I would watch it for a couple months before switching. Sounds like a good sked in NY, but make sure you could hold it consistently. Even a short commute takes a huge amount of time and frustration. Personally, I would stay on reserve, but the money can be an important issue. Each person's situation is different. I commuted the whole time I flew 121 (family reasons), and sweated out each trip - riding my own company with 2-4 JS's per aircraft. I had a two leg trip, though. Not sure where you're living, but how about driving into NY? At least it makes a good back up.

Good luck.