Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Arbitrator ruling on Pinnacle/Colgan (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/24027-arbitrator-ruling-pinnacle-colgan.html)

Stryker 03-26-2008 04:30 AM

*ding Ding* Round 2!!! Fight!:d

ToiletDuck 03-26-2008 04:54 AM


Originally Posted by tpersuit (Post 348588)
See, you did it again. Keep twisting everything I say. You only have one track way of defending yourself here and that is to say the other person is crying and attacking you.

Man, I'll be surprised what comes out of your mouth next.

Defending myself from? You keep acting like there is something I, or others, have to defend ourselves from.

nwa757 03-26-2008 05:53 AM


Originally Posted by Stryker (Post 348125)
what I am saying is that quite a few XJETers out there seem to want to put down everyone else when people are asking for honest and good information on ONLY THE COMPANY THEY ASKED ABOUT.

And dont think im just bashing XJETers... If they were hiring I definitely would apply there... I have nothing against the company. in fact my friend who works for XJET highly recommends it.....

ExpressJet pilots aren't putting people down. We're not mean, we're not bullies. It's actually a great pilot group. However, our mentality is that if people stop going to work for the worst airlines around, the better ones will persevere. What keeps Mesa, Colgan, Pinnacle running is pilot applications. A lot of people don't realize this. The 'regional is a regional' arguement is completely invalid. I can get you a XJT and Mesa contract and you can come to your own conclusions.

The other side is this. It can really be taken as an insult when another pilot group is willing to do your job for less. That really upsets a lot of people because it can be taken personally. A pilot at AWAC, Horizon, XJT, Comair, AE is trying to get ahead in life, support their family and have some job security yet all this is jeopardized daily by the lowest bidding, lowest paid, lowest work rules pilots.



...and back to the original post, it's not right that Pinnacle pilots and their profits bought Colgan their Q400s. The judge ruled so. Here's the analogy. UND buys 15 C172s and ups their tuition rates, then gives them to ERAU students to fly down in FL and ERAU lowers their tuition. What's fair and just about that?

ToiletDuck 03-26-2008 06:00 AM


Originally Posted by nwa757 (Post 348688)
ExpressJet pilots aren't putting people down. We're not mean, we're not bullies. It's actually a great pilot group. However, our mentality is that if people stop going to work for the worst airlines around, the better ones will persevere. What keeps Mesa, Colgan, Pinnacle running is pilot applications. A lot of people don't realize this. The 'regional is a regional' arguement is completely invalid. I can get you a XJT and Mesa contract and you can come to your own conclusions.

The other side is this. It can really be taken as an insult when another pilot group is willing to do your job for less. That really upsets a lot of people because it can be taken personally. A pilot at AWAC, Horizon, XJT, Comair, AE is trying to get ahead in life, support their family and have some job security yet all this is jeopardized daily by the lowest bidding, lowest paid, lowest work rules pilots.



...and back to the original post, it's not right that Pinnacle pilots and their profits bought Colgan their Q400s. The judge ruled so. Here's the analogy. UND buys 15 C172s and ups their tuition rates, then gives them to ERAU students to fly down in FL and ERAU lowers their tuition. What's fair and just about that?

You're point can be made but it seems most forget it's perfectly possible to fly for cheaper without sacrificing. Look at SWA. There are many corners companies cut that don't involve the pilot group. Aircraft expenses/financing, training department setup (owning sim vs contracting out), and all the other little things that cost more from ACARS to who does the performance. If you think it's the pilots pay that figures mostly into these operating costs then you're sadly mistaken. Some people need to accept the fact there are other/better ways a company could do business than the way their company is doing it.

mooney 03-26-2008 06:03 AM


Originally Posted by tpersuit (Post 348588)
See, you did it again. Keep twisting everything I say. You only have one track way of defending yourself here and that is to say the other person is crying and attacking you.

Man, I'll be surprised what comes out of your mouth next.


I hate to get involved in an internet ****ing match that goes nowhere, I prefer to go face to face. But typersuit, arent you the guy that ran to mommy and daddy in the majors forum and stared this post...


Some Colgan Pilots think they don't take flying away from CAL - check this post out (http://www.airlinepilotforums.com/im.../multipage.gif 1 2 3)
tpersuit

so I dont think anyone is twisting what you say. And yes I work for pinchanickle so I think I'd have more of a right of an argument about getting flying taken away by Colgan than you would at xjt, but thats not where im intending to go with this post.
Point is management and mainline decides who is flying it, dont blame the pilot group unless they are new hires at an alter-ego.

CAPIP1998 03-26-2008 06:05 AM

This is pointless and boring.

Anyone got any "real" information regarding the ruling?

mooney 03-26-2008 06:10 AM

ya i posted something a few posts back but it got hijacked again

shamrok 03-26-2008 10:03 AM

Originally Posted by nwa757

"The other side is this. It can really be taken as an insult when another pilot group is willing to do your job for less. That really upsets a lot of people because it can be taken personally. A pilot at AWAC, Horizon, XJT, Comair, AE is trying to get ahead in life, support their family and have some job security yet all this is jeopardized daily by the lowest bidding, lowest paid, lowest work rules pilots."







So your saying that those of us at CJC have no interest in getting ahead in life, could care less about supporting our families and don't want job security? That is the dumbest thing I have read here in a while. First of all, any pilot at any regional has already made efforts to get ahead in life. And for supporting our families, those of us that do have families, myself included, manage to make end's meet, a lot of us might have spouses that actually work too believe it or not which is called "dual income", and it's not always about how much you make but what you do with what you make. As for job security, in this industry? I dont think so. Having a family just means you dont spend the money on Ipods, Iphones and all the other little toys I see out there. Instead, you buy your child a pair shoes, take them to the museum, circus, whatever. It's part of growing up. You'll find out one day junior.

nwa757 03-27-2008 03:54 AM


Originally Posted by shamrok (Post 348852)

this is jeopardized daily by the lowest bidding, lowest paid, lowest work rules pilots."

So your saying that those of us at CJC have no interest in getting ahead in life, could care less about supporting our families and don't want job security?

Nice association there. Are you admitting that you went to work to join the non-union lowest bidding, lowest paid/work rules pilot group? Let us know how that helped our profession.

I have no doubt that you are trying to get ahead of life. We all are. We aren't going to get ahead in this profession if people keep applying to Colgan to fly the Q400 for peanuts. You know that Colgan/Pinnacle management doesn't want to pay you more. They are laughing all the way to the bank everytime a Q400 pushes out of the gate! 74 passengers, all kinds of revenue, just a portion to the crew.

Now just imagine if no one applied to work at Colgan. What do you think they would do? Just imagine.

shamrok 03-27-2008 06:16 AM


Originally Posted by nwa757 (Post 349415)
Nice association there. Are you admitting that you went to work to join the non-union lowest bidding, lowest paid/work rules pilot group? Let us know how that helped our profession.

I have no doubt that you are trying to get ahead of life. We all are. We aren't going to get ahead in this profession if people keep applying to Colgan to fly the Q400 for peanuts. You know that Colgan/Pinnacle management doesn't want to pay you more. They are laughing all the way to the bank everytime a Q400 pushes out of the gate! 74 passengers, all kinds of revenue, just a portion to the crew.

Now just imagine if no one applied to work at Colgan. What do you think they would do? Just imagine.

Well, you see I chose a company that would best suit my personal needs, not those of the industry. Why would I not choose a company that has much of what I am looking for such as good QOL? I would like to be home enough to see my 3 yr. old grow up rather than trying to "save the industry" and go somehwere which will not allow me to live in base. And relocation is not an option at this time. My family is more important to me than going to express jet so I can say I am saving the industry. Get over yourself! There are a lot more problems than Colgan in the biz.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:32 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands