Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   JetBlue (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/jetblue/)
-   -   Merger getting blocked (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/jetblue/141589-merger-getting-blocked.html)

Bluediver 03-06-2023 01:24 PM


Originally Posted by Flyby1206 (Post 3602996)
The argument for/against the merger is still the same, just more opponents on the other side. The only change I expect is another 4-6 months added onto the timeframe to get this completed and probably run it through the Supreme Court.

The argument against two small carriers merging to become the 5th largest carrier isn't going to hold water in the long term. If this is truly the case then the government needs to unravel DL/NW, CO/UA, AA/US, WN/AT, VX/AS.

Why stop there? Give back TWA, AMwest, Republic (1), Midwest and while you’re at it let’s bring back Morris Air for good measure.

Flyby1206 03-06-2023 01:28 PM


Originally Posted by Bluediver (Post 3603018)
Why stop there? Give back TWA, AMwest, Republic (1), Midwest and while you’re at it let’s bring back Morris Air for good measure.

F-it, bring back the Civil Aeronautics Board! 😂

Bluedriver 03-06-2023 03:03 PM

For all the political connections JB has, I believe there are 4 huge airlines with connections and political contributions placing their thumb on the scale against approval.

ProPilotBlue 03-06-2023 03:10 PM

The company can operate as 2 operating certificates. There is precedent for that (Republic, Atlas, etc.). It won't be as efficient, but they don't have to wait for a supreme court decision to actually merge. And in the meantime they could merge most of the operation, and maybe even transfer some assets to the JetBlue certificate. Annoying? Yes, but IMHO I don't think that's a deal-breaker. They WILL get the approval, eventually. Maybe it happens in late January of 2025...

Bluedriver 03-06-2023 03:14 PM

Interesting idea. Maybe they win in court, but if the DOT won't back down they close on the sale and slowly move assets to the JB certificate?

ProPilotBlue 03-06-2023 03:35 PM


Originally Posted by Bluedriver (Post 3603089)
Interesting idea. Maybe they win in court, but if the DOT won't back down they close on the sale and slowly move assets to the JB certificate?

Maybe? At the very least they could run them as 2 operations until such time that the DOT gets their heads extracted. 2 operations that work together for max efficiency.

RiddleEagle18 03-06-2023 03:53 PM

Our contract does not allow for that

Tranquility 03-06-2023 03:59 PM

It would be interesting to see this play out with our respective scope clauses regarding merger transactions…. We at NK have certain protections in cases of a merger, but I’d need a Rep to digest the legalese for me; lots of lawyer talk….

ProPilotBlue 03-06-2023 04:12 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603110)
Our contract does not allow for that

Oh, darn. I guess it will just have to be scrapped then. Pack it up fellas, the CBA won't let it happen!


I'm pretty sure that if necessary, a temporary modification could be made with some stipulations. It is in all of our best interests that this thing go through.

baseball3792 03-06-2023 04:26 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603110)
Our contract does not allow for that

I’m sure that it could be arranged… for a price

Bluedriver 03-06-2023 04:30 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603110)
Our contract does not allow for that

You mean like how our contract didn't allow the NEA? Holding my breath. :)

Hey, at least we'll get 2%.

avi8orco 03-06-2023 04:37 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603110)
Our contract does not allow for that

When has that ever stopped them? Guarantee you the check is already written to the MEC to fix that little inconvenience. CK will be selling us that flica waiting room and a .01 per diem raise to make that happen.

RiddleEagle18 03-06-2023 05:04 PM

As long as they are gonna pay us for it and the planes are brought onto our certificate and never allowed to move the other way.

swa/at style. That’s how they did it.

im just saying right now the contract doesn’t allow it and we better not allow a work around unless the language is very tight.

no dual ops without a plan to bring it all under one roof.

Bluedriver 03-06-2023 05:10 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603152)
As long as they are gonna pay us for it and the planes are brought onto our certificate and never allowed to move the other way.

swa/at style. That’s how they did it.

im just saying right now the contract doesn’t allow it and we better not allow a work around unless the language is very tight.

no dual ops without a plan to bring it all under one roof.

That's a Bingo.

I was inverted 03-06-2023 05:44 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603152)
As long as they are gonna pay us for it and the planes are brought onto our certificate and never allowed to move the other way.

swa/at style. That’s how they did it.

im just saying right now the contract doesn’t allow it and we better not allow a work around unless the language is very tight.

no dual ops without a plan to bring it all under one roof.

CBA 1.0: clearly doesn’t allow focus city to focus city and focus city to international codeshare/JV.
Company: “We are going to do it anyway.”
ALPA: ok, but only for a 2% raise (for a loss to inflation).
*sell job sell job sell job because FEAR!!!*

ALPA will fold for a crappy LOA because there will be fear of the arbitrator, or fear of force majeure, or some other reason B6ALPA will spew to justify folding like the wet noodle they are, but they will be sure to get them next time. They have as much spine as a jellyfish.

avi8orco 03-06-2023 06:13 PM

^^^^^…..gets it

Bluediver 03-06-2023 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by avi8orco (Post 3603134)
When has that ever stopped them? Guarantee you the check is already written to the MEC to fix that little inconvenience. CK will be selling us that flica waiting room and a .01 per diem raise to make that happen.


As long as they promise a Task Farce to look into Profit Sharing….. oh wait.

V2500 03-06-2023 06:33 PM


Originally Posted by I was inverted (Post 3603175)
CBA 1.0: clearly doesn’t allow focus city to focus city and focus city to international codeshare/JV.
Company: “We are going to do it anyway.”
ALPA: ok, but only for a 2% raise (for a loss to inflation).
*sell job sell job sell job because FEAR!!!*

ALPA will fold for a crappy LOA because there will be fear of the arbitrator, or fear of force majeure, or some other reason B6ALPA will spew to justify folding like the wet noodle they are, but they will be sure to get them next time. They have as much spine as a jellyfish.

Expect nothing less under CK “leadership”

pilotpayne 03-06-2023 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by baseball3792 (Post 3603126)
I’m sure that it could be arranged… for a price


Oh good grief our guys would probably just ask for a cut above shirts and it’s a deal

pilotpayne 03-06-2023 06:59 PM


Originally Posted by RiddleEagle18 (Post 3603152)
As long as they are gonna pay us for it and the planes are brought onto our certificate and never allowed to move the other way.

swa/at style. That’s how they did it.

im just saying right now the contract doesn’t allow it and we better not allow a work around unless the language is very tight.

no dual ops without a plan to bring it all under one roof.


Ahhh Frank Lorenzo returns. Man if anyone even thinks that dual ops would be ok they need to be shown a history book.

Excargodog 03-06-2023 07:23 PM


Originally Posted by SunnyFL (Post 3602986)
So how big of a deal with the DOT chiming in they plan on blocking this does it make compared to when we thought it was only the DOJ initially? Just curious if this changes anything compared to what we originally expected with the DOJ only?

DOT hasn’t blocked a certificate transfer since deregulation. They’ll get handed their heads in court if they seriously try this.

Personally, I think this is a head fake by DOJ. They are going to lose the NEA issue and want leverage to get JetBlue to compromise on that so they can save face.

baseball3792 03-06-2023 07:47 PM


Originally Posted by Excargodog (Post 3603224)
DOT hasn’t blocked a certificate transfer since deregulation. They’ll get handed their heads in court if they seriously try this.

Personally, I think this is a head fake by DOJ. They are going to lose the NEA issue and want leverage to get JetBlue to compromise on that so they can save face.

I think you overestimate the intelligence and skill of these people. I think the administration told them to do whatever it takes to block the merger, so that’s what they’re going to try to do. It is probably politically popular sadly.

Excargodog 03-06-2023 10:04 PM


Originally Posted by baseball3792 (Post 3603236)
I think you overestimate the intelligence and skill of these people. I think the administration told them to do whatever it takes to block the merger, so that’s what they’re going to try to do. It is probably politically popular sadly.

A prominent court loss just before the election will not help them politically. Nor will an FAA administrator who knows little about aviation.

JackpotAir 03-07-2023 05:04 AM


Originally Posted by Excargodog (Post 3603270)
A prominent court loss just before the election will not help them politically. Nor will an FAA administrator who knows little about aviation.

I mean it looks like this administration is ready to throw in the towel on the whole “student loan forgiveness” thing early on. Blocking B6/NK might just be another fight to lose for them at this point.

Forward lav 03-07-2023 06:25 AM


Originally Posted by JackpotAir (Post 3603329)
I mean it looks like this administration is ready to throw in the towel on the whole “student loan forgiveness” thing early on. Blocking B6/NK might just be another fight to lose for them at this point.

I’m pretty sure it already went through. I just flew with a guy that got over $10k forgiven. I’m looking forward to my refund check because I was responsible and paid mine.

FLPilot3190 03-07-2023 06:58 AM

It’s official: DOJ sues to block merger

avi8orco 03-07-2023 07:39 AM


Originally Posted by FLPilot3190 (Post 3603389)
It’s official: DOJ sues to block merger

https://thumbs.gfycat.com/LawfulEver...restricted.gif

actually….probably business as usual at LSC

Flyby1206 03-07-2023 08:18 AM

We might as well bring back regulation at this point. We're 75% of the way there.

Bluediver 03-07-2023 08:20 AM


Originally Posted by avi8orco (Post 3603417)
https://thumbs.gfycat.com/LawfulEver...restricted.gif

actually….probably business as usual at LSC


They’re to busy trying to put together quality lines for APR to worry much about the DOJ today…. Oh wait.

Forward lav 03-07-2023 08:22 AM


Originally Posted by FLPilot3190 (Post 3603389)
It’s official: DOJ sues to block merger

Posturing. The government that created the big three blocking number 5 is laughable. But, then again, if you you’ve been around during the last 3 years….

FLPilot3190 03-07-2023 08:32 AM


Originally Posted by Forward lav (Post 3603450)
Posturing. The government that created the big three blocking number 5 is laughable. But, then again, if you you’ve been around during the last 3 years….

I mean, I think it’ll get approved in the long run. What we’ll have to give in return remains to be seen. The DOT publicly considering blocking the transfer of Spirit’s certificate to us is absolutely ridiculous.

Excargodog 03-07-2023 08:38 AM


Originally Posted by Forward lav (Post 3603450)
Posturing. The government that created the big three blocking number 5 is laughable. But, then again, if you you’ve been around during the last 3 years….

Nonetheless, it makes it very difficult to justify in court. And as for the DOT threat to stop transfer of the certificate, the Supreme Court is already gunning for a case to reverse the Chevron deference doctrine. This will be a perfect opportunity. Jet Blue ought to appeal for a restraining order on DOT immediately. This woukd be a real opportunity to rein in reckless executive branch conduct.

bidnez 03-07-2023 08:56 AM

Hope it goes through, I don't think JB will survive without the merger... Just the cost to fight this for years is going to be decimating.

Roy Biggins 03-07-2023 09:00 AM


Originally Posted by bidnez (Post 3603473)
Hope it goes through, I don't think JB will survive without the merger... Just the cost to fight this for years is going to be decimating.

You’re not kidding. We’re pot committed at this point.

Bluedriver 03-07-2023 01:26 PM


Originally Posted by bidnez (Post 3603473)
Hope it goes through, I don't think JB will survive without the merger... Just the cost to fight this for years is going to be decimating.

Fascinating. You sound really informed on this subject, can you tell us more?

flyingpuma1 03-07-2023 03:14 PM


Originally Posted by bidnez (Post 3603473)
Hope it goes through, I don't think JB will survive without the merger... Just the cost to fight this for years is going to be decimating.

If you think it’s bad over at JB you should see us here at NK, can’t keep new hires (or old hires) and haven’t made a profit since before Covid, at least you have figured out how to make money our management can’t/doesn’t care.

Razzledazzle 03-07-2023 06:34 PM


Originally Posted by bidnez (Post 3603473)
Hope it goes through, I don't think JB will survive without the merger... Just the cost to fight this for years is going to be decimating.

fascinating . The airline with almost 2B in cash post Covid, and 10B in assets will tank on some legal fees? Tell me more….

I was inverted 03-07-2023 08:15 PM


Originally Posted by bidnez (Post 3603473)
Hope it goes through, I don't think JB will survive without the merger... Just the cost to fight this for years is going to be decimating.

Got any stock tips you’d be willing to share too? Thanks

Forward lav 03-08-2023 12:52 AM


Originally Posted by I was inverted (Post 3603831)
Got any stock tips you’d be willing to share too? Thanks

Buy hmbl 😂

Norge 03-08-2023 02:54 AM


Originally Posted by I was inverted (Post 3603175)
CBA 1.0: clearly doesn’t allow focus city to focus city and focus city to international codeshare/JV.
Company: “We are going to do it anyway.”
ALPA: ok, but only for a 2% raise (for a loss to inflation).
*sell job sell job sell job because FEAR!!!*

ALPA will fold for a crappy LOA because there will be fear of the arbitrator, or fear of force majeure, or some other reason B6ALPA will spew to justify folding like the wet noodle they are, but they will be sure to get them next time. They have as much spine as a jellyfish.

Sadly B6ALPA simply reflects our pilot group. Fold, fear, wet noodle, jellyfish...those words can describe our group as well. We certainly need stronger leadership (no question) but it's our peers who have yet to reject a company offer.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:45 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands