Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   From First to Worst (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/115097-first-worst.html)

JoePatroni 07-24-2018 04:39 PM


Originally Posted by RomeoHotel (Post 2641428)
Joe,

Since you mentioned the 10k ....
Does anyone have a copy of that thing...I remember scab captains waving it in my face... It may not have used the bankruptcy word but it was pretty specific about the "future without concessions"
All total BS posturing in my opinion... and did not sway my "NO" vote...

I don’t have any copies but I know for a fact the word “bankruptcy” was NEVER used except in internal (company/ALPA) communications. The IAH based scab contingent was instrumental in ramming through that POS contract.

XHooker 07-24-2018 05:00 PM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2641848)
I don’t have any copies but I know for a fact the word “bankruptcy” was NEVER used except in internal (company/ALPA) communications. The IAH based scab contingent was instrumental in ramming through that POS contract.

Joe, at the EWR roadshow the ALPA lawyer said passing the contract wouldn’t guarantee staying out of BK, but not passing C ‘05 would make BK likely. Much as we’d like to put it on IAH scabs, they were far from alone in pushing the contract. It was being pushed by our counsel from ALPAN as well.

JoePatroni 07-24-2018 06:35 PM


Originally Posted by XHooker (Post 2641859)
Joe, at the EWR roadshow the ALPA lawyer said passing the contract wouldn’t guarantee staying out of BK, but not passing C ‘05 would make BK likely. Much as we’d like to put it on IAH scabs, they were far from alone in pushing the contract. It was being pushed by our counsel from ALPAN as well.

I was at that roadshow and I still call BS. If it was so imminent, why was it NEVER mentioned by ANYONE else- especially in the financial community? The previous imminent bankruptcy, when Bethune took over, was splashed all over every newspaper and business magazine for weeks and months.

Without the IAH scab reps and Panarello, this thing would have had a much harder time coming to fruition. Since GUM and CLE, as well as the FI’s, usually voted in lockstep with the IAH scab contingent- it was game over.

Sunvox 07-24-2018 06:59 PM


Originally Posted by intrepidcv11 (Post 2641729)
No we are talking 2004-05. I always consult seeking alpha for ‘objective measures’ on a company. :rolleyes:

I agree Seeking Alpha is not a good source for objective information, but a Z-Score is quite objective:

http://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jbm...1910068087.pdf

XHooker 07-25-2018 02:20 AM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2641915)
I was at that roadshow and I still call BS. If it was so imminent, why was it NEVER mentioned by ANYONE else- especially in the financial community? The previous imminent bankruptcy, when Bethune took over, was splashed all over every newspaper and business magazine for weeks and months.

Without the IAH scab reps and Panarello, this thing would have had a much harder time coming to fruition. Since GUM and CLE, as well as the FI’s, usually voted in lockstep with the IAH scab contingent- it was game over.

Pretty much agree with your assessment, but a potential BK was mentioned by our ALPA-N counsel who, as you probably remember, was pushing the concessions hard.

Boeing Aviator 07-25-2018 08:04 AM


Originally Posted by XHooker (Post 2641859)
Joe, at the EWR roadshow the ALPA lawyer said passing the contract wouldn’t guarantee staying out of BK, but not passing C ‘05 would make BK likely. Much as we’d like to put it on IAH scabs, they were far from alone in pushing the contract. It was being pushed by our counsel from ALPAN as well.

I believe the National attorney was Ken Cooper. He was buddies with Stivila and they vacationed together too on a cruise during negotiations.

By the way it wasn’t just the scabs. Randy Newman EWR FO rep voted for and was selling that POS too. FYI don’t forget Stivila ave Muir both on NC and both NC Chairmam during that POS contract negotiation cycle. Both picked by Fred to work for him and negotiate against ALPA. Both in flight ops management today and Rick is just below Howard. After POS consessionary contract passed and Ken Cooper’s BS was exposed he retired from ALPA. He was a very weak negotiating attorney.

JoePatroni 07-25-2018 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by Boeing Aviator (Post 2642144)
I believe the National attorney was Ken Cooper. He was buddies with Stivila and they vacationed together too on a cruise during negotiations.

By the way it wasn’t just the scabs. Randy Newman EWR FO rep voted for and was selling that POS too. FYI don’t forget Stivila ave Muir both on NC and both NC Chairmam during that POS contract negotiation cycle. Both picked by Fred to work for him and negotiate against ALPA. Both in flight ops management today and Rick is just below Howard. After POS consessionary contract passed and Ken Cooper’s BS was exposed he retired from ALPA. He was a very weak negotiating attorney.

Jackson Martin did just as much, if not more, damage than those two *****s when he went to work for Abbott too.

Boeing Aviator 07-25-2018 03:22 PM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2642217)
Jackson Martin did just as much, if not more, damage than those two *****s when he went to work for Abbott too.

Well he’s back on the line, Howard fired him. Not the same with the other two.

JoePatroni 07-25-2018 03:24 PM


Originally Posted by Boeing Aviator (Post 2642367)
Well he’s back on the line, Howard fired him. Not the same with the other two.


I heard he is just trying to keep his head down, complete douchebag.

APC225 07-26-2018 05:25 AM

I’d rather have our contract than their representation.

JoePatroni 07-26-2018 06:02 AM


Originally Posted by APC225 (Post 2642612)
I’d rather have our contract than their representation.

Not one of those jerkoffs should be allowed in or around ANYTHING union.

Boeing Aviator 07-26-2018 06:36 AM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2642629)
Not one of those jerkoffs should be allowed in or around ANYTHING union.

They should both be fired from management. Let them both fly the line like Jackson.

JoePatroni 07-26-2018 07:15 AM


Originally Posted by Boeing Aviator (Post 2642663)
They should both be fired from management. Let them both fly the line like Jackson.

I would love to watch them have to slink around like Martin.

757Driver 07-26-2018 08:15 AM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2642692)
I would love to watch them have to slink around like Martin.

He’s hiding in LA on the 756 fleet. Pretty sure 99% of the guys in the right seat are former L-UAL and have no idea as to the crimes he’s committed.

JoePatroni 07-26-2018 10:49 AM


Originally Posted by 757Driver (Post 2642749)
He’s hiding in LA on the 756 fleet. Pretty sure 99% of the guys in the right seat are former L-UAL and have no idea as to the crimes he’s committed.

That’s too bad, if they did no one would talk to him.

pilotgolfer 07-26-2018 01:05 PM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2642839)
That’s too bad, if they did no one would talk to him.

Its a small fleet in LAX. Under 60 in each seat. Spread the word.

XHooker 07-26-2018 02:27 PM


Originally Posted by Boeing Aviator (Post 2642144)
I believe the National attorney was Ken Cooper.

I believe it was actually Mike Abrams. Pat Burke, former IACP President/ALPA MEC Chairman (he transitioned CAL into ALPA), stood up and said while he had tremendous respect for Mike, he disagreed with his assessment. Point being, it wasn't just CALALPA and NC connected players who were pushing C '05.

JoePatroni 07-27-2018 01:44 AM


Originally Posted by XHooker (Post 2642985)
I believe it was actually Mike Abrams. Pat Burke, former IACP President/ALPA MEC Chairman (he transitioned CAL into ALPA), stood up and said while he had tremendous respect for Mike, he disagreed with his assessment. Point being, it wasn't just CALALPA and NC connected players who were pushing C '05.

I used to fly with Pat Burke a lot back then, to say he “disagreed” is an understatement. I think the word “disgrace” would better describe his feelings toward that POS contract....as well as all the people involved in writing it.

XHooker 07-27-2018 08:14 AM


Originally Posted by JoePatroni (Post 2643222)
I used to fly with Pat Burke a lot back then, to say he “disagreed” is an understatement. I think the word “disgrace” would better describe his feelings toward that POS contract....as well as all the people involved in writing it.

As you probably recall, Pat was more diplomatic at the Road Show. He still got his point across.

The WB Captains took the biggest hit in C05. The loss of trip drop with pay for vacation alone was huge. The former union leaders still on the property sent out a joint letter opposing C05.

Boeing Aviator 07-27-2018 11:09 AM


Originally Posted by XHooker (Post 2642985)
I believe it was actually Mike Abrams. Pat Burke, former IACP President/ALPA MEC Chairman (he transitioned CAL into ALPA), stood up and said while he had tremendous respect for Mike, he disagreed with his assessment. Point being, it wasn't just CALALPA and NC connected players who were pushing C '05.

I’m fairly sure it was Ken Cooper he was the ALPA negotiator assigned to our MEC and was buddy buddy with Stivila.

Mike Abraham ALPA’s General Counsel and wildly referred to the Scope Pope, ALPA’s Scope Guro.

XHooker 07-27-2018 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by Boeing Aviator (Post 2643554)
I’m fairly sure it was Ken Cooper he was the ALPA negotiator assigned to our MEC and was buddy buddy with Stivila.

Mike Abraham ALPA’s General Counsel and wildly referred to the Scope Pope, ALPA’s Scope Guro.

You want sick? I'm such a pack rat and the whole period was so contentious, I've still got the notes and handouts from the meeting readily accessible. It was Michael E Abram, who was from an outside law firm, not ALPA as I had said. However, it wasn't Ken Cooper, either, not that any of this matters.

JoePatroni 07-28-2018 03:15 AM


Originally Posted by XHooker (Post 2643407)
As you probably recall, Pat was more diplomatic at the Road Show. He still got his point across.

The WB Captains took the biggest hit in C05. The loss of trip drop with pay for vacation alone was huge. The former union leaders still on the property sent out a joint letter opposing C05.


I remember the letter, it was excellent. Pat Burke is one of the good guys, was sorry to see him go.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:31 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands