Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   American (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/)
-   -   Profit Sharing Plan Implemented (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/94089-profit-sharing-plan-implemented.html)

eaglefly 03-26-2016 04:27 AM


Originally Posted by Jetwash (Post 2096153)
Just so you know this PS give is for the entire employee group. I highly doubt this is meant to placate pilots. They aren't that stupid

Yes, I am aware of that. It was APA's "strongly worded letter" which got press attention, but the issue of lack of enthusiasm and a mediocre product is system wide. Parker can't just use this strategy with pilots only or it just alienates other work groups more, but neutering your primary vocal critic was a fundamental goal.

Jetwash 03-26-2016 04:36 AM


Originally Posted by eaglefly (Post 2096782)
Yes, I am aware of that. It was APA's "strongly worded letter" which got press attention, but the issue of lack of enthusiasm and a mediocre product is system wide. Parker can't just use this strategy with pilots only or it just alienates other work groups more, but neutering your primary vocal critic was a fundamental goal.



Might not be what you want for the end game but you have to admit it's better than we had a week ago. I'll take progress.

This doesn't mean guys are gonna just lay down and let Doug steamroll us... But you can find some happiness in this. I know I know....just let it happen.....shhhhhh

A321 03-26-2016 06:12 PM

Foreword: I do think that 5% profit sharing is better than 0%. With that said:

It's important to look at the psychology behind all of this. Management is attempting to placate the employee groups at the lowest possible cost.

Simply accepting this as great while it is SUB-PAR compared to our peers at UAL and DAL is the same mentality that got us into this JCBA and crap contract in the first place. "Well, I guess this is good enough."

Where is min calendar day? Why does there A321 not pay the same as the B757? Why is E190 pay WAY below our competitors? Why do we have tons of 11 hour 3 day trips?

Why should we accept WAYYYY less profit sharing than Delta or United.

Until they match the competitors, management's message in disingenuous. Agents/FAs whoever else may be somewhat motivated by this.... but most pilots will not be FULLY MOTIVATED until we have Delta/United paychecks AND work rules.

Watch the next round of management bonus and stock option payouts on the next 8K. This small 5% share is smoke and mirrors for what is really going on behind the curtain.

Imapilot2 03-27-2016 12:33 AM


Originally Posted by A321 (Post 2097228)
Foreword: I do think that 5% profit sharing is better than 0%. With that said:

It's important to look at the psychology behind all of this. Management is attempting to placate the employee groups at the lowest possible cost.

Simply accepting this as great while it is SUB-PAR compared to our peers at UAL and DAL is the same mentality that got us into this JCBA and crap contract in the first place. "Well, I guess this is good enough."

Where is min calendar day? Why does there A321 not pay the same as the B757? Why is E190 pay WAY below our competitors? Why do we have tons of 11 hour 3 day trips?

Why should we accept WAYYYY less profit sharing than Delta or United.

Until they match the competitors, management's message in disingenuous. Agents/FAs whoever else may be somewhat motivated by this.... but most pilots will not be FULLY MOTIVATED until we have Delta/United paychecks AND work rules.

Watch the next round of management bonus and stock option payouts on the next 8K. This small 5% share is smoke and mirrors for what is really going on behind the curtain.

11 Hour 3 day trips? What the hell. That's bs.

eaglefly 03-27-2016 06:32 AM


Originally Posted by A321 (Post 2097228)
Foreword: I do think that 5% profit sharing is better than 0%. With that said:

It's important to look at the psychology behind all of this. Management is attempting to placate the employee groups at the lowest possible cost.

Simply accepting this as great while it is SUB-PAR compared to our peers at UAL and DAL is the same mentality that got us into this JCBA and crap contract in the first place. "Well, I guess this is good enough."

Where is min calendar day? Why does there A321 not pay the same as the B757? Why is E190 pay WAY below our competitors? Why do we have tons of 11 hour 3 day trips?

Why should we accept WAYYYY less profit sharing than Delta or United.

Until they match the competitors, management's message in disingenuous. Agents/FAs whoever else may be somewhat motivated by this.... but most pilots will not be FULLY MOTIVATED until we have Delta/United paychecks AND work rules.

Watch the next round of management bonus and stock option payouts on the next 8K. This small 5% share is smoke and mirrors for what is really going on behind the curtain.

Wait till 2020. Then, he will once again be offering Delta pay scales (us catching up scale-wise, but WAY behind from years of overall compensation deficiencies), but there will be ominous trade-offs. What will many say ?

Why, the same thing as now, which was the same thing said of the last contract offer albeit with different rationalizations. Those who balk will be "negative nancy's" angry about free money or chastised for complaining about pay RAISES (why do some people complain about free money or pay raises ?). Yet again, I talked to two more pilots yesterday who are impressed with Parker's move and I can see it already. As a group, the majority of us will be nicely prepped by then and ready to be rolled again in a few years. What I'm seeing now is exactly the same show I've seen for 25 years, but with a periodically changing cast. I have little doubt about the curtain call. The only difference is that this time, I will be perfectly happy with more money like the majority were last year and the "free" money (it isn't, Parker is buying something for this money which will pay off handsomely in a few years) like now. The other things........................well, that's for complainers. Me will no complain no more heckling from the back row, but applaud from the front taking any pay raises and any free money that comes my way. The majority confirm those are good things, so why rock the boat when only good things can be lost ?

QuagmireGiggity 03-27-2016 08:30 AM


Originally Posted by beancounter (Post 2095000)
Much higher, but those rates were negotiated by their respective unions during contract talks. This wasn't negotiated, management just decided to listen to their employees. Of course some guys over here are already *****ing about it.... amazing.

Wel well , my husband that beats me went to the dollar store and bought me a dress. How thoughtful.

Route66 03-28-2016 03:34 PM


Originally Posted by eaglefly (Post 2097423)
Wait till 2020. Then, he will once again be offering Delta pay scales (us catching up scale-wise, but WAY behind from years of overall compensation deficiencies), but there will be ominous trade-offs. What will many say ?

Why, the same thing as now, which was the same thing said of the last contract offer albeit with different rationalizations. Those who balk will be "negative nancy's" angry about free money or chastised for complaining about pay RAISES (why do some people complain about free money or pay raises ?). Yet again, I talked to two more pilots yesterday who are impressed with Parker's move and I can see it already. As a group, the majority of us will be nicely prepped by then and ready to be rolled again in a few years. What I'm seeing now is exactly the same show I've seen for 25 years, but with a periodically changing cast. I have little doubt about the curtain call. The only difference is that this time, I will be perfectly happy with more money like the majority were last year and the "free" money (it isn't, Parker is buying something for this money which will pay off handsomely in a few years) like now. The other things........................well, that's for complainers. Me will no complain no more heckling from the back row, but applaud from the front taking any pay raises and any free money that comes my way. The majority confirm those are good things, so why rock the boat when only good things can be lost ?

Thanks for the reality check. You're not going to be alone. I'm with you and so will the majority of pilots. APA/ALPA/USAPA/TEAMSTERS....etc. Getting your money for nothing.

Name User 03-28-2016 03:50 PM

Good Lord it's a free 5% bonus. Hopefully it encourages people to give a crap around here. More so the front line employees. I'm tired of taking the offline commute just so I will be treated better. It's pretty sad.

Sliceback 03-28-2016 04:06 PM

Name user - they'll just be even angrier that you're happy with 5% vs zero.
Zero rocks. Five percent is for guys who can't open their eyes (John Oliver ...)

ATR35 03-28-2016 05:16 PM


Originally Posted by A321 (Post 2097228)
Foreword: I do think that 5% profit sharing is better than 0%. With that said:

It's important to look at the psychology behind all of this. Management is attempting to placate the employee groups at the lowest possible cost.

Simply accepting this as great while it is SUB-PAR compared to our peers at UAL and DAL is the same mentality that got us into this JCBA and crap contract in the first place. "Well, I guess this is good enough."

Where is min calendar day? Why does there A321 not pay the same as the B757? Why is E190 pay WAY below our competitors? Why do we have tons of 11 hour 3 day trips?

Why should we accept WAYYYY less profit sharing than Delta or United.

Until they match the competitors, management's message in disingenuous. Agents/FAs whoever else may be somewhat motivated by this.... but most pilots will not be FULLY MOTIVATED until we have Delta/United paychecks AND work rules.

Watch the next round of management bonus and stock option payouts on the next 8K. This small 5% share is smoke and mirrors for what is really going on behind the curtain.

That's the best assessment I've seen yet. Simple dollar store Doug trying to pull another Walmart type deal getting Delta type effort for pennies on the dollar. No thanks, when we have a similar contract and profit sharing as the other two big carriers I'll be interested. Don't forget we are still far in last place versus United & Delta. Enter in the coolaide drinkers to tell us that we should have a good attitude and be happy to be here... In other words saying that it's okay to be in last place.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:47 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands