Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   Spirit, the multi million dollar mistake! (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/92237-spirit-multi-million-dollar-mistake.html)

RalphWiggum 12-17-2015 05:47 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Din (Post 2029289)
Why would the company really care if they've got high turn over? Assuming the company can keep pilots long enough to recoup their initial training costs;
1) keeps average wages way down
2) allows them to advertise quick upgrades and 3) keeps the any real culture and solidarity at a minimum.

As long as we pay above RJ Fo or CFI wages the bottom of the barrel will still apply. That's why NC needs to really focus on FO pay too. We need quality guys.

you're not understanding what i said. I said if it exceeds their ability to staff the airline (new hires, upgrades) and all the deliveries we have on order. They don't care about turnover. There is a difference.

Fltattndpkr 12-17-2015 06:02 AM

I hate to get into the middle if this, but I am new to this site and have an interview with spirit. After reading this forum I'm not so sure I even want to go.
I have been a regional Capt for 3 yes seems the pay scale the company has proposed is no better than where I am.
Ya you have brand new aircraft but why come to spirit to be responsible for more people and be paid so poorly.....Thoughts

Chimpy 12-17-2015 06:13 AM

I guess the good thing about this this thread is that managament reads APC and maybe they'll see how insulting their proposal was.

Whether or not they care is another thing



Originally Posted by Fltattndpkr (Post 2029308)
I hate to get into the middle if this, but I am new to this site and have an interview with spirit. After reading this forum I'm not so sure I even want to go.
I have been a regional Capt for 3 yes seems the pay scale the company has proposed is no better than where I am.
Ya you have brand new aircraft but why come to spirit to be responsible for more people and be paid so poorly.....Thoughts

Spirit may currently appear to be a dead end job (subject to change!)but it's less of a dead end job than a regional. You have no decision to make
Until you are offered a class. Worst case, you get an AIRBUS type and see what our next contract brings. Nobody says you can't leave

BillyBaroo 12-17-2015 06:22 AM


Originally Posted by Fltattndpkr (Post 2029308)
I hate to get into the middle if this, but I am new to this site and have an interview with spirit. After reading this forum I'm not so sure I even want to go.
I have been a regional Capt for 3 yes seems the pay scale the company has proposed is no better than where I am.
Ya you have brand new aircraft but why come to spirit to be responsible for more people and be paid so poorly.....Thoughts

Its a personal choice that you will certainly have to weigh the pros and cons of where you are and where you want to be at any point in time, most likely by retirement. Many of the posts on this and other threads give good insight, so do your due diligence and read through them (albeit with a grain of salt). Yes we are in section 6 negotiations, and yes at the current time we are much lower than our peers in many areas. However, the current contract was signed over 5 years ago, resulting in leap frogging of peer groups with their own CBA. One day your at the bottom, the next at or near the top, etc. One thing I often tell myself is even with all the crap we may put up with, the worst day here is still better than the best day at my former regional. "At the end of the day" each regional is still a sub-contractor regardless if your a wholly owned. We have seen where regionals can be bought/sold/ at a whim. Whipsawing IMHO will always be prevalent and a factor at each regional airline. Although times are good now with improvements to pay and other QOL advancements to regionals in this cycle, what will happen during the next economic downturn is anyone's guess. Again, when the music inevitably stops, will you have that proverbial chair......

rvr1800 12-17-2015 06:23 AM


Originally Posted by F9 Driver (Post 2029297)
We've got the lowest rates in the industry. It's a fact too. We just came through bankruptcy without a single work rule touched, but that's for another discussion.

The only reason I chime in is to point out that the peer group you use in contract negotiations is NEGOTIATED. The company says "Spirit and Frontier" and ALPA had best say "American and SWA". Eventually you meet in the middle somewhere.

That the ugly house down the block exists and affects your property value may be a fact, but they may scrape it and build one that makes yours look like a POS.

It is all a big cycle that's been going on for years. The difference seems to be the public forums for venting, the age 65 rule having recently stalled so many plans (you were warned not to bet your mortgages on) and the entitled mentality so pervasive in every facet of today's society.

Rant over. Good luck with your contract!

Great post. I agree with everything you said.

I didn't post my comment with the intention of making this a Jetblue vs spirit argument. We have our own problems that we're trying to fix with our first ALPA contract. I only pointed that out because Smails and Rainbows came on here attacking the OP and telling him to "just quit". That's such a juvenile argument I felt I had to speak up.

RalphWiggum 12-17-2015 06:34 AM


Originally Posted by Chimpy (Post 2029315)
I guess the good thing about this this thread is that managament reads APC and maybe they'll see how insulting their proposal was.

Whether or not they care is another thing




Spirit may currently appear to be a dead end job (subject to change!)but it's less of a dead end job than a regional. You have no decision to make
Until you are offered a class. Worst case, you get an AIRBUS type and see what our next contract brings. Nobody says you can't leave

Precisely. The sky isn't falling. It's frustrating but at least you'll come into this eyes wide open. We have great pilots and it's mostly a good place to work. worst case scenario you get the type and quit for a better job.

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 06:39 AM


Originally Posted by Rainbows (Post 2029158)
We ain't saying a new contract with increased pay rates and retirement while holding on to our QOL rules isn't what we want. I'm saying their going about it the wrong way. And how do you mean we're dragging down the rest of the industry? How about the other carriers who don't have four days off between pairings, or transition conflict, or line bidding or sweet vacation rules, or nice inexpensive insurance? Huh? Are they dragging down the industry? How about those pilot groups who have given up scope, allowed code sharing, a and b plans, etc, they dragging down the industry? Please, you gotta be a special kind of stupid if you think the legacies are sitting looking across the negotiating table quoting Spirit's rates to its pilots. :rolleyes:

*they're

You will find any way you can to justify your industry leading concessionary wages won't you?

4 days off between 6 day work blocks. Pretty sweet brah. And yes, your rates do take away the negotiating power legacy pilots have. Are they helping?

BiminiBendo 12-17-2015 06:47 AM

Hey guys, can you tell me exactly how much those regional FOs make?...... Just curious.

Don't forget that we have free smiles here guys!

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 07:01 AM


Originally Posted by Chimpy (Post 2029315)
I guess the good thing about this this thread is that managament reads APC and maybe they'll see how insulting their proposal was.

Whether or not they care is another thing




Spirit may currently appear to be a dead end job (subject to change!)but it's less of a dead end job than a regional. You have no decision to make
Until you are offered a class. Worst case, you get an AIRBUS type and see what our next contract brings. Nobody says you can't leave

A 220 passenger, A321 is a stepping stone now? That's a new low. You do realize you are actually taking passengers from higher paying legacy jobs right, same jobs you keep your apps updated for?
Now if you weren't doing it at such a discount it wouldn't be an issue (the argument being it's actually a legit business model rather than than depending on cheap labor that doesn't realize their own value subsidizing growth and maintaining profit margins).

Fltattndpkr 12-17-2015 07:04 AM


Originally Posted by BiminiBendo (Post 2029340)
Hey guys, can you tell me exactly how much those regional FOs make?...... Just curious.

Don't forget that we have free smiles here guys!

First year is in the 40's now. 2nd year 43 1st year capt (3rd yr seniority) $80..
Most Rjs carrying 70 pax

Ya and we had those crappy pins years ago to..."Busted" for doing something good...

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 07:05 AM


Originally Posted by BiminiBendo (Post 2029340)
Hey guys, can you tell me exactly how much those regional FOs make?...... Just curious.

Don't forget that we have free smiles here guys!

Regional | AirlinePilotCentral.com

Lakeaffect 12-17-2015 08:09 AM


Originally Posted by Chimpy (Post 2029315)
I guess the good thing about this this thread is that managament reads APC and maybe they'll see how insulting their proposal was.

Whether or not they care is another thing




Spirit may currently appear to be a dead end job (subject to change!)but it's less of a dead end job than a regional. You have no decision to make
Until you are offered a class. Worst case, you get an AIRBUS type and see what our next contract brings. Nobody says you can't leave

I think "but it's better than my regional" is exactly what management wants to hear. keeping a nice stream of applications whilst paying rock bottom wages.

Cruise 12-17-2015 08:14 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029336)
*they're

You will find any way you can to justify your industry leading concessionary wages won't you?

4 days off between 6 day work blocks. Pretty sweet brah. And yes, your rates do take away the negotiating power legacy pilots have. Are they helping?


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029359)
A 220 passenger, A321 is a stepping stone now? That's a new low. You do realize you are actually taking passengers from higher paying legacy jobs right, same jobs you keep your apps updated for?
Now if you weren't doing it at such a discount it wouldn't be an issue (the argument being it's actually a legit business model rather than than depending on cheap labor that doesn't realize their own value subsidizing growth and maintaining profit margins).


Trolling DAL troll is trolling! So appreciative to have your insight here. Thanks!

Gunga Galunga 12-17-2015 08:23 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029359)
A 220 passenger, A321 is a stepping stone now? That's a new low. You do realize you are actually taking passengers from higher paying legacy jobs right, same jobs you keep your apps updated for?
Now if you weren't doing it at such a discount it wouldn't be an issue (the argument being it's actually a legit business model rather than than depending on cheap labor that doesn't realize their own value subsidizing growth and maintaining profit margins).

Oh great another double breasted sky God chimes in to whine about how Spirit, Emirates, regionals etc are taking your jobs away.

My question is simple to you. How do you come on here and troll when your E190 rates max at $139 an hour in THE LEFT SEAT? You're taking away E190 pax from JetBlue with those bottom feeding rates!!

You'll probably read this after you get done charging your golf cart after telling everyone in Peachtree City you're a Delta pilot. Until then $uck it

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 08:34 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Galunga (Post 2029448)
Oh great another double breasted sky God chimes in to whine about how Spirit, Emirates, regionals etc are taking your jobs away.

My question is simple to you. How do you come on here and troll when your E190 rates max at $139 an hour in THE LEFT SEAT? You're taking away E190 pax from JetBlue with those bottom feeding rates!!

You'll probably read this after you get done charging your golf cart after telling everyone in Peachtree City you're a Delta pilot. Until then $uck it

That will change soon my friend. They will soon be better than your airbus rates.

Gunga Galunga 12-17-2015 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029456)
That will change soon my friend. They will soon be better than your airbus rates.

Don't hold your breath buddy. It'll be a while before Richard hands over $50/HR + to you guys. He has the cheapest 190 pilots in the industry now. Plus he needs to make the point that you can't vote down a contract and automatically get one better. It won't be the gift you make it out to be to save face here. By that time our Airbus rates will be just fine.

Until then- make sure you wear your hat.

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by Cruise (Post 2029434)
Trolling DAL troll is trolling! So appreciative to have your insight here. Thanks!

Someone has to balance out the "amazing QOL" guys that come on here all the time and fight against fighting for a decent wage. You guys never have good arguments; just filler. again, another Spirit pilot with no insight whatsoever.

Packrat 12-17-2015 08:39 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029359)
A 220 passenger, A321 is a stepping stone now? That's a new low. You do realize you are actually taking passengers from higher paying legacy jobs right, same jobs you keep your apps updated for?

Ding! Ding! Ding! We have a winner!


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029359)
Now if you weren't doing it at such a discount it wouldn't be an issue (the argument being it's actually a legit business model rather than than depending on cheap labor that doesn't realize their own value subsidizing growth and maintaining profit margins).

That Airbus SJS blinds a lot of guys to the harm they do to the entire profession. every load of passengers who elect the ULCCs means fewer pilots at the legacies. Some people just don't get the connection to their own detriment.

Why not just shoot yourself in the foot and get it over with?

DickBurns 12-17-2015 08:43 AM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2029460)
Ding! Ding! Ding! We have a winner!



That Airbus SJS blinds a lot of guys to the harm they do to the entire profession. every load of passengers who elect the ULCCs means fewer pilots at the legacies. Some people just don't get the connection.

You make it sound like you're not a pilot unless you're a legacy pilot. Yeah, we are taking your passengers. We are your competitors! Regional pilots flying YOUR passengers at crap rates is another story.

Gunga Galunga 12-17-2015 09:02 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029459)
Someone has to balance out the "amazing QOL" guys that come on here all the time and fight against fighting for a decent wage. You guys never have good arguments; just filler. again, another Spirit pilot with no insight whatsoever.

Make sure you fly that E190 for 139 and $95 an hour! Hypocrite

Packrat 12-17-2015 09:06 AM


Originally Posted by DickBurns (Post 2029463)
Yeah, we are taking your passengers. We are your competitors! Regional pilots flying YOUR passengers at crap rates is another story.

The hole in your logic is Spirit isn't flying in regional markets. You are competing head to head with the legacies while undercutting pilot wages/benefits.

Do the math. Again, every plane load you fly in a major market is one less plane load for the Legacies. And YOU want to "upgrade" to a legacy flight deck?

"Oh, I have another foot. Let's shoot that one, too!"

rightside02 12-17-2015 09:10 AM

Nearly 6 pages of this thread and I haven't actually yet understood what this thread is about ...


Although, as usual it's turned into a Delta versus the world thread

Man hatters gonna hate , to each his own

DickBurns 12-17-2015 09:14 AM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2029485)
The hole in your logic is Spirit isn't flying in regional markets. You are competing head to head with the legacies while undercutting pilot wages/benefits.

Do the math. Again, every plane load you fly in a major market is one less plane load for the Legacies. And YOU want to "upgrade" to a legacy flight deck?

"Oh, I have another foot. Let's shoot that one, too!"

What are you talking about? Who said I want to go to a legacy? You're assuming that we all want to leave. Also, what would you have said 5 years ago about our contract? I bet any US Air guy would have given a lot for it! Inevitably we will get a good contract and be back where we need to be with pay and benefits. And inevitably we will keep expanding from major hub to major hub. And, god willing, we keep taking passengers from you guys well into the future. You see, my friend, I work for Spirit and I hope to keep working here for a very long time. We are your COMPETITORS! Get it?

Packrat 12-17-2015 09:16 AM

Yeah, I get it. Glad you're proud of the fact that you're stabbing your ALPA brothers in the back by flying for substandard pay/benefits.

Good for you. Looks like Spirit found a low self-esteem sucker.

Chimpy 12-17-2015 09:17 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029359)
A 220 passenger, A321 is a stepping stone now? That's a new low. You do realize you are actually taking passengers from higher paying legacy jobs right, same jobs you keep your apps updated for?
Now if you weren't doing it at such a discount it wouldn't be an issue (the argument being it's actually a legit business model rather than than depending on cheap labor that doesn't realize their own value subsidizing growth and maintaining profit margins).

I didn't say that at all. I told him to come here and see what the next contract brings. If it's higher pay and a good retirement, he's already here. If it is a long drawn out process or inferior, leave. Pretty simple.

Also, you're a fool if you think pilot labor costs have that much of an impact on our margins, or any airlines for that matter

Packrat 12-17-2015 09:18 AM


Originally Posted by Chimpy (Post 2029495)
If it is a long drawn out process or inferior, leave. Pretty simple

Typical RLA negotiations go 2 to 5 years past their amendable date. Factor that in....

DickBurns 12-17-2015 09:20 AM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2029494)
Yeah, I get it. Glad you're proud of the fact that you're stabbing your ALPA brothers in the back by flying for substandard pay/benefits.

Good for you. Looks like Spirit found a low self-esteem sucker.

We are in negotiations, genius. Should we all just quit and hope that the legacy gods will shine their light down upon us?

Packrat 12-17-2015 09:24 AM


Originally Posted by DickBurns (Post 2029499)
We are in negotiations, genius. Should we all just quit and hope that the legacy gods will shine their light down upon us?

Again, typical RLA pilot negotiations drag out 2 to 5 years past their amendable date. Do you really think Spirit has any intention of giving up poor pilot pay rates anytime soon?

The key word in RLA contracts is "amendable". There is never a termination date. You could be working for your current rates for years to come.

And "retro" pay? Perhaps a "signing bonus." But full retro is a pipe dream.

DickBurns 12-17-2015 09:32 AM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2029503)
Again, typical RLA pilot negotiations drag out 2 to 5 years past their amendable date. Do you really think Spirit has any intention of giving up poor pilot pay rates anytime soon?

The key word in RLA contracts is "amendable". There is never a termination date. You could be working for your current rates for years to come.

And "retro" pay? Perhaps a "signing bonus." But full retro is a pipe dream.

Well, let's burn this place down and hand the keys to you guys! All hope is lost!

Listen, buddy. We're doing our best to get a leading contract. I'm sure we will get a much better deal soon enough. I'm confident that our guys won't ratify anything less. In the meantime, our job is to keep doing our job. Flying from major city to major city is what we do here. We aren't flying passengers on an rj that bought tickets on your website for **** wages. That is where your gripe needs to be.

Dr Pepper 12-17-2015 09:50 AM


Originally Posted by Packrat (Post 2029485)
The hole in your logic is Spirit isn't flying in regional markets. You are competing head to head with the legacies while undercutting pilot wages/benefits.

Do the math. Again, every plane load you fly in a major market is one less plane load for the Legacies. And YOU want to "upgrade" to a legacy flight deck?

"Oh, I have another foot. Let's shoot that one, too!"


Packrat I believe you fly for Alaska? If so you guys didnt exactly bang it out of the park with your recent contract. Talk about undercutting, Wow.
At least our contract is 5 years old what's your excuse?

Chimpy 12-17-2015 09:54 AM


Originally Posted by Dr Pepper (Post 2029527)
Packrat I believe you fly for Alaska? If so you guys didnt exactly bang it out of the park with your recent contract. Talk about undercutting, Wow.
At least our contract is 5 years old what's your excuse?

Hahahahahha are you serious? I thought he flew for Delta?

ALASKA? The nerve.............

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 10:16 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Galunga (Post 2029458)
Don't hold your breath buddy. It'll be a while before Richard hands over $50/HR + to you guys. He has the cheapest 190 pilots in the industry now. Plus he needs to make the point that you can't vote down a contract and automatically get one better. It won't be the gift you make it out to be to save face here. By that time our Airbus rates will be just fine.

Until then- make sure you wear your hat.

Are you serious? He said we couldn't have 190's unless we voted TA1 in. Guess what, we have 190's. TA2 is going to make him pay for them. It will be good for the company and good for us. The pilots actually have the leverage right now, too bad you guys can't see that. Whats happening to the regionals right now will creep into the LCC's as far as attrition goes.

And how much negotiating capital should they have negotiated for a CRJ900/EMB rates back in 2012 for an airplane they didn't have on property? You need to go to bizness skool.

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 10:19 AM


Originally Posted by DickBurns (Post 2029512)
Well, let's burn this place down and hand the keys to you guys! All hope is lost!

Listen, buddy. We're doing our best to get a leading contract. I'm sure we will get a much better deal soon enough. I'm confident that our guys won't ratify anything less. In the meantime, our job is to keep doing our job. Flying from major city to major city is what we do here. We aren't flying passengers on an rj that bought tickets on your website for **** wages. That is where your gripe needs to be.

I bet if you extrapolate the wages and apply them to a 220 seat A321, you are flying for ****ty wages and the tickets were sold on website.

DickBurns 12-17-2015 10:23 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029549)
I bet if you extrapolate the wages and apply them to a 220 seat A321, you are flying for ****ty wages and the tickets were sold on website.

Which is why we are not going to settle for a lousy deal.

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 10:28 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Galunga (Post 2029482)
Make sure you fly that E190 for 139 and $95 an hour! Hypocrite

Really? You are going to bring up rates for an aircraft that isn't on property yet? TA2 my friend, have some patience. Keep updating your app, maybe you will get your call. I can't wait to come back to this thread when TA comes and it tops out at $200 bucks an hour, like the 717 (+15% DC +23% PS). But yeah, I don't get 4 days off between 6 days work blocks.

Spirit Airlines | AirlinePilotCentral.com

Window_Seat 12-17-2015 10:30 AM


Originally Posted by DickBurns (Post 2029552)
Which is why we are not going to settle for a lousy deal.

Good, there you go. Don't sell yourself short. That is the point of all my posts/trolling. Too many guys think its awesome cause Spirit is better than a regional. You are flying 220 seat airplanes with a 20% profit margin. Time to get paid!

Chimpy 12-17-2015 10:42 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 2029560)
Good, there you go. Don't sell yourself short. That is the point of all my posts/trolling. Too many guys think its awesome cause Spirit is better than a regional. You are flying 220 seat airplanes with a 20% profit margin. Time to get paid!

This!

I come to work to get paid!

Time to pay up.

Also, let's not forget it was the SPIRIT pilots who last went on strike. I'm pretty confident we have a group here that is willing to fight if need be.

abbynormallaw 12-17-2015 11:05 AM


Originally Posted by Chimpy (Post 2029577)
This!

I come to work to get paid!

Time to pay up.

Also, let's not forget it was the SPIRIT pilots who last went on strike. I'm pretty confident we have a group here that is willing to fight if need be.

++++++1! Straight up!

Let's not make this a Delta vs Spirit vs Alaska vs JB..

Full circle from the OP, we need leverage! Having a problem filling classes might get us some.. Until then, it may be a long fight.. Hopefully a unified pilot group type fight!

SirHelios 12-17-2015 11:26 AM


Originally Posted by abbynormallaw (Post 2029603)
Hopefully a unified pilot group type fight!

This needs to start right now.

Packrat 12-17-2015 12:49 PM

I agree with these previous posters. You guys fly mainline jets on mainline routes. You NEED mainline pay. Period.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:04 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands