![]() |
Evidence that unions have a purpose
I'm just at the beginning of the long climb up the ladder to what will hopefully be a successful career in aviation. What will be there for me when I get to the top will be whatever the pilots before me accepted or demanded. It is easy to forget that unions were created for a reason; they so rarely move with purpose that it is easy to forget that they can and why they do. When they don't, it is usually a sign of the good times... but times are not so good right now. All I can say is that I'm glad that the DAL ALPA folks have activated their unity to make a point. When things like what happened today happen it is the mechanism by which the industry recalibrates back to reality. The union is there to make sure the airlines understand the value and legitimate demands of their pilots, something easily forgotten in the numbers game of business. Delta pilots DID act out of self-interest as many of you have complained about, but in so doing they create a standard for the treatment of pilots and what they ought to be able to expect. Is it unreasonable to expect a contract that was signed in good faith to not be thrown out? These people have freely given away their pensions and prospects for a decent retirement while losing wages with which to live for now and save for the now uncertain future with. All I can say is that I am greatful that DAL pilots have used the tool that is available to them to draw a line in the sand, for themselves knowingly.. but perhaps unknowingly for me to still have a CAREER to look forward to in a few years. Thanks all!
|
Originally Posted by Imeneo
I suppose that if there is a stike at Delta soon, the company will tank. Then everyone, including the pilots, will end up screwing themselves while the executives will land softly elsewhere on golden parachutes.
It makes no sense to strike when a company is on the verge of collapse... I say weather the storm and when things get better, demand for pay raises. If that doesn't work, at least then a stike would not destroy the company, but make it lose enough money to get investors to pressure management to talk to the unions. I've been reading quite a few threads here and it seems that there is a high level of pride on the employee side of the airlines... so much so that they are willing to destroy a company and put themselves out of work rather than work for less. It must be understood that the airline industry is a high cost, low margin industry with little competative advantages between companies (especially when everything that an airline does in terms of strategy is a matter of public record). As long as there are more pilots than there are airline jobs, airlines will push for lower wages... and as long as people are willing to pay no more than $79 each way to Fort Myers, airlines are not going to raise salaries either. |
Originally Posted by fireman0174
Years ago, in the 1980's when Hank Duffy was it's President, ALPA had a public educational program similar to what you're suggesting.
It was funded by volunteer donations from ALPA pilots, not regular union dues. Unfortunately the program lasted a very short time because not enough members contributed to it. :( |
Originally Posted by captain_drew
HEAR! . . HEAR!!
WELL SAID . . . but you were W-A-A-A-Y too polite <G> . . shoulda told him ‘FO’ . . and that isn’t a ‘seat position’ :p |
RedeyeAV8r, It was not Skywriting who made the comments you replied to... apparently the quote option does not work on his computer... Those were MY earlier comments.
Originally Posted by RedeyeAV8r
To Skywriting
Point 1: I don't work for Delta but these guys/gals have already given in most cases in excess of a 50% cut in Pay & Benefits last year. What did their MGT do with the billions in concessions? Apparently, management is asking for more from the empolyees people with the highest pay scales... the unions may have bargained down from what was earlier deemed necessary by management. Point 2. If you were currently working in the industry and had experience with collective bargining your opinions would carry some weight, however, You do not and they don't. I'm not really sure why this is being brought up... people are entitled to opinion and rational thinking. Point 3. The whole point of collective bargining to have a Legal right to ask for Quid pro Quo when in discussions (negotiations) with MGT, both in Good times and the Bad. The Delta Pilots have a contract. All they are asking is for MGT to bargin...........not dictate. There is nothing wrong with this, but it seems that pilots are unwilling to take any paycuts in the mainline when they are the only employees making in excess of 80K. Where else is the company supposed to take cuts?... FA's, baggage handlers... those people make less than nothing to start out with... IF Executive bonuses are cancelled, this usually means little and will only be a respectful formality because bonuses in certain cases are usually given in company stock options, rather than cash. All emloyees at delta are suffering... particularly those who only make $9.00 or so an hour. And now the pilots want to strike during difficult times at Delta and run the airline into the ground... and put everyone out of work. I have a feeling that non-pilots are not on the same boat in terms of striking. Most Delta mainline pilots after the cuts will be making well above the national average income. I think this is reasonable considering difficult times. When times are GOOD then pay-raises and added benefits are always a good thing and there will be NO objections from my side of the fence. Let's all pray that this striking issue will be resolved quickly and not to the detriment of the company. Point 4 is probably the most important. If it wasn't for collective bargining in the first place (Meaning Unions) you probably would not want this Job anyway. The Delta Pilots are a professional bunch and they know what they are facing...................Why do you think 95% of them voted to strike? Do you really think 5400 hundred pilots would just arbitrarily vote to strike?..................That is their last legal method to attempt to get their MGT tp bargain in good faith..............Just like the NW Pilots were faced with a month ago. I may want this job, but I may not have it if the Delta strike drives Delta out of business... then a little guy like me after schooling will have a couple hundred hours compared to the thousands of hours ex-Delta guys will have... as well as ex-Indy air pilots, as well as all the furloughed and laid off pilots across the country. I think in the end if this stike ends Delta, it would be because pilots have too much pride and too little concern for other people (new pilots and non-pilot employees alike). Point 5. Unions having too much power?....Pleeeaasssse. Can unions stop Corp Exces from getting Multi Million in bonuses afer they squander Billions and running Airlines into bankruptcy? Can Unions get MGT to price their product where they can make a profit? Can unions save the corporate pension fiasco?All the Unions can say is enough is enough and that is what you are seeing presently. In an earlier post I retracted this opinion... I don't have the time or capability to gather the references to verify my claim... so I won't go into this any further. Point 6. If you do get into the industry, I would love to hear your opinions after a year or so on the line. Until then, I suggest that you Sit back, watch, learn and keep your uniformed "outside looking in" opinions to a minimum................ If I ended up hating flying for the airlines after a year... I'll quit. Just like any other industry if the working conditions aren't satisfactory for an individual they can just post their resume and move on. Most pilots are well educated, but very demoralized... this is quite perplexing... if a person hates a job enough, they should quit for their own benefit... not drive the industry to the ground because of bad feelings. This brings another gripe that I have with the airlines... pensions... unless they can be taken on by new employers or transferred from career to career then they need to be phased out (with the new generation) and converted into personal investment schemes that can follow an individual regardless of employer or career choice. I think ultimately it is adherence to pensions (among other things) that keep pilots unhappy and immobile... two of the things that are poison in the employee pools of big business. Just one pilot's opinion who has been in the industry for 20+ years and just like many of my bretheren who post here, I've been thru negotiations x 6, paycuts after paycuts, furloughs. mergers, strikes, staring over 3 times. I am fortunate enough to currently be employed by a very profitable company. I have seen it all except for the Divorce and that is one I hope to avoid. I for one understand what the Delta (and other Pilot groups are facing) I know they face a very tough choice. But I for one admire them and support them 100%. Who knows I may be faced with the same choice in the coming year. I understand and respect your experiences and opinions concerning this issue, however there are repeated concerns of mine that have yet to be addressed. I'm hoping that eventually someone will give me solid, common sense answers that I can understand. |
Originally Posted by Imeneo
Apparently, management is asking for more from the empolyees people with the highest pay scales... the unions may have bargained down from what was earlier deemed necessary by management.[QOUTE]
Again your Ignorance........Delta MGT is asking a bankruptcy judge to void the existing contract of Delta Pilots......They are not just asking for more Pay cuts, they want to completely gut the contract, the importance of which you don't seem to comprehend! [QOUTE] There is nothing wrong with this, but it seems that pilots are unwilling to take any paycuts in the mainline when they are the only employees making in excess of 80K. Where else is the company supposed to take cuts?... FA's, baggage handlers... those people make less than nothing to start out with... IF Executive bonuses are cancelled, this usually means little and will only be a respectful formality because bonuses in certain cases are usually given in company stock options, rather than cash.[QOUTE] [COLOR="Red"]MGT is coming backto the PILOTS for more pay cuts "AGAIN" after thaey gave 1 billion already........The Delta Pilots already gave BIG concessions last year...........what is it about that you don't understand?/COLOR] [QOUTE] I may want this job, but I may not have it if the Delta strike drives Delta out of business... [QOUTE] You probably won't have the chance if Delta MGT gets their way due to the lack of protections offered by the contracts, i.e more furloughs ahead........ [QOUTE] If I ended up hating flying for the airlines after a year... I'll quit. Just like any other industry if the working conditions aren't satisfactory for an individual they can just post their resume and move on. Most pilots are well educated, but very demoralized... this is quite perplexing... if a person hates a job enough, they should quit for their own benefit... not drive the industry to the ground because of bad feelings.This brings another gripe that I have with the airlines... pensions... unless they can be taken on by new employers or transferred from career to career then they need to be phased out (with the new generation) and converted into personal investment schemes that can follow an individual regardless of employer or career choice. I think ultimately it is adherence to pensions (among other things) that keep pilots unhappy and immobile... two of the things that are poison in the employee pools of big business.[QOUTE] Again your ignorance..........It is seniority that keeps pilots tied to a particular company! [QOUTE]I understand and respect your experiences and opinions concerning this issue, however there are repeated concerns of mine that have yet to be addressed.I'm hoping that eventually someone will give me solid, common sense answers that I can understand. |
Originally Posted by Imeneo
Apparently, management is asking for more from the empolyees people with the highest pay scales... the unions may have bargained down from what was earlier deemed necessary by management.
Originally Posted by Imeneo
I think in the end if this stike ends Delta, it would be because pilots have too much pride and too little concern for other people (new pilots and non-pilot employees alike).
Do us all a favor and QUIT FLYING and choose another career. |
Originally Posted by 757Driver
Once again your ignoring the fact that MANAGEMENT isn't part of these extensive cuts. If the Pilots are asked to take a 50% cut than management, (the HIGHEST paid people at Delta), should take 75% ones, right? News flash Imbecileo, they aren't and have no plans to do so.
I hope, for our sake, that you never become employed by a major carrier. Its blatantly obvious that you'll fit in perfectly as a Scab, Chief Pilot or other suck-ass management type who has not one iota of concern for his fellow Airman. Try spouting that rhetoric once you get the job and you may find yourself upside down in the nearest trashcan. Do us all a favor and QUIT FLYING and choose another career. You have quite an immature way of expressing yourself... personal attacks and other childish games. I'm 24 and I express my opinions as opinions... and nothing more or less. If you have something to enlighten me with, enlighten me... I am willing to be learn. But don't use childish games to humilate those you disagree with while offering little of substance in return... it simply isn't becoming of your rank as an aircraft officer. |
Originally Posted by RedeyeAV8r
Again your ignorance..........It is seniority that keeps pilots tied to a particular company!
|
Originally Posted by RedeyeAV8r
To Skywriting
Point 1: I don't work for Delta but these guys/gals have already given in most cases in excess of a 50% cut in Pay & Benefits last year. What did their MGT do with the billions in concessions? Point 2. If you were currently working in the industry and had experience with collective bargining your opinions would carry some weight, however, You do not and they don't. Point 3. The whole point of collective bargining to have a Legal right to ask for Quid pro Quo when in discussions (negotiations) with MGT, both in Good times and the Bad. The Delta Pilots have a contract. All they are asking is for MGT to bargin...........not dictate. Point 4 is probably the most important. If it wasn't for collective bargining in the first place (Meaning Unions) you probably would not want this Job anyway. The Delta Pilots are a professional bunch and they know what they are facing...................Why do you think 95% of them voted to strike? Do you really think 5400 hundred pilots would just arbitrarily vote to strike?..................That is their last legal method to attempt to get their MGT tp bargain in good faith..............Just like the NW Pilots were faced with a month ago. Point 5. Unions having too much power?....Pleeeaasssse. Can unions stop Corp Exces from getting Multi Million in bonuses afer they squander Billions and running Airlines into bankruptcy? Can Unions get MGT to price their product where they can make a profit? Can unions save the corporate pension fiasco?All the Unions can say is enough is enough and that is what you are seeing presently. Point 6. If you do get into the industry, I would love to hear your opinions after a year or so on the line. Until then, I suggest that you Sit back, watch, learn and keep your uniformed "outside looking in" opinions to a minimum................ Just one pilot's opinion who has been in the industry for 20+ years and just like many of my bretheren who post here, I've been thru negotiations x 6, paycuts after paycuts, furloughs. mergers, strikes, staring over 3 times. I am fortunate enough to currently be employed by a very profitable company. I have seen it all except for the Divorce and that is one I hope to avoid. I for one understand what the Delta (and other Pilot groups are facing) I know they face a very tough choice. But I for one admire them and support them 100%. Who knows I may be faced with the same choice in the coming year. |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:32 PM. |
Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands