Originally Posted by
The dude
I don't think stalling a part 121 passenger carrying turbo prop is a "mistake". A mistake is dialing a wrong frequency, a wrong inbound course, a missed fix in a flight plan etc...
I think the issue is the airlines' (especially the regionals) tendency to push people through training who don't have the necessary stick and rudder and/or judgment skills to safely operate a complex aircraft. I've seen it with my own eyes numerous times as a former regional guy.
I'm not necessarily saying this particular crew was skill-deficient, but the scenario does point that direction.
I agree. When I came off of regional airline training I didn't really know how to keep the airplane from stalling at the FAF approach speed... The crew was skilled enough. The CA came from the saab and was just out of 400 training. The FO supposedly had prior Dash8 experince before colgan. Let's wait before blaming us lowly regional pilots.