Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   Fat pax want bigger seat and unlimited snacks (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/142458-fat-pax-want-bigger-seat-unlimited-snacks.html)

Nantonaku 04-20-2023 11:33 AM

This discussion is not what I expected to find after reading the title. I guess the topic of fat people was a little too politically hot for APC.

ReadOnly7 04-20-2023 12:33 PM


Originally Posted by CBreezy (Post 3626989)
Whew, talk about ad hominem from the cheap seats.

​​​​​​

​​​​

it’s literally the OPPOSITE of ad hominem. He’s not attacking the person, he’s attacking the position. (Ukraine nonsense)

CBreezy 04-20-2023 12:36 PM


Originally Posted by ReadOnly7 (Post 3627043)
it’s literally the OPPOSITE of ad hominem. He’s not attacking the person, he’s attacking the position. (Ukraine nonsense)

He's attacking the person based on his opinion on a completely unrelated subject. He did not attack his opinion regarding overweight people at all. I didn't read much but it doesn't even appear to be that absurd of an opinion and is backed up with knowledge and experience. Just some people don't like it.

It's literally the same concept of coming on here and saying "Aren't you the same person who says he likes the Chevy Volt?!" It has nothing to do with the subject at hand, it changes the subject entirely (red herring) and attacks the person.

Hubcapped 04-20-2023 02:54 PM


Originally Posted by DownWithNarita (Post 3626985)
Hey hubcapped aren't you the one on the ukraine thread spouting nonsense that has now been debunked since all the Intel leaks showed the world the big picture?

People in glass houses.

Ehh? Which stuff has been debunked specifically? It’s pretty childish to not only not provide any context for your complaints, but furthermore bleed it into another thread. Get control my friend, this is just the internet. I formally apologize to everyone on his behalf. He is clearly upset.

To Mr narita, please have proper manners and keep threads where they belong. Apc would be chaos if we let the children run rampant no?

DeltaboundRedux 04-25-2023 12:40 PM


Originally Posted by Hubcapped (Post 3626571)
Did fox lie or not? Curious for your thoughts on this

Of course! About what?

All "news" programs lie. In all mediums, constantly, unreservedly, and without shame. Truth telling isn't it's purpose.

Your real question should be "did fox meet the legal threshold for damages in a defamation case?" It's a very difficult legal threshold to meet. Alan Dershowitz says no; I've read a few of his books and I respect his opinion.


-------------------------

Not a huge Chomsky fan, but "Manufacturing Consent - The Political Economy of the Mass Media" is a good read if you're interested in modern day Mass Propaganda.

Propaganda isn't what you think it is, you're not equipped to resist it (I'm not either, the only way to win is not to play). It's an ocean we all swim in without even realizing it's there.

Stan446 04-26-2023 07:57 PM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 3624987)
I wouldn't be 100% sure... the right congress might be interested in something like this, saving another oppressed class from themselves at the expense of everyone else. What's not to love?

But what I want to know is do you have to be legitimately fat to get a free adjacent seat, or do you just have to hit a certain weight, even if you're fit? Ie, is it weight or BMI? I could sure you use some extra elbow room too.

You just get a red vest that says, "Service Person" instead of service dog and they'll be all set.

Wingtip220 05-12-2023 03:55 PM

The dominos are beginning to fall. “What do you mean I can’t have a full row for free due to my size? That’s discriminatory!!”

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/05/11/b...ion/index.html

symbian simian 05-12-2023 04:44 PM


Originally Posted by Wingtip220 (Post 3635811)
The dominos are beginning to fall. “What do you mean I can’t have a full row for free due to my size? That’s discriminatory!!”

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/05/11/b...ion/index.html

Science: "obese people cost more". More health care cost, more fuel used to fly them around, even if they fit in 1 seat.
Not a fan of the pro-fat movement. Most discrimination is traditionally towards things people can't change. The whole gender thing has moved that goalpost a bit, but a man wearing a skirt while flying does not cost the airline extra. If my grandparents and my parents all died of cancer not due to lifestyle choices I should still get health insurance. If I smoke, my life insurance premium goes up. That is fair IMO. Being fat is a choice.

Wingtip220 05-12-2023 04:55 PM


Originally Posted by symbian simian (Post 3635838)
Science: "obese people cost more". More health care cost, more fuel used to fly them around, even if they fit in 1 seat.
Not a fan of the pro-fat movement.

unfortunately once again the camels nose has been let in the tent on this identity politic and its going to be exploited to the fullest. I can see the social media shaming coming to the first airline that’s accused and the PR nightmare that follows.

Hedley 05-12-2023 06:12 PM

Airlines can figure out how many seats per flight would be affected by fat people spilling over into the next seat, hold those seats, and then spread that cost out among the rest of the passengers through higher ticket prices. If the blocked seats are not being used by a fat person, release them to revenue standby or non-rev pax. If a pilot is assigned a deadhead next to someone taking up half of their seat, just get off, call scheduling, and tell them to try again. I agree that people should pay for the space that they occupy and that others shouldn’t be inconvenienced because someone else spills over into theirs, but that isn’t PC.

WXS15 05-12-2023 06:41 PM


Originally Posted by Hedley (Post 3635873)
Airlines can figure out how many seats per flight would be affected by fat people spilling over into the next seat, hold those seats, and then spread that cost out among the rest of the passengers through higher ticket prices.

Airlines could do that, but why would they give up revenue? If the passenger demand is high enough that they could sell single seats at those higher rates, why would they A) not already be charging that rate and B) hold back pairs of seats for a single passenger that would literally be sold at half price?

symbian simian 05-12-2023 06:53 PM


Originally Posted by Hedley (Post 3635873)
Airlines can figure out how many seats per flight would be affected by fat people spilling over into the next seat, hold those seats, and then spread that cost out among the rest of the passengers through higher ticket prices. If the blocked seats are not being used by a fat person, release them to revenue standby or non-rev pax. If a pilot is assigned a deadhead next to someone taking up half of their seat, just get off, call scheduling, and tell them to try again. I agree that people should pay for the space that they occupy and that others shouldn’t be inconvenienced because someone else spills over into theirs, but that isn’t PC.

Sorry. but no. Generally treehugger, but if you can't fit in a seat, you should pay for two. We make people pay for carrying extra luggage, this is the same. I think we should start charging for seat belt extenders.

Hedley 05-13-2023 03:56 AM


Originally Posted by symbian simian (Post 3635896)
Sorry. but no. Generally treehugger, but if you can't fit in a seat, you should pay for two. We make people pay for carrying extra luggage, this is the same. I think we should start charging for seat belt extenders.

Couldn’t agree more. I should have specified if forced due to regulations or social pressure prohibiting discrimination against the undisciplined. If you take up two seats you should pay for both, just as those who take up one seat should expect to use all of it, but we live in a world where something as unhealthy as obesity is not only normalized, it’s celebrated.

JamesNoBrakes 05-15-2023 08:01 PM

Well yeah, but the obese population now makes up so much of the general population that, well, good luck with that. Doesn't matter if it's the left or right side of the aisle, literally, both are obese and both think it's "fat shaming" the moment you bring up living healthy and not being obese. We basically have set up ourselves for this with our city designs, letting businesses convince us that the most important things are to go to college, start a family and have kids, buy a house, etc., there's no time for healthy lifestyle or open natural areas you can get to just to stretch your legs. It's all about consumption, riding texas-wheelchairs (side-by-sides), e-bikes, short-cuts, making life so easy that you just get fat...

John Carr 05-15-2023 08:38 PM


Originally Posted by JamesNoBrakes (Post 3637042)
Well yeah, but the obese population now makes up so much of the general population that, well, good luck with that. Doesn't matter if it's the left or right side of the aisle, literally, both are obese and both think it's "fat shaming" the moment you bring up living healthy and not being obese. We basically have set up ourselves for this with our city designs, letting businesses convince us that the most important things are to go to college, start a family and have kids, buy a house, etc., there's no time for healthy lifestyle or open natural areas you can get to just to stretch your legs. It's all about consumption, riding texas-wheelchairs (side-by-sides), e-bikes, short-cuts, making life so easy that you just get fat...

In typical fashion, we could learn a lot from dogs. Do the usual "dog years' conversion";

https://www.avma.org/javma-news/2019...-shorter-lives

But then again, just let them go, Darwinism sort it out, etc.....

Grumpyaviator 05-16-2023 08:13 AM

Fat-shaming is inappropriate, but maybe society should stop coddling and enabling those who are living unhealthy lifestyles. Obesity related illnesses are the leading cause of death among black females and they’re being glamorized and encouraged to live a life that will kill them prematurely.

Hedley 05-16-2023 08:52 AM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by Grumpyaviator (Post 3637207)
Fat-shaming is inappropriate, but maybe society should stop coddling and enabling those who are living unhealthy lifestyles. Obesity related illnesses are the leading cause of death among black females and they’re being glamorized and encouraged to live a life that will kill them prematurely.

Unfortunately we live in a world where feelings trump facts.

DownWithNarita 05-18-2023 03:18 PM

Here's another.

https://twitter.com/ben_kew/status/1...140823552?s=20

Wingtip220 05-18-2023 07:50 PM


Originally Posted by DownWithNarita (Post 3638219)

same story from the NY Post. United is the first to be accused. Who’s next

https://nypost.com/2023/05/18/i-cant...iscrimination/

Hedley 05-19-2023 05:30 AM


Originally Posted by Wingtip220 (Post 3638315)
same story from the NY Post. United is the first to be accused. Who’s next

https://nypost.com/2023/05/18/i-cant...iscrimination/

Being that the video is obviously from a Polaris cabin, am I the only one that finds it funny that she can’t fit down the aisle of a “widebody”?

Profane Kahuna 05-19-2023 05:38 PM

Ticket prices should be by the pound

TransWorld 05-19-2023 07:11 PM

It strikes me unlimited snacks and fat are a spiral. One creates more of the other.

highfarfast 05-19-2023 09:17 PM


Originally Posted by TransWorld (Post 3638941)
It strikes me unlimited snacks and fat are a spiral. One creates more of the other.

Every time I see this thread title, I can’t help but think of the irony. It’s probably intentional.

TransWorld 05-20-2023 08:48 AM


Originally Posted by highfarfast (Post 3638990)
Every time I see this thread title, I can’t help but think of the irony. It’s probably intentional.

I’m trying to lose weight. Get me a Diet Coke and a couple of candy bars.

LAXtoDEN 05-20-2023 08:50 AM


Originally Posted by TransWorld (Post 3639159)
I’m trying to lose weight. Get me a Diet Coke and a couple of candy bars.

“the full can please”

I’ll make a deal. When they get off their ass and go on a real diet, they can get their bigger seats. What happens is the seat gets bigger because they got smaller.

Grumpyaviator 05-20-2023 11:43 AM


Originally Posted by DownWithNarita (Post 3638219)


her pronouns are kilograms and pounds

TransWorld 05-21-2023 08:17 AM


Originally Posted by Grumpyaviator (Post 3639226)
her pronouns are kilograms and pounds

Those are weighty pronouns.

John Carr 05-21-2023 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by TransWorld (Post 3639632)
Those are weighty pronouns.

Probably likes Kilos better, smaller number and all.

covid19 05-21-2023 12:21 PM


Originally Posted by John Carr (Post 3639680)
Probably likes Kilos better, smaller number and all.

Well, we better got go to stones. Even a smaller number. The morbidly obese can once again feel normal.

at6d 05-21-2023 06:10 PM

This is a heavy topic.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:40 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands