Originally Posted by
USMCFLYR
I had around 400 hours of GA time and my ratings (except for any instructor rating) prior to coming to the military side. I will agree with you that the first 400 hours of my military training was different - more intense. I mean - bombing, dogfighting, low levels at 300-540kts at 200-500', or CARRIER QUALIFICATION - day and night!!!! Of course no civilian training is going to touch that extreme.
But I'll tell you what - - I'll put up a Commercial Pilot with instrument rating who is going for his CFI certification against that same freshly minted FRS aviator in the area of some basic aviation knowledge (pick any of the FAA writtens) and even the PPL would probably eat him alive!
Just remember this.....the airplane (in my community) is nothing more than a flying weapons system. We military pilots are NOT professional pilots. I don't get paid to fly. I get paid for being a Marine - flying is just what I do when Uncle Sam needs some attitudes readjusted

If I want someone to take off from an expeditionary airfield at night and conduct a self-escorted strike on NVGs; then I'll chose the military trained pilot. If I want someone to get me safely from DFW to LAX in IMC, then that 25 y/o, 1000 hr "child" is better suited to be flying my family around in an RJ anyday (as part of well trained and coordinated crew) - IMO.
USMCFLYR
Speaking of intensity of training...one could probaly make an easy argument that the firehouse in the mouth method employed by the military is not the most inducive to learning way of doing things.
DISCLAIMER, I am in no way saying that i know how to better train a military pilot than the military. They have been doing it a long time with great success.
In my civilian training the pace was what i wanted it to be. I was allowed time to injest and dijest. I get the feeling that luxory is not always there in military training.
I would bet money...not a lot 'cause i aint that confident in the vager...that at 250 hours as a civilian I had more chance to learn more at the correlation level than a military pilot with the same hours.
Miliage varies obviously. Some guys i'm sure really rocket up in a military environment. The method just isn't for everyone.