Originally Posted by
rickair7777
Basically, students are not as helpless or as ignorant as the public, so they don't need the same protections.
I'm not so sure about that. Maybe not =as= ignorant and helpless but you don't have to spend much time on an internet forum where students ask a lot of questions to see just how little they understand the process they are in.
Personally, I think that the difference is a difference in the FAA's view of instructors. The FAA trusts them when giving instruction - from lower medical certificate requirements to allowing even allows a CFI to take a student for his first night flight without being night-current. There's also probably less potential for profit-motive-based abuse in the instructional setting where payment is based on one student at a time than there is even in non-Part 135 commercial sightseeing tours.