Something I don't get
#22
Prime Minister/Moderator

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 44,908
Likes: 694
From: Engines Turn or People Swim
#23
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 900
Likes: 0
While you bring up a good point, I think you actually fingered the whole problem with this industry. "Get there as fast as you can" is a theory that has probably brought about the ruin of many good people. This frame of mind makes smart people do some incredibly stupid things, i.e Go-Jets. It is the same mindset that allows the Great Lakes of the world (I dont have anything their pilots) to pay the basement rate that they do. We have lost the power to negotiate because of this theory. It allows the Regional Airline Academies of the world to charge 100K to get you your ratings in 18 months, with the carrot dangling in front of the professional jet job, while you get hit with the stick when you can no longer afford to do your job because you cant pay the loans. Just my thoughts.
#24
Thread Starter
Banned
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 781
Likes: 0
Do you have something against ATP or do you just not listen?
This is directly from their site:
http://www.atpflightschool.com/airli...ram/index.html
Included in the Price
Airline Career Pilot Program $44,995 Apartments (90 Day Fast Track Only) Included Cross-Country Hotels Included 5 FAA Written Exams
(IRA, CAX, FIA, FII & FOI) Included Manuals, Training Syllabus & Checklists Included Jeppesen Airway Manual with Charts for Cross-Country Phase Included Airline Career Pilot Program $44,995
Before you even start the program, you get a Box with all the stuff you will need for the course in it. Jepp Inst/Comm. book, 4 Gliem Books, All the PTS' and Oral exam guides, Airplane Flying Handbook, Instrument Flying Handbook, The Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge, The Flight Instructor's Handbook, checklists, Seminole PIM/POH, custom syllabus and 3 very nice polo shirts. While we were living in the apartment that ATP provided, I contacted the leasing office, it went for $1250/mo. The average electric bill was $160/mo and cable was $70/mo, ATP paid for it all. There was 4 of us living in the apartment. At the end of the program, I turned in my receipts for reimbursement on charts and expenses on the road and that came to $190, ATP paid that. While I was down there, I stayed in hotels a total of 9 nights at an average of $110/night, ATP picked up the tab. They also would take car of cab rides and rental cars if you needed them to, I never did.
Lets break it down then:
Total Cost ATP Today = $45,000
Less 5 FAA Writtens (5*$90/ea) = $450
Less 4 Gliem books (4*$20) = $80
Less Jepp Book = $60
Less Handbooks (3*$15) = $45
Less PTSs & OEGs = $75
Less PA-44 POH = $50.00
Less reimbursed expenses = $190
Less Hotels = (9*$110) = $990
Less Rent and Utilities ((1250+160+70)/4) = 370/person/month = $1110
Total Cost of Flight Training ~ $41,950
Now if you do a rough calculation and base the whole thing on multi time, it comes down to $220 per hour dual. Not too bad. But that also includes god knows how much ground time, 10 hours in a 172, 30 hours in a crappy sim and 70 hours in a Level 6 Seminole FTD, all with your instructor.
Now if you want to separate that out a little more:
Less 172 time ($80*10) = $800
Now you are down to $41,150. Who knows how much ground time we spent, but it was a lot. I won't even add in the cost of the sim because I have no idea what they would bill at. But we will conservatively say 200 hours of instructor time outside of flying including the 100 hours spent in the sim.
Less Instructor time (200*$30) = $6000 and you would pay more than that at your mom and pop FBO.
Now you are down to $35,150. Which is $185 per hour dual. I would dare you to beat that somewhere else.
Now if you really want to make it look nice, when I did it 3 years ago, it was $32000 and you got 150 hours of multi time. And I figured that that ended up being $155 and hour dual. You can barely rent a new 172 for that.
This is directly from their site:
http://www.atpflightschool.com/airli...ram/index.html
Included in the Price
Airline Career Pilot Program $44,995 Apartments (90 Day Fast Track Only) Included Cross-Country Hotels Included 5 FAA Written Exams
(IRA, CAX, FIA, FII & FOI) Included Manuals, Training Syllabus & Checklists Included Jeppesen Airway Manual with Charts for Cross-Country Phase Included Airline Career Pilot Program $44,995
Before you even start the program, you get a Box with all the stuff you will need for the course in it. Jepp Inst/Comm. book, 4 Gliem Books, All the PTS' and Oral exam guides, Airplane Flying Handbook, Instrument Flying Handbook, The Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge, The Flight Instructor's Handbook, checklists, Seminole PIM/POH, custom syllabus and 3 very nice polo shirts. While we were living in the apartment that ATP provided, I contacted the leasing office, it went for $1250/mo. The average electric bill was $160/mo and cable was $70/mo, ATP paid for it all. There was 4 of us living in the apartment. At the end of the program, I turned in my receipts for reimbursement on charts and expenses on the road and that came to $190, ATP paid that. While I was down there, I stayed in hotels a total of 9 nights at an average of $110/night, ATP picked up the tab. They also would take car of cab rides and rental cars if you needed them to, I never did.
Lets break it down then:
Total Cost ATP Today = $45,000
Less 5 FAA Writtens (5*$90/ea) = $450
Less 4 Gliem books (4*$20) = $80
Less Jepp Book = $60
Less Handbooks (3*$15) = $45
Less PTSs & OEGs = $75
Less PA-44 POH = $50.00
Less reimbursed expenses = $190
Less Hotels = (9*$110) = $990
Less Rent and Utilities ((1250+160+70)/4) = 370/person/month = $1110
Total Cost of Flight Training ~ $41,950
Now if you do a rough calculation and base the whole thing on multi time, it comes down to $220 per hour dual. Not too bad. But that also includes god knows how much ground time, 10 hours in a 172, 30 hours in a crappy sim and 70 hours in a Level 6 Seminole FTD, all with your instructor.
Now if you want to separate that out a little more:
Less 172 time ($80*10) = $800
Now you are down to $41,150. Who knows how much ground time we spent, but it was a lot. I won't even add in the cost of the sim because I have no idea what they would bill at. But we will conservatively say 200 hours of instructor time outside of flying including the 100 hours spent in the sim.
Less Instructor time (200*$30) = $6000 and you would pay more than that at your mom and pop FBO.
Now you are down to $35,150. Which is $185 per hour dual. I would dare you to beat that somewhere else.
Now if you really want to make it look nice, when I did it 3 years ago, it was $32000 and you got 150 hours of multi time. And I figured that that ended up being $155 and hour dual. You can barely rent a new 172 for that.
#25
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 213
Likes: 0
From: DHC-6 / PC-12
You still don't get it because you don't want to get it. The only reason that someone would post a thread like this is to argue. And the only reason that you continue to argue is that you like it. The only reason that this isn't case-closed for you is that you have no sufficient evidence to back up your position and purely do not like ATP. I'm not telling you that you have to like it, I'm asking you to produce some facts that show that it is not as efficient and as effective at getting you time and ratings as it has been portrayed by the company, by myself and by other people who have been there.
#26
Thread Starter
Banned
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 781
Likes: 0
AVIVIII, I don't hate ATP, just trying to make a post that would maybe show others that they can save a lot more money for the same ratings by going through a regular school. However if you have money to burn and would like to go to an airline specific school then by all means go to an academy. By the way you're saying the 45K price is for 190 hours at ATP? What about the private license? Add another 5-8 grand. Housing is only included for 90 days. Total = 50-60K. At my local airport they have a twin for 180 per hour, instructors 35. Do the math.
#27
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Nov 2006
Posts: 213
Likes: 0
From: DHC-6 / PC-12
Even at that, it is still $36,000 PLUS to get 190 hours of multi time. And that figure doesn't include the PPL either.
If you want to get the private through ATP, thats another $9K and they provide housing for that as well. Thats 2 months and 85 hours. So it is private and then some more PIC X-C time on top of it all.
So yeah, you could probably save 3-4 thousand doing it all multi at that specific FBO. That is assuming that you can actually get a deal like that. Also assuming that the plane doesn't break down or get scheduled by someone else and the instructor is always available. And again, that you aren't in a rush. That still doesn't include housing, sim training, ground training, writtens or expenses.
Where is this FBO? What type of plane is it? Does it have GPS? Slaved gyros? Insurance?
If you want to get the private through ATP, thats another $9K and they provide housing for that as well. Thats 2 months and 85 hours. So it is private and then some more PIC X-C time on top of it all.
So yeah, you could probably save 3-4 thousand doing it all multi at that specific FBO. That is assuming that you can actually get a deal like that. Also assuming that the plane doesn't break down or get scheduled by someone else and the instructor is always available. And again, that you aren't in a rush. That still doesn't include housing, sim training, ground training, writtens or expenses.
Where is this FBO? What type of plane is it? Does it have GPS? Slaved gyros? Insurance?
#28
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 762
Likes: 0
Even at that, it is still $36,000 PLUS to get 190 hours of multi time. And that figure doesn't include the PPL either.
If you want to get the private through ATP, thats another $9K and they provide housing for that as well. Thats 2 months and 85 hours. So it is private and then some more PIC X-C time on top of it all.
So yeah, you could probably save 3-4 thousand doing it all multi at that specific FBO. That is assuming that you can actually get a deal like that. Also assuming that the plane doesn't break down or get scheduled by someone else and the instructor is always available. And again, that you aren't in a rush. That still doesn't include housing, sim training, ground training, writtens or expenses.
Where is this FBO? What type of plane is it? Does it have GPS? Slaved gyros? Insurance?
If you want to get the private through ATP, thats another $9K and they provide housing for that as well. Thats 2 months and 85 hours. So it is private and then some more PIC X-C time on top of it all.
So yeah, you could probably save 3-4 thousand doing it all multi at that specific FBO. That is assuming that you can actually get a deal like that. Also assuming that the plane doesn't break down or get scheduled by someone else and the instructor is always available. And again, that you aren't in a rush. That still doesn't include housing, sim training, ground training, writtens or expenses.
Where is this FBO? What type of plane is it? Does it have GPS? Slaved gyros? Insurance?
There are better deals out there than ATP, that is a fact. It may just take some more searching. It is also easier to work out a deal with a FBO than trying to work out a deal with a big name school like ATP
I believe BURflyer is just saying that ATP is not the end all be all of Flight Training, like some would make it out to be.
#29
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 175
Likes: 0
From: 747 FO
While I'm not against the run of the mill FBO there are a few things to consider. 1) you don't always have aircraft availible and if you do, you can't fly them three times that day probably 2) you won't get to fly through California, Nevada, Arizona, Texas, Mississippi, Florida, and back to build your XC time. 3) When I take my FBO's airplane somewhere and the alternator breaks, I end up paying for them to come out and fix it or mail a new part. This is the reality of "mom and pop" FBOs.
And please show me an FBO where I can rent a 2005 PA44-180 w/ dual GNS 430s (WAAS on the way) wet for $200 an hour. Especially if it's near AZ.
And please show me an FBO where I can rent a 2005 PA44-180 w/ dual GNS 430s (WAAS on the way) wet for $200 an hour. Especially if it's near AZ.
#30
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 175
Likes: 0
From: 747 FO
Agreed there are definitely, other ways to do your training. Just please god don't get roped into BS pay up front, take 2 years to get your ratings done crap (like RAA). Go to a university get your degree and spend two summers doing your ratings (or certificates). Done.



