Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   Delta runway incursion JFK (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/126603-delta-runway-incursion-jfk.html)

USMCFLYR 01-12-2020 09:47 AM


Originally Posted by BMEP100 (Post 2955233)
What he said......plus
I’ve no doubt the FO never looked out the window and said “ Clear Right”, and the Captain did not wait for it.

I’ve seen this more and more this last decade as heads down duties increase. When I prompt the FO for the “Clear right?”, approaching the runway, I often get a response of either perfunctory “ yeah, clear right before their head swivels”, or some subtle irritation “.


See and avoid is not in Magenta..maybe it should be.

I was on a low approach to RWY 29 at KMSY when a Delta jet taxied across the approach end on Sierra taxiway on the way to RWY 02. It is in our SOP to clear both directions on taxiways and runways as you mention in your post above. It was obvious to us that the CA never took a look out his window to see an airplane with all its' lights on and landing gear down coming down final.
Head on a swivel and always expect the unexpected.
We saw him coming towards the runways from some distance out and were talking about whether he was going to stop because he had a hearty dose of steam down the taxiway it seemed.

Adlerdriver 01-12-2020 09:56 AM


Originally Posted by Varsity (Post 2955027)
Perhaps Delta should hire more regional pilots. You know, the ones with thousands of hours of experience at JFK/ORD/LAX.. (insert major airport here)..

EDIT: Listened to it. Inexcusable. Even after the incident wasn't providing a proper read back. Cute military "Roger" though.

Someone's got a chip on their shoulder. I think Delta has probably hired plenty of high quality RJ pilots. But not you apparently - could be the entitled attitude. Nah.... it's obviously their problem.

If busy airports overwhelmed you at first, that's okay, it happens. Thank goodness you found the opportunity to taxi around them for thousands of hours until you were able to figure it out.

Anyone know what a "military Roger" is? I wasn't aware the DOD had a monopoly on the use of the phrase. However, it is referenced 12 times in the current AIM, which, last I checked wasn't published via any military source.

ShyGuy 01-12-2020 10:08 AM

Apparently this video is cut off. When she says hold short, that was the second instruction to hold short of 22R. The first time is cut off/not included in the video.

PackPilot 01-12-2020 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by Bat2210 (Post 2955306)
The Delta pilots mistake started 500 feet out on final. You can see the runways and aircraft holding short of the active right runway. You can HEAR the tower controlling the right active runway. You can usually see another aircraft in position. Your brain has to go beyond the radome.



Actually this is not really the case if I remember JFK correctly (not based there). The tower that clears them to cross 22R on 119.1 is the 22L tower controller, while the tower that clears the plane for takeoff is obviously 22R tower controller, but on 123.9. So you don’t have the SA hearing the 22R controller clearing another plane to takeoff while you’re crossing. I’ve never understood why JFK does this. Just about every other airport in the country one controller issues the crossing and takeoff clearances. This is a big factor and was just waiting to happen IMO.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Brillo 01-12-2020 10:36 AM


Originally Posted by Adlerdriver (Post 2955321)
Someone's got a chip on their shoulder. I think Delta has probably hired plenty of high quality RJ pilots. But not you apparently - could be the entitled attitude. Nah.... it's obviously their problem.

If busy airports overwhelmed you at first, that's okay, it happens. Thank goodness you found the opportunity to taxi around them for thousands of hours until you were able to figure it out.

Anyone know what a "military Roger" is? I wasn't aware the DOD had a monopoly on the use of the phrase. However, it is referenced 12 times in the current AIM, which, last I checked wasn't published via any military source.

Varsity comes out of left field with his anti-military schtick no matter what the subject. Dude, let it go. I'm sorry that when you applied you got denied due to some kind of weird, disproportionate body measurements or because every officer recruiter you talked to got the impression that you might be sewing together a suit made out of human skin in your mom's basement. It's not our fault.

ShyGuy 01-12-2020 10:55 AM


Originally Posted by PackPilot (Post 2955340)
Actually this is not really the case if I remember JFK correctly (not based there). The tower that clears them to cross 22R on 119.1 is the 22L tower controller, while the tower that clears the plane for takeoff is obviously 22R tower controller, but on 123.9. So you don’t have the SA hearing the 22R controller clearing another plane to takeoff while you’re crossing. I’ve never understood why JFK does this. Just about every other airport in the country one controller issues the crossing and takeoff clearances. This is a big factor and was just waiting to happen IMO.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

SEA does something similar. Regardless, if you know JFK is landing 22L, they're probably taking off 22R as well (and landing 22R as well). Part of every briefing should be how many runways you have to cross to get to the gate.

ShyGuy 01-12-2020 10:57 AM


Originally Posted by Adlerdriver (Post 2955321)
Someone's got a chip on their shoulder. I think Delta has probably hired plenty of high quality RJ pilots. But not you apparently - could be the entitled attitude. Nah.... it's obviously their problem.

If busy airports overwhelmed you at first, that's okay, it happens. Thank goodness you found the opportunity to taxi around them for thousands of hours until you were able to figure it out.

Anyone know what a "military Roger" is? I wasn't aware the DOD had a monopoly on the use of the phrase. However, it is referenced 12 times in the current AIM, which, last I checked wasn't published via any military source.


You gotta talk their language. If the tower lady had said, "Delta 300, knock it off, knock it off!"

Man those guys would have punched right through that intersection double time and then broken off on Alpha. :D

PackPilot 01-12-2020 11:37 AM


Originally Posted by ShyGuy (Post 2955360)
SEA does something similar. Regardless, if you know JFK is landing 22L, they're probably taking off 22R as well (and landing 22R as well). Part of every briefing should be how many runways you have to cross to get to the gate.



Yes but they thought they were cleared to cross 22R (though I didn’t hear them read that back). If you thought you were cleared to cross but then heard the tower say, “Delta 254 cleared for takeoff 22R” they may have hit the brakes. They obviously screwed up....but that may have saved their mistake.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

CousinEddie 01-12-2020 12:52 PM


Originally Posted by Varsity (Post 2955027)
Perhaps Delta should hire more regional pilots. You know, the ones with thousands of hours of experience at JFK/ORD/LAX.. (insert major airport here)..

EDIT: Listened to it. Inexcusable. Even after the incident wasn't providing a proper read back. Cute military "Roger" though.

You wanna play that game? Here is an example from the regional side of a not so well stated clearance coupled with a lack of SA nearly causing a disaster. In the days before EGPWS, it could have been a hull loss. I can just imagine how you come across in an interview.

Incident: Skywest CRJ9 at Medford on Dec 24th 2017, GPWS alert on approach

PRS Guitars 01-12-2020 01:53 PM


Originally Posted by Varsity (Post 2955027)
Perhaps Delta should hire more regional pilots. You know, the ones with thousands of hours of experience at JFK/ORD/LAX.. (insert major airport here)..

EDIT: Listened to it. Inexcusable. Even after the incident wasn't providing a proper read back. Cute military "Roger" though.

Sorry, military pilots generally don’t use “roger” especially fighter pilots. It’s not taught and not in any manuals I’ve ever seen.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:10 PM.


User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Website Copyright ©2000 - 2017 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands