DL I see your arguments and at some level I agree with them, but I feel the free exchange of ideas concerning the next CBA overrides the downside. As long as people don't start drawing lines in the sand on this forum, or stating what they will or won't accept, then many of the previous ideas are very thought provoking and may not have been thought of by many. We each have our pet peeves with the CBA.
I hear what you're saying Bitme and I don't disagree completely, my gut just tells me that our natures will lead to those lines being drawn. Look at our discussions on the other thread about the idea of caps. That got to a level that even involved one of our reps giving his opinion.