Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   American (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/)
-   -   APA Fails to Raise the Bar (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/143937-apa-fails-raise-bar.html)

CRJCapitan 07-30-2023 05:44 AM


Originally Posted by Thatsapproved (Post 3674944)
I don’t get why people are so upset about the 2.0. I’m okay with living on coattails. Its
like college. I’d rather cheat of the smart kid then spend valuable drinking time studying lol

If you’re being serious…not the attitude we want to have lol

NERD 07-30-2023 06:36 AM

Braniff Christmas?




Originally Posted by aa73 (Post 3674852)
APA’s structure, governance and bylaws are what hampers its ability to secure ILCs. Period, dot, end of sentence. It has nothing to do with AA pilots running it, or former US, or former AW, or whoever. You could have an army of the smartest pilots in charge of fixing it but they will fall flat on their faces - and they have over the years I’ve been here - simply due to the almost autonomous and absolute power the BOD has over everybody else in the union, including the NOs. At the end of the day, we live and die by the BOD’s actions. The ONLY time APA has made gains is when the membership itself has revolted or acted on its own against its leadership. (Braniff Christmas, Sept to Remember, etc.)
When a union only makes gains when its membership revolts, you’ve got a deeply flawed union.
There is indeed one way to fix APA. Schitt can it and replace it with ALPA.
Until that happens, we will trail the industry. It’s really that simple. The ILCs happening everywhere today except APA is proof.
AA pilots have been ham strung by APA for DECADES. It’s like being in a bad marriage with no way out. If you want to fault AA pilots, fault them for not going back to ALPA a lot sooner. Unfortunately, AA pilots have been “institutionalized” by APA’s actions over the decades and part of that has become ingrained in their DNA. That’ll take a while to purge, but it is possible - through a fresh start with ALPA.

I’ll end my rant with one more example of the BOD’s antics and why this union is so broken. Last spring, the ALPA exploratory committee actually RECOMMENDED to the BOD that, in their view, the next step in exploring an ALPA merger needed to proceed, based on their extensive research. In other words, the very committee that the BOD appointed to explore a merger with ALPA recommended we take the next step. And the BOD shot down ITS OWN COMMITTEE’S RECOMMENDATIONS immediately as the panic set in that their days might be numbered. Now, what does that tell you as to the question if APA can be fixed?


170Till5 07-30-2023 07:08 AM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 3674934)
okay buddy. I guess it’s just hard for you to fathom that your airline’s management and your union lag the industry. Enjoy contract 2.0 or 3.0 or 3.5 or whatever it is.

A lot of the pilots there were content and lazy waiting to flow.. Their contract exemplifies the same laziness

beancounter 07-30-2023 08:09 AM


Originally Posted by Varks (Post 3674654)
I’ll take our sick any day. Somehow doing only 4 day trips I have accumulated over 500 hours sick time. It can be done.

Does Delta have annual cost of living adjustments to LTD? Yes it gets 401k.

stop cherry picking. This will be the best contract of my career.

Yeah, I built up hundreds of hours of sick time on the narrow body, because I was only flying 12-13 days a month and the trips were good. The new guys now will never see that, because they’re flying garbage trips, 16 days a month, and getting pounded into the ground. Very few of them I talk to have any sick time, it’s impossible to accumulate it.

KNIFE06 07-30-2023 08:21 AM


Originally Posted by JulesWinfield (Post 3674931)
There’s an imax compass guide. Read that.

Yes I’ve read it. It’s only 8 pages and is clearly written for someone familiar with the subject and not on reserve, the FAQ don’t address my questions. Hence why I asked for someone more versed in the subject to opine.

FYI: “go read a compass manual” is actually not helpful advice, nor does it answer the question. Cheers.

CRJdriver2017 07-30-2023 08:43 AM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 3674849)
Delta has been and will continue paying for jets with cash. Go read their 10K’s…

Serious question because I see a common trend with Delta guys….do y’all have Delta posters in your rooms? Do y’all have weekly meetings where you sit in a big groups and talk about how much more awesome y’all are than others?

LBFO79 07-30-2023 08:53 AM


Originally Posted by CRJdriver2017 (Post 3675042)
Serious question because I see a common trend with Delta guys….do y’all have Delta posters in your rooms? Do y’all have weekly meetings where you sit in a big groups and talk about how much more awesome y’all are than others?

just because he is stating facts, does not make him a delta nerd

delta is better run, makes more money, has happier employees, has more pilots, and a much better contract. It’s unfortunately our reality because of how poor our airline and union are run.

StoneQOLdCrazy 07-30-2023 08:57 AM


Originally Posted by Dolphinflyer (Post 3674868)
No, I'm not going to do your assigned homework. I think DAL does a better job but still has to replace AC.

If you think paying cash for AC is a plan, you're dead and don't even know it.

Ask the NWA old guys about old NWA and the Checchi. Should be a good primer for all cash fleet.

Rules for leveraged buyouts have changed, bud.

But I’m sure you knew that.

maybe worry less about what another management team’s plan is, and more about raising the bar.

if, in fact, AA is on the tail end of its massive debt pay down , then it should have been even easier to raise the bar.

CRJCapitan 07-30-2023 09:34 AM


Originally Posted by StoneQOLdCrazy (Post 3675049)

maybe worry less about what another management team’s plan is, and more about raising the bar.

In his defense, you are the one commenting on another airline’s thread. You, along with the thread starter, started this whole thing unprovoked…

ImSoSuss 07-30-2023 10:30 AM


Originally Posted by Varks (Post 3674654)
I’ll take our sick any day. Somehow doing only 4 day trips I have accumulated over 500 hours sick time. It can be done.

Does Delta have annual cost of living adjustments to LTD? Yes it gets 401k.

stop cherry picking. This will be the best contract of my career.

How many have you accumulated since COVID and the optimizer?

ImSoSuss 07-30-2023 10:34 AM


Originally Posted by MCDUmanipulator (Post 3674673)
will solve absolutely nothing. Ask spirit guys how alpa did for them on the latest contract.

They did pretty good considering it was supposed to just be a bridge until the JetBlue JCBA. Why don't you ask Spirit pilots how well ALPA did when they negotiated their industry leading QOL contract a few years ago?

ImSoSuss 07-30-2023 10:41 AM


Originally Posted by beancounter (Post 3675020)
Yeah, I built up hundreds of hours of sick time on the narrow body, because I was only flying 12-13 days a month and the trips were good. The new guys now will never see that, because they’re flying garbage trips, 16 days a month, and getting pounded into the ground. Very few of them I talk to have any sick time, it’s impossible to accumulate it.

^^^^^ This right here. Accumulating sick time is not a thing anymore.

StoneQOLdCrazy 07-30-2023 11:59 AM


Originally Posted by CRJCapitan (Post 3675062)
In his defense, you are the one commenting on another airline’s thread. You, along with the thread starter, started this whole thing unprovoked…

oh, it most certainly was provoked. By APA's pathetic display of unionism and discombobulated lack of leadership. ****ing freeloaders.

CRJCapitan 07-30-2023 12:11 PM


Originally Posted by StoneQOLdCrazy (Post 3675140)
oh, it most certainly was provoked. By APA's pathetic display of unionism and discombobulated lack of leadership. ****ing freeloaders.

You do realize UALPA only started making serious progress with United management after the AA AIP, right? But your revisionist history of what happened literally a month ago sounds better

P.S. And if you don’t believe me, go look at the United forum from back in April and May.

Montcalm 07-30-2023 12:22 PM


Originally Posted by CRJCapitan (Post 3675148)
You do realize UALPA only started making serious progress with United management after the AA AIP, right? But your revisionist history of what happened literally a month ago sounds better

P.S. And if you don’t believe me, go look at the United forum from back in April and May.

You do realize that it was massively voted down, right? They regrouped and knocked it out of the park. We miserably failed what, four times now?

These threads are getting absurd.

CRJCapitan 07-30-2023 12:28 PM


Originally Posted by Montcalm (Post 3675159)
You do realize that it was massively voted down, right? They regrouped and knocked it out of the park. We miserably failed what, four times now?

These threads are getting absurd.

What are you talking about? AA came out with the most recent AIP on 5/19 and, up until that point, UA pilots were talking on their forum about how little progress that had made in their negotiations. No one will take the time and go back and read the threads, but they’re there.

I don’t care about their TUMI TA if that’s what you’re talking about.

aa73 07-30-2023 01:46 PM


Originally Posted by NERD (Post 3674963)
Braniff Christmas?

Back in the 1981/1982ish time frame, just before Braniff went under… AA management desperately needed more lift at DFW over the Christmas holidays. Behind the union’s back, they negotiated a quick deal with Braniff to carry AA passengers on AA routes using the AA code. The morning it was scheduled to start, a bunch of AA Captains maneuvered their aircraft after pushback to park and block every Braniff pushback at DFW. They shut em down that morning. The deal was called off immediately afterwards. Obviously I wasn’t around back then but from what I’ve been told, it was a coordinated secret grass roots effort at the membership level that enabled that to happen.

StoneQOLdCrazy 07-30-2023 02:17 PM


Originally Posted by CRJCapitan (Post 3675148)
You do realize UALPA only started making serious progress with United management after the AA AIP, right? But your revisionist history of what happened literally a month ago sounds better

P.S. And if you don’t believe me, go look at the United forum from back in April and May.

revisionist history? This is happening right now. You had like 3 chances to exceed industry leading and you only matched every time.

no one in the industry is interested in your candy-ass excuses. But hey, as long as you can convince yourself.

ACEssXfer 07-30-2023 02:43 PM


Originally Posted by StoneQOLdCrazy (Post 3675210)
revisionist history? This is happening right now. You had like 3 chances to exceed industry leading and you only matched every time.

no one in the industry is interested in your candy-ass excuses. But hey, as long as you can convince yourself.

Did we match though? Isom has claimed the new new AA AIP is worth 9 billion. The UAL AIP is 10+ billion.

Armyguy 07-30-2023 02:50 PM

IMAX is all the empty nesters say over and over.

If it was so great for everybody then more pilots would be IMAXing yet they aren't. There is a reason for that.

Bunch of senior idiots at this company

MCDUmanipulator 07-30-2023 03:22 PM


Originally Posted by ImSoSuss (Post 3675094)
They did pretty good considering it was supposed to just be a bridge until the JetBlue JCBA. Why don't you ask Spirit pilots how well ALPA did when they negotiated their industry leading QOL contract a few years ago?

Ask the 30% that voted no. Just like the 30% that will vote no here.

StoneQOLdCrazy 07-30-2023 03:24 PM


Originally Posted by ACEssXfer (Post 3675225)
Did we match though? Isom has claimed the new new AA AIP is worth 9 billion. The UAL AIP is 10+ billion.

Good point. I stand corrected.

TransWorld 07-30-2023 03:50 PM

As Sen. Everett Derksen famously said, a billion here, a billion there. soon you are talking about real money.

Dolphinflyer 07-30-2023 03:57 PM


Originally Posted by Armyguy (Post 3675231)
IMAX is all the empty nesters say over and over.

If it was so great for everybody then more pilots would be IMAXing yet they aren't. There is a reason for that.

Bunch of senior idiots at this company

Yes and No, anything without family obligations makes airline scheduling easier in life, IMAX or not.

More and more pilots are IMAXing, there is a reason for that, they are learning from others and just starting. Others simply don't give a crap about anything and can't be bothered to learn anything about the contract to improve their lives, more than a few over the years have had their spouses bid for them or leave money on the table every day.

Claiming some vague "there's a reason for that" is pure ignorance and stupidity, but no surprise to hear.

If you wonder where senior idiots come from, just upgrade.

Dolphinflyer 07-30-2023 04:06 PM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 3674934)
okay buddy. I guess it’s just hard for you to fathom that your airline’s management and your union lag the industry. Enjoy contract 2.0 or 3.0 or 3.5 or whatever it is.

Try not to live up the expected behavior of your past posts. Yes, I've read 10K's about airline finances about how it can affect our careers and I simply pointed out a FACT that may or may not concern you, that paying off and having no debt in the business is bad news. You may be aware of the risk, good.

I mentioned Checchi and NWA? Ring a bell. Where were you when it happened? I was reading the financial info about the fallout of a low debt company getting screwed.

Congrats on getting hired at DAL. Hopefully they can manage the CAPEX for the 757/767 replacement cost.

Armyguy 07-30-2023 04:24 PM


Originally Posted by Dolphinflyer (Post 3675260)
Yes and No, anything without family obligations makes airline scheduling easier in life, IMAX or not.

More and more pilots are IMAXing, there is a reason for that, they are learning from others and just starting. Others simply don't give a crap about anything and can't be bothered to learn anything about the contract to improve their lives, more than a few over the years have had their spouses bid for them or leave money on the table every day.

Claiming some vague "there's a reason for that" is pure ignorance and stupidity, but no surprise to hear.

If you wonder where senior idiots come from, just upgrade.

i will admit that was a good burn at the end. Well played sir

Dolphinflyer 07-30-2023 04:33 PM


Originally Posted by Armyguy (Post 3675281)
i will admit that was a good burn at the end. Well played sir

Didn't mean a personal insult to you, I spent close to 2 decades in the right seat wondering where some of these clueless company senior hacks came from( majority guys were great)

Then I upgraded and saw the clueless company hacks in the right seat (again outside majority of good guys and gals)

Best to both our careers

FangsF15 07-30-2023 05:00 PM


Originally Posted by ACEssXfer (Post 3675225)
Did we match though? Isom has claimed the new new AA AIP is worth 9 billion. The UAL AIP is 10+ billion.

