Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Career Questions (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/career-questions/)
-   -   Envoy or SkyWest on the crj at ORD (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/career-questions/97790-envoy-skywest-crj-ord.html)

chrisreedrules 10-16-2016 04:42 PM


Originally Posted by Jvw700 (Post 2225037)
Man you sure know a lot about AA's business plans!! Do you sit in on planning meetings with the other executives!

No, but its not hard to see what's going on. As soon as that 700 flying was announced for SkyWest and Envoy announced LGA I knew DCA was the only other logical choice for a base for PSA. Look at which contracts are either flying inefficient 50 seaters (AWAC) and/or have a top-heavy/expensive seniority list (AWAC and RAH) and you can see where they may be wanting to make cuts. Mesa's flying going to someone else will likely be due to staffing. The same could be said about TSA as well.

Jvw700 10-16-2016 04:52 PM

Here's my WAG. Eagle shrunk by over 1000 pilots over the last few years. The envoy side is now where they want it at about 2000 pilots. The need for hiring is coming from the increase in flow and perhaps a few more airframes. AAG finally has the ability to contract out to multiple carriers where they didn't when they were AMR. You might see some smaller companies disappear but I don't believe AAG wants to give up the cheaper feed they get from other contract carriers. To AAG, envoy/PDT/PSA will always be a cost unit....

Blizzard 10-16-2016 04:59 PM

A lot of interesting stuff here. Thanks to everyone who has contributed. Question for Envoy folks--if I flew the crj out of Chicago and then in a year or two they transferred them all out to PSA, what is the process? Do they let you choose whichever plane you want to fly (prob the 145 since I live in Chicagoland)? Any plans for the 175 to come to Chicago eventually, or is it just DFW? Looks like reserve is 6 months or so on the crj and 8 months on the 145 for new hires out of ORD, from the paperwork that recruiting sent, so looks a bit shorter for the crj, which is one of the reasons I want that bird.

lakehouse 10-16-2016 05:04 PM


Originally Posted by Blizzard (Post 2225053)
A lot of interesting stuff here. Thanks to everyone who has contributed. Question for Envoy folks--if I flew the crj out of Chicago and then in a year or two they transferred them all out to PSA, what is the process? Do they let you choose whichever plane you want to fly (prob the 145 since I live in Chicagoland)? Any plans for the 175 to come to Chicago eventually, or is it just DFW? Looks like reserve is 6 months or so on the crj and 8 months on the 145 for new hires out of ORD, from the paperwork that recruiting sent, so looks a bit shorter for the crj, which is one of the reasons I want that bird.

First off those numbers constantly change. With the hiring it will all drop.

If they close crj ord you can pick anything your seniority can hold.

I do warn you ord appears to be setup for a downsizing right now. Just be aware of that.

chrisreedrules 10-16-2016 05:17 PM


Originally Posted by Jvw700 (Post 2225047)
Here's my WAG. Eagle shrunk by over 1000 pilots over the last few years. The envoy side is now where they want it at about 2000 pilots. The need for hiring is coming from the increase in flow and perhaps a few more airframes. AAG finally has the ability to contract out to multiple carriers where they didn't when they were AMR. You might see some smaller companies disappear but I don't believe AAG wants to give up the cheaper feed they get from other contract carriers. To AAG, envoy/PDT/PSA will always be a cost unit....

Envoy, PSA, and Piedmont will continue to be the cheaper feed (even with higher pay rates) if they are constantly scooping the highest paid off the top and attracting relatively cheap new hires in at the bottom. Even if they added another $20 /hour to all the pay scales it would still be cheaper than most other regionals. By virtue of the relatively junior pilot groups all 3 will have in the next few years. And with the WOs, it's all profit. They don't have to pay another business (who also has shareholders to make money for) any of the profits. They keep it all for themselves.

Jvw700 10-16-2016 05:23 PM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 2225064)
Envoy, PSA, and Piedmont will continue to be the cheaper feed (even with higher pay rates) if they are constantly scooping the highest paid off the top and attracting relatively cheap new hires in at the bottom. Even if they added another $20 /hour to all the pay scales it would still be cheaper than most other regionals. By virtue of the relatively junior pilot groups all 3 will have in the next few years. And with the WOs, it's all profit. They don't have to pay another business (who also has shareholders to make money for) any of the profits. They keep it all for themselves.

You don't know how these agreements work do you? There is a reason Skywest can do it cheaper and it's not because the pilots are cheaper...
You will always be a cost unit to AAG, they have said as much! They have also said they wanted a more manageable sized pilot group, hence the reason why they shrunk over 1000 pilots. But you're at PSA so you wouldn't know. Whatever AAG wants you give.... maybe that was before your time.

Blizzard 10-16-2016 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by lakehouse (Post 2225056)
First off those numbers constantly change. With the hiring it will all drop.

If they close crj ord you can pick anything your seniority can hold.

I do warn you ord appears to be setup for a downsizing right now. Just be aware of that.

Thanks-good info.

Skyvector 10-16-2016 05:30 PM


Originally Posted by Jvw700 (Post 2225047)
Here's my WAG. Eagle shrunk by over 1000 pilots over the last few years. The envoy side is now where they want it at about 2000 pilots. The need for hiring is coming from the increase in flow and perhaps a few more airframes. AAG finally has the ability to contract out to multiple carriers where they didn't when they were AMR. You might see some smaller companies disappear but I don't believe AAG wants to give up the cheaper feed they get from other contract carriers. To AAG, envoy/PDT/PSA will always be a cost unit....

Here's my WAG:

You left Envoy a couple of years ago for a lateral to another Regional. Now you desperately need to convince yourself you made the right choice. So you spend your days posting outdated garbage in Envoy threads while hoping and praying they fail.

That way you can feel good about your decision..which is looking more and more foolish with each passing day. Bring on your usual comeback about "schedules"..that great arbitrary, anectocal argument that is all the rage on APC these days.

WesternSkies 10-16-2016 05:33 PM

American ops are a dumpster 🔥.
But today I would pick envoy anyway.

Jvw700 10-16-2016 05:35 PM


Originally Posted by Skyvector (Post 2225075)
Here's my WAG:

You left Envoy a couple of years ago for a lateral to another Regional. Now you desperately need to convince yourself you made the right choice. So you spend your days posting outdated garbage in Envoy threads while hoping and praying they fail.

That way you can feel good about your decision..which is looking more and more foolish with each passing day. Bring on your usual comeback about "schedules"..that great arbitrary, anectocal argument that is all the rage on APC these days.

I knew it was only a matter of time before envoys number one fan boy would show up! I have absolutely no regrets about leaving that dismal place and never will!! My posts about envoy are pretty current actually. Nothing has changed except new hires now get a massive bonus. Same old management team and their cheerleaders like yourself who fail to see reality.

PilotJ3 10-16-2016 05:36 PM


Originally Posted by lakehouse (Post 2225056)
First off those numbers constantly change. With the hiring it will all drop.

If they close crj ord you can pick anything your seniority can hold.

I do warn you ord appears to be setup for a downsizing right now. Just be aware of that.


Chicago is not downsizing. Rah has shrunk so they've been covered with CRj7 from envoy and skywest cr2/7.

DilsonWic 10-16-2016 05:42 PM


Originally Posted by Jvw700 (Post 2225079)
I knew it was only a matter of time before envoys number one fan boy would show up! I have absolutely no regrets about leaving that dismal place and never will!! My posts about envoy are pretty current actually. Nothing has changed except new hires now get a massive bonus. Same old management team and their cheerleaders like yourself who fail to see reality.

But please help us understand why you obsess about this place still?

Do you also stalk your ex-girl/boyfriends?

Jvw700 10-16-2016 05:46 PM


Originally Posted by DilsonWic (Post 2225082)
But please help us understand why you obsess about this place still?

Do you also stalk your ex-girl/boyfriends?

I have many friends there still, k son? Given your screen name it's no surprise you come to the companies defense. How's he treating you these days?

DilsonWic 10-16-2016 06:13 PM


Originally Posted by Jvw700 (Post 2225086)
I have many friends there still, k son? Given your screen name it's no surprise you come to the companies defense. How's he treating you these days?

Gawd! Even the way you type is so condescending and smug, glad you're gone. You're probably a peach to share a cockpit with. I'm done with ya, brah!

word302 10-16-2016 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 2225032)
I'm sure you don't pay as much attention as those of us at the WOs, but there are some important factors to consider...

1) If you don't work for an AA WO, you can certainly apply to AA as an off the street hire. However, your chances are very slim that you will get hired because only 25-30% of new hires at AA are coming from off the street, and most of those are military pilots. That leaves UA and DA. Delta traditionally has hired about 50% of its pilots from the military. So maybe your odds aren't so good there (unless you go work for Endeavor, which is probably your best shot. And even they only have a 40-50% pass rate for their interview with Delta). That leaves UA, who also hires a large percentage of military pilots. However you can go work for an AA WO, have the exact same odds as every other non-WO pilot applying at DA and UA except for one thing: You have a guaranteed flow in your back pocket, "just in case".

2) AA has said that they are moving non-WO flying back to their WOs. That means pilots flying for other regionals may not have a job within a couple years. They are going to continue raising pay and improving the flow agreements as needed to attract pilots.

...There is a lot of speculation about what AA may do to attract pilots in the next couple years. I've heard everything from the well thought out and plausible (DoH), to the absurd (staple). Either way, things will continue to improve and the WOs will only further outpace the rest of the industry in terms of compensation and benefits as the pilot shortage deepens.

You all keep spouting this crap, but the majors are just starting the hiring boom. AA will not be able to only hire from the military and WOs without shrinking drastically (either themselves or the WOs). Anyone who networks and puts forth a little effort will have a job with the legacies. Just look at the retirement numbers, it's 4th grade math guys.

chrisreedrules 10-16-2016 06:38 PM


Originally Posted by word302 (Post 2225115)
You all keep spouting this crap, but the majors are just starting the hiring boom. AA will not be able to only hire from the military and WOs without shrinking drastically (either themselves or the WOs). Anyone who networks and puts forth a little effort will have a job with the legacies. Just look at the retirement numbers, it's 4th grade math guys.

They will continue to undercut the non-WO feed and simultaneously make their WOs more attractive in compensation and benefits to staff their WOs in the short term. And long term is anyone's guess. These are uncharted waters for the industry to a great extent. Maybe AA says the only way to work for them is through a WO and strikes a deal that says you get longevity from DoH when you flow. Maybe mainline absorbs the 900s and 175s and takes WO pilots with them. The fact is that if AA weren't committed to the career path through its WOs then why waste the money and effort to make it so?

I'm not here saying the flow is the be all and end all that some make it out to be. It isn't. But it's a great tool to guarantee movement while you work at a WO and also a great "backup plan" if you don't get called by DA and UA. AAG management knows that in order to continue to staff its WO regionals, it's going to have to keep upping the ante. And they are well aware that unless they streamline and hasten the path from WO to mainline they will begin losing a lot of their regional pilots to DA and UA (last month we lost double what we lose from the flow to AA to both DA and UA). Things are only going to improve from here for WO pilots. American has backed itself in a corner and now they aren't left with any "cheap" options.

lakehouse 10-16-2016 07:35 PM


Originally Posted by PilotJ3 (Post 2225080)
Chicago is not downsizing. Rah has shrunk so they've been covered with CRj7 from envoy and skywest cr2/7.

I know something you don't but that's fine.

I will say hypothetically this time next year ord will be about 50% it's current size only 145 and the 175 is the wild card on anything better. :)

Eject 10-16-2016 10:10 PM


Originally Posted by lakehouse (Post 2225153)
I know something you don't but that's fine.

I will say hypothetically this time next year ord will be about 50% it's current size only 145 and the 175 is the wild card on anything better. :)

I think this may be true. My WAG is the 700's are gone in 8 months.

banana380 10-17-2016 05:08 AM


Originally Posted by lakehouse (Post 2225153)
I know something you don't but that's fine.

I will say hypothetically this time next year ord will be about 50% it's current size only 145 and the 175 is the wild card on anything better. :)

The hiring info pamphlet I was handed in July had the 175 listed for both DFW and ORD...

ordflyer8794 10-17-2016 05:18 AM


Originally Posted by banana380 (Post 2225287)
The hiring info pamphlet I was handed in July had the 175 listed for both DFW and ORD...

With the amount of flying being done by the 175 in ORD I think we'll eventually see a ORD base. If not, NYC but this will also be contingent on us getting more 175 options.

amcnd 10-17-2016 05:51 AM


Originally Posted by banana380 (Post 2225287)
The hiring info pamphlet I was handed in July had the 175 listed for both DFW and ORD...

LOL. You believed a pamphlet!!! Good one..

banana380 10-17-2016 06:48 AM


Originally Posted by amcnd (Post 2225313)
LOL. You believed a pamphlet!!! Good one..

Not saying I believed it, just saying that's what was printed.

I'm personally chasing the extra 5K on the 145 in DFW so the 175 being in ORD or not doesn't matter to me.

lakehouse 10-17-2016 06:53 AM

The pamphlet was when we had an open vacancy for the 175 ord. It canceled.

To my knowledge the override for the 145 was removed in mid Aug. Regardless the new bonus/rates make for some high first year pay.

Pick the base you live in. Each airplane has pluses and minuses. The 145 you can at least be based ord dfw lga and most likely mia soon.

uavking 10-17-2016 10:40 AM


Originally Posted by lakehouse (Post 2225348)
To my knowledge the override for the 145 was removed in mid Aug. Regardless the new bonus/rates make for some high first year pay.

Extra $5k for "legacy fleet" aircraft came back with the higher pay rates in September. Now, actually seeing that $5k in a check is a whole different story.

RyanP 10-18-2016 03:27 PM


Originally Posted by Eject (Post 2225219)
I think this may be true. My WAG is the 700's are gone in 8 months.

No way they are gone that soon with the way the keep delaying everything.

egl2fdx 10-18-2016 04:18 PM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 2225021)
In a short period of time PSA will be flowing 2014 hires. That's pretty incredible.

Yea, try 3 years.

chrisreedrules 10-18-2016 04:23 PM


Originally Posted by egl2fdx (Post 2226644)
Yea, try 3 years.

That's a relatively short amount of time for flow in this industry. And it will likely be much sooner than that if attrition keeps up the way it has.

Duesenflieger 10-18-2016 07:59 PM

In three years, AA will be hiring people from every corner of the regional industry, whether they hail from the AA wholly owneds or not: just simply too many retirements.

Aviatrx 10-19-2016 09:55 AM

Yes they will. If you are lucky, they might give you a chance to interview. Don't screw up!

VArellano 10-20-2016 05:52 AM

Are new hires seeing KORD out of training at Skywest?

Bucknut 10-20-2016 06:40 AM

Skywest Versus Envoy
 
United has a clause in thier contract that they are to hire from an ALPA carrier. Food for thought!

Is offline 10-20-2016 10:12 AM


Originally Posted by VArellano (Post 2227675)
Are new hires seeing KORD out of training at Skywest?

Yes, and the 30 700's are moving to ORD and PHX.

Squallrider 10-20-2016 11:14 AM


Originally Posted by Bucknut (Post 2227699)
United has a clause in thier contract that they are to hire from an ALPA carrier. Food for thought!

Yes but it doesn't say how many or that it's exclusive...sooo yea food for thought your dues are a waste

colonials13 10-20-2016 11:20 AM


Originally Posted by Bucknut (Post 2227699)
United has a clause in thier contract that they are to hire from an ALPA carrier. Food for thought!


Originally Posted by Squallrider (Post 2227843)
Yes but it doesn't say how many or that it's exclusive...sooo yea food for thought your dues are a waste

Anyone have a copy of that please?

DontEnvoyMe 10-21-2016 06:21 AM


Originally Posted by lakehouse (Post 2225153)
I know something you don't but that's fine.

I will say hypothetically this time next year ord will be about 50% it's current size only 145 and the 175 is the wild card on anything better. :)

What do you know?

colonials13 10-21-2016 11:32 AM


Originally Posted by Bucknut (Post 2227699)
United has a clause in thier contract that they are to hire from an ALPA carrier. Food for thought!

After asking around, I've found out that this only applies if you are unemployed due to furlough from an ALPA carrier.

Specifically - "Subject to other legal obligations, the Company shall make reasonable efforts to fill Pilot vacancies with the individuals who satisfy United’s hiring standards, who have previously worked for carriers represented by ALPA, and who are no longer working for those carriers for economic reasons such as lay-offs or the shutdown of that carrier. "


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:24 PM.


Website Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands