[QUOTE=Airway;2506356][QUOTE=baseball;2506253]Pre-built lines weren't all that bad. PBS really only benefits the top 10% in each fleet/seat. Everyone else suffers.

It will never happen now that the horse is out, but pre-built lines, remember, you may not have gotten what you wanted, but we had an effective trip trade system so you could fix it. Now, you can't, trip trading is a joke. But don't worry, we'll fix it in the next contract.

[QUOTE=Airway;2506356][QUOTE=baseball;2506253]We could probably eliminate the whole global solution thing by getting rid of a published g line. Let the computer build lines in seniority order. When it can't build any more legal lines, everyone below just goes on reserve and the left over trips would go into open time. I'd guess the reserve line would move up about 5%, but the senior guys would get more of their choices.

[QUOTE=rp2pilot;2506521][QUOTE=Airway;2506356]IMO, if you're anywhere near the g-line there's a lot of value in knowing it. Especially if you're at or above by a few spots. It's not perfect but I think it works well.

At previous airline there was no such thing and there were times when far more people were bumped onto reserve than anticipated when block hours were low, and sometimes senior pilots found themselves on reserve for questionable reasons and despite not overly restrictive bid groups (yes there were "line donors" too).

With the g-line, IF getting a line is critical (commuter, juggling schedules w/ kids in the equation, etc), you know what your last bid group must be to ensure you get at least some sort of line.

[QUOTE=Chuck D;2506550][QUOTE=rp2pilot;2506521]Not trying to sound dismissive, but it's a serious question. Is the G line system a significant reason we have Global Solution screwing over a bunch of lineholders every month? It seems like it only *kind of* benefits a very small group of pilots at the expense of many. How does knowing if you're above the g-line help commuters or people with schedule inflexibility? If you're so close that you don't know if you're getting a line or not, whatever line you might get is not going to be commutable anyhow, and will probably stink either way.

[QUOTE=rp2pilot;2506521][QUOTE=Airway;2506356]If that worked, I would be all for it. I'm tired of getting the "Requested Award prevents solution completion" in the Reason Report.

[QUOTE=Tony Nelson;2506580][QUOTE=rp2pilot;2506521]Right-this should be unacceptable. If you can hold it in this situation we should get it. That’s why we have reserve and open time and seniority

Yes, yes, yes.

[QUOTE=Tony Nelson;2506580][QUOTE=rp2pilot;2506521]100%. That thing has screwed me too much lately.

[QUOTE=Airway;2506695][QUOTE=Tony Nelson;2506580]"Reserve is a choice." :(

I am told if everyone bids "award work low" PBS will crash.