Theoretically, this would be in place to prevent pilots from talking too much. What it will really do is push pilots to talk TOO LITTLE.........which can be just as dangerous. Effective communication is critical and this will stifle that very requirement for safe operation of aircraft.
If my conversations and comments are going to be monitored, I'll give them what they want and be the quietest pilot out there. Unfortunately, I'd be better and safer if I could speak freely.
This will be another example of something that sounds good on paper, but results in as many new problems as old ones supposedly solved.
Idiots.