capital on better things like FO pay, better hotel language etc...

Let's hope that what's going on now, is just a blip on the radar screen and a bump in the road. After getting trashed for 6 years, I'm skeptical, but will remain optimistic. I'm just not convinced our good days are over.