This from Dallas Morning news or The Startle-Gram
To be fair last year APA Neg Committee members stormed out one morning.
What's an mediator to do? It's his or her job to keep them all in one room. It's his or her job to make progress.
Speaking on the phone with one of my pilot buddies who is divorced and went through divorce mediation in Florida. His mediator was really aggressive and forceful in trying to make negotiations happen, so much so that my buddy felt he was being railroaded. Finally his attorney said, "just walk out, leave and go to a pub."
Divorce mediators are monitored (graded) by the courts in their success rates. If they do not have a high %age of success in out of court settlements, then they less likely to be assigned work by the courts. Florida requires court ordered mediation for divorce before court date.
This contract seems more like a divorce than contract negotiations.
7576
UPDATE: AA, APA trade shots about negotiations
>
> 12:05 PM Thu, Apr 02, 2009
>
> Terry Maxon
>
> UPDATE: I originally reprinted an excerpt from the American Airlines update
> on pilot negotiations. Now I've seen the Allied Pilots Association update
> from the union's Wednesday hotline.
>
> So we'll just lay out the two versions of what happened Wednesday:
>
> Management's interpretation, from American Airlines Negotiations
>
> "The agenda for Wednesday morning was to discuss Scope-related issues,
> something that we recognize is a sensitive and important issue to pilots. AA
> negotiators began the session with an industry comparison on the competitive
> importance of commuter feed. Within minutes, it became evident that the
> behavior of APA's negotiating committee chairman would make it impossible to
> have a productive discussion on Scope and talks were recessed for the day."
>
Allied Pilots Association interpretation, from the APA website:
>
> "More valuable bargaining time was lost today when management's negotiators
> walked out of scope discussions 10 minutes into the day's session after
> becoming upset and frustrated when questioned about the content of their
> scope-related slide show comparing regional carrier operations within the
> industry. In addition, the management negotiators were unable to answer some
> basic questions or explain the intent of their presentation. The federal
> mediator was unable to convince them to return to the table, so the result
> was an entire day of bargaining lost."