Merlin Crash at CRG in 2003
#1
Line Holder
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Feb 2006
Position: J3 to CL600; retired doing instrument taining
Posts: 78
Merlin Crash at CRG in 2003
JACKSONVILLE, FL --October 13, 2006 -- Trial attorneys Don Maciejewski and Jack London announced today that the Swanson family's lawsuit against the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and Robinson Aviation, Inc. (RVA) has been settled for $2.5 million.
The Swanson family contended in the suit that Craig Municipal Airport in Jacksonville had faulty equipment and air traffic controllers failed to warn pilot George C. Swanson of his position before he crashed near the airport on Thanksgiving 2003.
"Since we began this case, the government changed the antennae to a modern system that prevents the fault, and the air traffic controllers who were handling the airplane at the time of the crash have been reassigned," Maciejewski said. "It is heartbreaking to lose a parent and a friend this way, but the Swanson family has given itself to public service ever since their great-grandfather was the personal physician to two U.S. presidents. It is only fitting that their father's last act was also a public service -- to make flying safer for pilots in Jacksonville and North Florida."
Swanson, a physician, and his children were flying from Port Arthur, Texas, to Jacksonville on Thanksgiving to meet with his mother and brother, a Jacksonville police officer, before flying to the Keys. He died when his Swearingen Merlin II airplane crashed into woods in thick fog near Atlantic and Kernan boulevards, 1.8 miles from Craig airport. He was 56.
All four children aboard the plane were injured but survived.
"When the Swanson family asked us to find out why their father's airplane crashed, we knew it would require an investigation into why the air traffic controllers at Craig Field did not advise the pilot of his position, but we didn't think that was enough," London said. "After thousands of pages of government records, many thousands of questions put to many witnesses, and after research into little-known details about instrument landing failures, we were able to tell the Swanson children what we learned -- something that very few people knew, and those people weren't talking."
"Craig Field had a radio landing system for almost a decade that the government knew was out of specification but left unchanged," Maciejewski said. "Moreover, pilots were never told that a government inspection had revealed that the glideslope at Craig was subject to course reversal that affected the airplane landing instruments, particularly in bad weather."
The Swanson family contended in the suit that Craig Municipal Airport in Jacksonville had faulty equipment and air traffic controllers failed to warn pilot George C. Swanson of his position before he crashed near the airport on Thanksgiving 2003.
"Since we began this case, the government changed the antennae to a modern system that prevents the fault, and the air traffic controllers who were handling the airplane at the time of the crash have been reassigned," Maciejewski said. "It is heartbreaking to lose a parent and a friend this way, but the Swanson family has given itself to public service ever since their great-grandfather was the personal physician to two U.S. presidents. It is only fitting that their father's last act was also a public service -- to make flying safer for pilots in Jacksonville and North Florida."
Swanson, a physician, and his children were flying from Port Arthur, Texas, to Jacksonville on Thanksgiving to meet with his mother and brother, a Jacksonville police officer, before flying to the Keys. He died when his Swearingen Merlin II airplane crashed into woods in thick fog near Atlantic and Kernan boulevards, 1.8 miles from Craig airport. He was 56.
All four children aboard the plane were injured but survived.
"When the Swanson family asked us to find out why their father's airplane crashed, we knew it would require an investigation into why the air traffic controllers at Craig Field did not advise the pilot of his position, but we didn't think that was enough," London said. "After thousands of pages of government records, many thousands of questions put to many witnesses, and after research into little-known details about instrument landing failures, we were able to tell the Swanson children what we learned -- something that very few people knew, and those people weren't talking."
"Craig Field had a radio landing system for almost a decade that the government knew was out of specification but left unchanged," Maciejewski said. "Moreover, pilots were never told that a government inspection had revealed that the glideslope at Craig was subject to course reversal that affected the airplane landing instruments, particularly in bad weather."
http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?e...02X01981&key=1
The deceased pilot (Commercial, Instrument, Airplane SE & ME Land & Sea) exhibited poor judgment in attempting an approach in weather way below minimums (1/4 mile and 100 foot ceiling).
Thoughts?
Cub
#2
I know there are some times where you need to get in...but there are just some times where you need to stick to your guns and respect your own personal minimums...
If you don't have any...set some!
Lax
If you don't have any...set some!
Lax
#5
Line Holder
Thread Starter
Joined APC: Feb 2006
Position: J3 to CL600; retired doing instrument taining
Posts: 78
"First fool on turkey day"
The final NTSB report was issued yesterday.
Reference NTSB web link
http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?e...02X01981&key=1. The cause of the crash was entirely attrributed to the actions of the pilot. The weather at St Augustine (25 south) was clear with 2 miles visibility and Jax International had wx above minnimums with aircraft landing successfully. It is so sad that this pilot was killed but here is the bottom line; if he had executed a missed approach at the minnimum approach altitude, he would have positively not hit the trees and terrain.
Just my personal thoughts. cub
Reference NTSB web link
http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?e...02X01981&key=1. The cause of the crash was entirely attrributed to the actions of the pilot. The weather at St Augustine (25 south) was clear with 2 miles visibility and Jax International had wx above minnimums with aircraft landing successfully. It is so sad that this pilot was killed but here is the bottom line; if he had executed a missed approach at the minnimum approach altitude, he would have positively not hit the trees and terrain.
Just my personal thoughts. cub
Last edited by cub pilot; 05-30-2007 at 01:25 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post