Those are personal opinions based on what's important to you individually. I assume you've both worked here?

My opinion is that Eagle is a decent place to work if you value things other than rapid turbine PIC accumulation. I have passed on other opportunities and continue to do so because Eagle allows me some QOL that I wouldn't get elsewhere. Maybe I'm just severely dain bramaged, but having worked for a number of airlines I do think I have a clue.

Bottom line is that each person needs to view any given position from the perspective of how it works for them.