"Overall value" isn't the gauge. Isom himself is on video saying he was prepared to "match" DL. It's totally disingenuous to say AA didn't match DL, then UA on the vast majority of the bullet points, including pay tables to the penny. It's one long list of "me too" snap-ups.

Hueypilot 07-30-2023 05:28 PM


Originally Posted by Dolphinflyer (Post 3675260)
Yes and No, anything without family obligations makes airline scheduling easier in life, IMAX or not.

More and more pilots are IMAXing, there is a reason for that, they are learning from others and just starting. Others simply don't give a crap about anything and can't be bothered to learn anything about the contract to improve their lives, more than a few over the years have had their spouses bid for them or leave money on the table every day.

Claiming some vague "there's a reason for that" is pure ignorance and stupidity, but no surprise to hear.

If you wonder where senior idiots come from, just upgrade.

I have kids at home, and I'm running into IMAX, although accidentally. Just been running my PPROJ up as high as I can tolerate in order to pay for a home under construction that always seems to be going over budget! Can't wait to slow down once it's completed, however.

PRS Guitars 07-30-2023 06:20 PM


Originally Posted by Hueypilot (Post 3675306)
I have kids at home, and I'm running into IMAX, although accidentally. Just been running my PPROJ up as high as I can tolerate in order to pay for a home under construction that always seems to be going over budget! Can't wait to slow down once it's completed, however.

Thats the thing about IMAX, you’d be way better off getting a spread sheet and running a game-plan than just high flying. High flying alone will get you in IMAX hell, the negative side of IMAX where you get limited to about 75 hours and no free time off. Consider speaking with some experts.

CRJJ 07-30-2023 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by PRS Guitars (Post 3675328)
Thats the thing about IMAX, you’d be way better off getting a spread sheet and running a game-plan than just high flying. High flying alone will get you in IMAX hell, the negative side of IMAX where you get limited to about 75 hours and no free time off. Consider speaking with some experts.

I’m still in training but I’ve been learning IMAX from my best friend, and I can tell at this point that the difference between mastering IMAX or not must be the difference between happy and miserable/I hate AA type of pilots. Looks like literally two different jobs.

CRJCapitan 07-30-2023 06:37 PM


Originally Posted by FangsF15 (Post 3675298)
"Overall value" isn't the gauge. Isom himself is on video saying he was prepared to "match" DL. It's totally disingenuous to say AA didn't match DL, then UA on the vast majority of the bullet points, including pay tables to the penny. It's one long list of "me too" snap-ups.

Thank you for your reasonable take.

Dolphinflyer 07-30-2023 06:42 PM


Originally Posted by Hueypilot (Post 3675306)
I have kids at home, and I'm running into IMAX, although accidentally. Just been running my PPROJ up as high as I can tolerate in order to pay for a home under construction that always seems to be going over budget! Can't wait to slow down once it's completed, however.

No matter what, kids are primary.
You can get sucked into the ultimate "nirvana" IMAX goal, but don't sacrifice time with them for it.

PRS Guitars 07-30-2023 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by CRJJ (Post 3675331)
I’m still in training but I’ve been learning IMAX from my best friend, and I can tell at this point that the difference between mastering IMAX or not must be the difference between happy and miserable/I hate AA type of pilots. Looks like literally two different jobs.

Not true, you don’t have to IMAX to get good QOL. Honestly, most important thing is learn the contract, learn the scheduling tools (PBS, TTS, DOTC), learn to analyze what you can do at your seniority using the PBS Award Report. Also use that report to choose your base if you commute and have options. Figure out the best way to bid a reserve schedule. I’ve flown with many CA’s, and surprisingly many FO’s that have no clue how to bid their schedule, they also don’t care about even trying to improve it.

CRJJ 07-30-2023 07:28 PM


Originally Posted by PRS Guitars (Post 3675339)
Not true, you don’t have to IMAX to get good QOL. Honestly, most important thing is learn the contract, learn the scheduling tools (PBS, TTS, DOTC), learn to analyze what you can do at your seniority using the PBS Award Report. Also use that report to choose your base if you commute and have options. Figure out the best way to bid a reserve schedule. I’ve flown with many CA’s, and surprisingly many FO’s that have no clue how to bid their schedule, they also don’t care about even trying to improve it.

What information do you get on that PBS award report ?

Montcalm 07-30-2023 07:36 PM


Originally Posted by CRJCapitan (Post 3675162)
What are you talking about? AA came out with the most recent AIP on 5/19 and, up until that point, UA pilots were talking on their forum about how little progress that had made in their negotiations. No one will take the time and go back and read the threads, but they’re there.

I don’t care about their TUMI TA if that’s what you’re talking about.

Yes, APA most definitely saved UALPA with our bottom of the industry TA1… 🤦🏻‍♂️

As I said. Absurd.

CRJCapitan 07-30-2023 08:03 PM


Originally Posted by Montcalm (Post 3675353)
Yes, APA most definitely saved UALPA with our bottom of the industry TA1… 🤦🏻‍♂️

As I said. Absurd.

Sequence of events last eight months:

1) December 2022- Delta sets new industry standard with AIP
2) March 2023- Delta TA ratified
3) April 2023-Murmurs of progress/imminent AA deal, not nearly as much progress on UA side
4) May 2023- AA reaches AIP
5) Late May-June 2023- Murmurs of progress on UA side
6) July 2023- UA AIP

The point is not that the AA AIP was industry leading, it was industry matching at best. Having an agreement at all at AA did two things: it gave UALPA leverage because United was now the only one without a pilot agreement, and it gave SK an opportunity to show up RI. You really think the timing is a coincidence? There is little doubt in my mind much of the timing of the UA AIP was to mess with the vote of the AA TA and possibly send us down a potential path of mediation. This is something I felt would happen back in we came out with our AIP/TA. All of timing of what I stated above can be validated with a combination of Google searches and looking at UA threads on this site.

Right now, those in upper management at the legacies are playing chess and we are playing checkers. You have to read between the lines.

Montcalm 07-30-2023 08:45 PM


Originally Posted by CRJCapitan (Post 3675367)
Sequence of events last eight months:

1) December 2022- Delta sets new industry standard with AIP
2) March 2023- Delta TA ratified
3) April 2023-Murmurs of progress/imminent AA deal, not nearly as much progress on UA side
4) May 2023- AA reaches AIP
5) Late May-June 2023- Murmurs of progress on UA side
6) July 2023- UA AIP

The point is not that the AA AIP was industry leading, it was industry matching at best. Having an agreement at all at AA did two things: it gave UALPA leverage because United was now the only one without a pilot agreement, and it gave SK an opportunity to show up RI. You really think the timing is a coincidence? There is little doubt in my mind much of the timing of the UA AIP was to mess with the vote of the AA TA and possibly send us down a potential path of mediation. This is something I felt would happen back in we came out with our AIP/TA. All of timing of what I stated above can be validated with a combination of Google searches and looking at UA threads on this site.

Right now, those in upper management at the legacies are playing chess and we are playing checkers. You have to read between the lines.

Your persistence perplexes me. Airline management infightings aren't linked to our union's failure to keep up with the industry. You're confusing cause and effect.

It appears we lack your divine omniscience. All I witness are the perpetual failings of APA, time and time again, like a recurring bad joke.

PRS Guitars 07-30-2023 08:58 PM


Originally Posted by CRJJ (Post 3675350)
What information do you get on that PBS award report ?

the best thing to do is take a look at it, it’s found where you look at 3xp beta. It will show everybody’s pbs award (their schedule). It shows what layer they were awarded in. The trips are hyperlinked so you can look at the details. It shows everybody’s coverage days either none, or Line Holder (LH) or reserve (LC or SC). It shows what the reserve pilots bid…must off vs prefer off. It shows how many days off Line holders got, and their credit. It shows vacations and training. It shows Line holders TAFB. In general it shows percentages of line holder reserve, MALV etc.

You can look at historical data. I look at old December awards every year to gauge how pilots bid and gauge what I can hold as an example (holiday pay has completely changed bidding behavior though). Otherwise I just look back a month or 2. It can help you manage expectations and also not waste layers bidding stuff you won’t get.

AllYourBaseAreB 07-30-2023 09:04 PM


Originally Posted by FangsF15 (Post 3675298)
"Overall value" isn't the gauge. Isom himself is on video saying he was prepared to "match" DL. It's totally disingenuous to say AA didn't match DL, then UA on the vast majority of the bullet points, including pay tables to the penny. It's one long list of "me too" snap-ups.

For the money people, AA profit sharing will be a fraction of Delta’s due to not having a pilot only pool to payout from


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:56 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands