Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Envoy Airlines (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/envoy-airlines/)
-   -   Envoy or PSA (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/envoy-airlines/98302-envoy-psa.html)

pagey 11-15-2016 12:59 PM


Originally Posted by LongTimeListenr (Post 2243896)
A lot of what ifs and hypotheticals in there.

"Our flow will increase". Yea...because you said so, or because "they're going to have to sooner or later". We've heard it all before. :rolleyes:

Ahh, no. It will increase because an increase is contained in the LOA. For every 63(?) captains we gain one slot at AA. With 30+ acft still to come at PSA there is no way the flow will not increase.

chrisreedrules 11-15-2016 01:48 PM


Originally Posted by LongTimeListenr (Post 2243896)
A lot of what ifs and hypotheticals in there.

"Our flow will increase". Yea...because you said so, or because "they're going to have to sooner or later". We've heard it all before. :rolleyes:

Huh? Our flow increasing is part of an LOA. We're filling 2 classes /month well into the new year. No reason I can see why it won't. We still have some of the most growth left of any regional around today.

PilotJ3 11-15-2016 06:04 PM


Originally Posted by PSA help (Post 2243779)
Delta loves to hire PSA pilots. We have sent more to Delta than AA in the last few months.

You only have to send 5 to Delta to be more than AA. XD

On the other hand, Delta is also hiring envoy FOs. So doesn't matter which way he goes it will be fine.

I would say go with the easiest commute. Been here 6yrs and being Jmanned only 3 times and 2 of them I was able to get out of it without issues.

LongTimeListenr 11-15-2016 06:27 PM


Originally Posted by pagey (Post 2243907)
Ahh, no. It will increase because an increase is contained in the LOA. For every 63(?) captains we gain one slot at AA. With 30+ acft still to come at PSA there is no way the flow will not increase.

Absolutely has to happen, right? I suppose it would be unfortunate if those -900s ended up being brought in as -200s were retired or parked. That would through a very ugly wrench into that projection. :eek:

LongTimeListenr 11-15-2016 06:31 PM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 2243932)
Huh? Our flow increasing is part of an LOA.

That's quite the misleading statement since it's contingent upon your staffing numbers changing. Smoke and mirrors as y'all continue to gloss over the fact that it's not a guarantee.


We're filling 2 classes /month well into the new year. No reason I can see why it won't. We still have some of the most growth left of any regional around today.

I suppose time will tell. But until then....you're still at the slower flow.

filler....

Dubz 11-15-2016 06:34 PM


Originally Posted by PilotJ3 (Post 2244076)
So doesn't matter which way he goes it will be fine.

I would say go with the easiest commute. Been here 6yrs and being Jmanned only 3 times and 2 of them I was able to get out of it without issues.

Concur... personally, I don't think it will much matter which WO a person chooses today. I suspect that flow and salary will be virtually the same across the board; with only subtle differences in work rules. I find it hard to believe that Delta, United, or any other carrier sees PSA, Envoy, Endeavor, etc. on a resume and favors one over the other. How does one's work day or responsibility vary significantly over the other? But what do I know... I'm just a pilot. It's been said a million times, select based on QOL -- most would say that QOL is best attained by minimizing one's effort in getting to and from work.

chrisreedrules 11-16-2016 02:36 AM


Originally Posted by LongTimeListenr (Post 2244096)
Absolutely has to happen, right? I suppose it would be unfortunate if those -900s ended up being brought in as -200s were retired or parked. That would through a very ugly wrench into that projection. :eek:

That's why they are getting major engine overhauls and new interiors...

ORDinary 11-16-2016 07:25 AM


Originally Posted by cr700 (Post 2243629)
Much has been made on this board about schedules at Envoy. I have to be honest. It's LARGELY EXAGGERATED! There are a few anti Envoy types here that are constantly posting anything bad about the company possible and that includes schedules.

I will admit though that there are issues with a few of the sequences. However, these should affect very few pilots and not on every single sequence. As has been posted ad nauseum here, the issues lie in the flight file that is assigned to Envoy by AAG. The lack of midday flying has been one of the central issues Envoy has faced in the past year.

Expect anything that is an issue to improve in January or February as AAG is expected to add midday flying to the Envoy package.

After saying all of that, you are still going to flow to American. And you are going to flow faster than PSA or PDT. These three carriers are the only no interview and automatic flow in the industry. Envoy's flow percentages and contract language are far superior to PSA and PDT as well. If you want AA, then Envoy is where you want to be.

Anyone who thinks our schedule and QoL problems are exaggerated obviously sits behind a desk for a living and either doesn't know what they're talking about, or is being dishonest.

VFRrequest 11-16-2016 08:12 AM

"When you add up Envoy’s increased signing bonus"

Envoy boosts industry-leading starting pay to $60,000! | Envoy Air

Pedro4President 11-16-2016 09:44 AM


Originally Posted by VFRrequest (Post 2244373)
"When you add up Envoy’s increased signing bonus"

Envoy boosts industry-leading starting pay to $60,000! | Envoy Air

22,100$ on day one..... shocking they increased it so quickly.

PSA also doing this?

LongTimeListenr 11-16-2016 09:59 AM


Originally Posted by chrisreedrules (Post 2244212)
That's why they are getting major engine overhauls and new interiors...

Ah yes, the old "If they're maintaining the engines and putting in different seats we must be keeping them!" :rolleyes: If only that were an accurate metric.

That's your first response? It's concerning that you have to cling to such strings of hope.

banana380 11-16-2016 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by Pedro4President (Post 2244445)
22,100$ on day one..... shocking they increased it so quickly.

PSA also doing this?

News & Press | PSA Airlines

Looks like $21K for those with a CRJ type rating.

BizJet 11-16-2016 10:42 AM

At this rate Envoy just for the 22k looks better. But only in the money aspect. I could pay off a little over 50% of my students loans with the roughly 15/20% tax taken off.

NMuir 11-16-2016 10:44 AM


Originally Posted by BizJet (Post 2244497)
I could pay off a little over 50% of my students loans with the roughly 15/20% tax taken off.

Explain please? :confused:

Dubz 11-16-2016 11:10 AM


Originally Posted by Pedro4President (Post 2244445)
22,100$ on day one..... shocking they increased it so quickly.

PSA also doing this?

Looks like all 3 bumped bonuses up in order to make 1st year pay 60K.

BizJet 11-16-2016 11:11 AM


Originally Posted by NMuir (Post 2244498)
Explain please? :confused:

$22,100 * .20 (assuming 20% tax) = $17,680 ($4,420 is tax)

I could pay off roughly 50% of my student loan with that amount.

PSA help 11-16-2016 11:12 AM


Originally Posted by BizJet (Post 2244534)
$22,100 * .20 (assuming 20% tax) = $17,680 ($4,420 is tax)

I could pay off roughly 50% of my student loan with that amount.

Paying off high interest loans will save you a TON of money in the long run!

BizJet 11-16-2016 11:13 AM


Originally Posted by Dubz (Post 2244531)
Looks like all 3 bumped bonuses up in order to make 1st year pay 60K.

PSA is only if you hold a CRJ type, I believe.

chrisreedrules 11-16-2016 11:16 AM


Originally Posted by Dubz (Post 2244531)
Looks like all 3 bumped bonuses up in order to make 1st year pay 60K.

Kind of crazy... Just a year and a half ago pay was less than half of what it is now. American really does seem intent on staffing its WOs and following through.

Upntheair27 11-16-2016 11:28 AM

Before PSA was claiming $58000 with a 20,000K sign on bonus, now its 60K with only 21,000K bonus. Arent we missing a thousand dollar bill in there somewhere?

JayBee 11-16-2016 11:35 AM


Originally Posted by Upntheair27 (Post 2244566)
Before PSA was claiming $58000 with a 20,000K sign on bonus, now its 60K with only 21,000K bonus. Arent we missing a thousand dollar bill in there somewhere?

don't worry about details and reading the contract - just sign here

Upntheair27 11-16-2016 11:38 AM


Originally Posted by JayBee (Post 2244574)
don't worry about details and reading the contract - just sign here

haha oh yeah of course...maybe if I were 22 again and they were hiring me into a new shiny CRJ700 with 600 hours total time. Ahh, the good ol days making 17,000 first year pay :-)

MaCrOs 11-16-2016 11:41 AM


Originally Posted by BizJet (Post 2244534)
$22,100 * .20 (assuming 20% tax) = $17,680 ($4,420 is tax)

I could pay off roughly 50% of my student loan with that amount.

Bonuses are taxed at flat rate of 25%

BizJet 11-16-2016 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by MaCrOs (Post 2244581)
Bonuses are taxed at flat rate of 25%

So $16,575 after the tax. Still not to bad. Now if only Envoy had better reserve times...

PleaseComplete 11-16-2016 11:49 AM

not trying to be disingenuous here but having several offers on my table is making it hard to decide and....

what i can't shake from my mind is if it was such a good place to work than why do they have to throw big bonuses at you (envoy or psa) ?

every time i think that previous thought I think of that movie Tommy Boy where Chris Farley says "if you want me to poop in a box and write guaranteed on it...."

also, i keep thinking about how American Eagle got screwed on the flow

i don't know, as i said not trying to be disingenuous here having hard time deciding what is best for me

havick 11-16-2016 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by PleaseComplete (Post 2244585)
not trying to be disingenuous here but having several offers on my table is making it hard to decide and....

what i can't shake from my mind is if it was such a good place to work than why do they have to throw big bonuses at you (envoy or psa) ?

every time i think that previous thought I think of that movie Tommy Boy where Chris Farley says "if you want me to poop in a box and write guaranteed on it...."

also, i keep thinking about how American Eagle got screwed on the flow

i don't know, as i said not trying to be disingenuous here having hard time deciding what is best for me

Either way, the longer you wait to make your decision to get into a class, you're doing yourself a disservice by losing seniority at whichever carrier you decide to go with as others join ahead of you at 50/month.

Dubz 11-16-2016 11:58 AM


Originally Posted by Upntheair27 (Post 2244566)
Before PSA was claiming $58000 with a 20,000K sign on bonus, now its 60K with only 21,000K bonus. Arent we missing a thousand dollar bill in there somewhere?

The press release says "over $21000". Looking at the three websites Piedmont's breaks it down to 38.8 (salary) + 16.2 (sign on) + 5 (121 experience bonus); PSA's states "can receive over $21,000 immediately"; and Envoy's says "receive up to $22,100 sign-on bonus on your first day."

That would lead my untrained eye to believe that they wanted to tout 60K 1st year FO pay across the board and like the previous examples... what one gets they all get.

Has Envoy dropped the 121 experience requirement for the 5K? Neither Envoy or PSA gave a specific breakdown that I could find.

chrisreedrules 11-16-2016 11:59 AM

The industry has changed immensely in the past couple years. American is invested more in its regionals than any other legacy and it would hit American harder if it's WOs didn't succeed than it ultimately would UA and DA. Therefore, they are making themselves the most attractive to new hires to ensure their supply of regional pilots. Endeavor offers attractive pay. So does Republic, although it isn't as good as Endeavor or the WOs and they have a longer upgrade. SkyWest has good bases and pretty good pay/contract. Lots of places are attractive right now based on whatever scenario you're working with. The WOs however, are far from being a "guaranteed turd in a box" as CF so eloquently put it.

havick 11-16-2016 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by Dubz (Post 2244592)
The press release says "over $21000". Looking at the three websites Piedmont's breaks it down to 38.8 (salary) + 16.2 (sign on) + 5 (121 experience bonus); PSA's states "can receive over $21,000 immediately"; and Envoy's says "receive up to $22,100 sign-on bonus on your first day."

That would lead my untrained eye to believe that they wanted to tout 60K 1st year FO pay across the board and like the previous examples... what one gets they all get.

Has Envoy dropped the 121 experience requirement for the 5K? Neither Envoy or PSA gave a specific breakdown that I could find.

No previous 121 time required at all at Envoy for the full bonus. The 5k is simply if you take a legacy type as opposed to the 175. So if you take the 145 or CRJ you'll get the whole 22k.

BizJet 11-16-2016 12:08 PM


Originally Posted by havick (Post 2244594)
No previous 121 time required at all at Envoy for the full bonus. The 5k is simply if you take a legacy type as opposed to the 175. So if you take the 145 or CRJ you'll get the whole 22k.

How does PSA break their new bonus down?

NMuir 11-16-2016 12:09 PM


Originally Posted by PSA help (Post 2244537)
Paying off high interest loans will save you a TON of money in the long run!

Except that Sallie Mae applies extra payments to interest, not principle :mad:

PleaseComplete 11-16-2016 12:16 PM


Originally Posted by havick (Post 2244587)
Either way, the longer you wait to make your decision to get into a class, you're doing yourself a disservice by losing seniority at whichever carrier you decide to go with as others join ahead of you at 50/month.

Roger that, for what its worth in my mind its down to PSA or Skywest - leaning towards PSA but hesitant for previously stated reasons.

BizJet 11-16-2016 12:25 PM


Originally Posted by NMuir (Post 2244604)
Except that Sallie Mae applies extra payments to interest, not principle :mad:

Thankfully all mine are federal. So they should count it towards principle.

PiedmontFlyer 11-16-2016 01:32 PM


Originally Posted by Dubz (Post 2244592)
The press release says "over $21000". Looking at the three websites Piedmont's breaks it down to 38.8 (salary) + 16.2 (sign on) + 5 (121 experience bonus); PSA's states "can receive over $21,000 immediately"; and Envoy's says "receive up to $22,100 sign-on bonus on your first day."

That would lead my untrained eye to believe that they wanted to tout 60K 1st year FO pay across the board and like the previous examples... what one gets they all get.

Has Envoy dropped the 121 experience requirement for the 5K? Neither Envoy or PSA gave a specific breakdown that I could find.

envoy
$37,900 base pay + $17,100 signing bonus + $5,000 (if you fly CRJ or E145) = $60,000

PSA
$38,480 base pay + $16,520 signing + $5,000 (if you have CRJ type rating) = $60,000

Piedmont
$38,800 base pay + $16,200 signing + $5,000 (if you have any Part 121 experience) = $60,000

Dubz 11-16-2016 02:32 PM


Originally Posted by PiedmontFlyer (Post 2244655)
envoy
$37,900 base pay + $17,100 signing bonus + $5,000 (if you fly CRJ or E145) = $60,000

PSA
$38,480 base pay + $16,520 signing + $5,000 (if you have CRJ type rating) = $60,000

Piedmont
$38,800 base pay + $16,200 signing + $5,000 (if you have any Part 121 experience) = $60,000

Perfect... thanks.

Dubz 11-16-2016 02:42 PM


Originally Posted by PleaseComplete (Post 2244585)
not trying to be disingenuous here but having several offers on my table is making it hard to decide and....

what i can't shake from my mind is if it was such a good place to work than why do they have to throw big bonuses at you (envoy or psa) ?

every time i think that previous thought I think of that movie Tommy Boy where Chris Farley says "if you want me to poop in a box and write guaranteed on it...."

also, i keep thinking about how American Eagle got screwed on the flow

i don't know, as i said not trying to be disingenuous here having hard time deciding what is best for me

Personal perspective, but I believe the reason the WOs/AA are offering bonuses is that they didn't want to adjust the pay scales across the board. It was easier and cheaper to give bonuses and manipulate the pay scales by shifting the year 3 and 4 scales to 1 and 2. It was all done to fill seats.

If I were looking, I would consider the ease of getting to work, anticipated reserve time frame, other QOL issues, and then pay. You will have plenty of time to think about whether or not that 5K differential was worth it when you are on your second year of reserve when you could have sat two or three months... if you find yourself there. You'll make up the 5K month by month by not being on reserve and flying over guarantee.

Best of luck with your decision.

BizJet 11-16-2016 03:00 PM

By that logic it's

Envoy
Pro: Commuting, full bonus
Con: Reserve Length, contract violations, lifer top heavy

PSA
Pro: Reserve length, SAP, senior line holder at around a year
Con: Commuting, smaller bonus, Most likely will have to move

So it's leaning towards PSA just for the QOL of reserve and line holding.

Dubz 11-16-2016 03:28 PM


Originally Posted by BizJet (Post 2244695)
By that logic it's

Envoy
Pro: Commuting, full bonus
Con: Reserve Length, contract violations, lifer top heavy

PSA
Pro: Reserve length, SAP, senior line holder at around a year
Con: Commuting, smaller bonus, Most likely will have to move

So it's leaning towards PSA just for the QOL of reserve and line holding.

All depends on what your priorities are... if you don't want to move go to Envoy. If you want to live in a PSA base pack your bags. If you want to fly a lot soon and have more control over your schedule... PSA. I'm glad you and many have the option to choose. I'm no naysayer, I don't think there's all that much of a difference between the three. You would have to ask an Envoyer but my guess is that reserve times are shortening now that classes are filling up.

VoiceOfReason 11-16-2016 03:28 PM


Originally Posted by PiedmontFlyer (Post 2244655)
envoy
$37,900 base pay + $17,100 signing bonus + $5,000 (if you fly CRJ or E145) = $60,000

PSA
$38,480 base pay + $16,520 signing + $5,000 (if you have CRJ type rating) = $60,000

Piedmont
$38,800 base pay + $16,200 signing + $5,000 (if you have any Part 121 experience) = $60,000

Man, that's a lot of "IFs"...banking on lateral movement once again.

The Poach...I mean, the Purge begins!

Upntheair27 11-16-2016 03:37 PM


Originally Posted by PiedmontFlyer (Post 2244655)
envoy
$37,900 base pay + $17,100 signing bonus + $5,000 (if you fly CRJ or E145) = $60,000

PSA
$38,480 base pay + $16,520 signing + $5,000 (if you have CRJ type rating) = $60,000

Piedmont
$38,800 base pay + $16,200 signing + $5,000 (if you have any Part 121 experience) = $60,000

So the PSA base pay of 38.50x75 plus $3000 for hotels comes out to $37,650. I know its close but am i missing something or did they slightly raise hourly pay rate recently too?


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:19 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands