![]() |
Originally Posted by iceman49
(Post 1110399)
Where do you find the LM-2 report? thanks
Organization Query Page (Disclosure) Carl |
.........................
|
Originally Posted by TheManager
(Post 1110275)
Hey Carl,
Thanks and Happy New Year. I read Slow's response to my post and contemplated it.... for a minute. I was late to a New Years party and decided to put it in a hold for later. You captured everything I had planned to say. One point I do want to reiterate. YES the Committee guys are getting C2K pay. Slow, you responded that they are not getting C2K rates. Rates, of course not. But if you take 92, or even 87 hours of pay.... on the highest equipment they can hold plus stipends/per diem, etc., then their W2's look no different than they probably did in 2001. Mind you, while they are representing the interests and needs of the pilots, this windfall is paid for by Delta, not ALPA. So, while line guys are dealing with an average line value of 72 hours a month from Nov-March with little to no open time to pick up, and while still under a bk contract, those under full FPL see no change from C2K. Tell us again how they are down here in the trenches with us fighting and are not swayed at all by the company's funded influence? So easy to change. How about the line pilots pay you all to represent us? Carl |
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110297)
No matter how many times you repeat it, your statement still is not factual. I did not parse words. But now you're equivocating. Before you asserted that W2's looked no different than C2K. Now you're stating "probably...in 2001." I'm sure if pay went back to the May 2001 scale you'd excoriate ALPA while beating your DPA tamborine.
You know slowplay, I expect more from my unelected MEC bureaucrats. When Delta management pays you your 92 hours flight pay loss per month plus 1,000 stipend plus expenses, I'm starting to think maybe they're not getting their money's worth. I know the line pilots sure aren't. Carl |
Originally Posted by Pineapple Guy
(Post 1110415)
Timbo, I deleted my response - it's just not worth it.
I just made my New Year's resolution, which is to sign off this board. It has grown tiresome and redundant. This used to be a place where the "Latest and Greatest" was heard; but now it seems to be nothing more than an anti-ALPA ranting club with the same dozen or so guys constantly whining. Enjoy and Sayonara, but I've got better things to do with my life. |
Originally Posted by Timbo
(Post 1110416)
How long has the Communications Chair been talking down to us? Seems like 10 years, but it may only be 5...he would be the first one I would replace, and I would have done it two years ago.
On the Term Limit thing? You simply make it a Requirement of being a Delta Pilot, just like paying dues is required under Agency Shop. Hold a Lottery, pull 4 names for each slot, and have an election. If you win, you must serve, but in 2 years you are Free again, having done your part. I think that would motivate the silent majority to wake up and pay attention to what they are actaully voting on! |
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
Maybe you ought to actually read the source material, assistant groundskeeper. Then you wouldn't have to guess. The LM-2 breaks out all compensation and expense reimbursement (per diem, expenses, vacation reimbursement, etc.) for every individual. The document is way more intrusive than Federal requirements for publicly traded corporations, as they only are required to list the top 5 earners. Oh, all the stuff the union funds, such as the Charitable Fund and Furlough/Emergency Relief fund is in their too.
Carl |
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
There is only one guy on DPA's NC that has run for major public office (3 times). Asking for money from a union PAC that you've never contributed to is hypocritical, don't you think?
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
I guess you don't like democracy, Spackler. Remember, it's not the Detroit Pilots Association.
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
The other councils representing the other 9,000 plus pilots get a vote too. And not one single committee guy got to vote on how that resolution was processed. All of it was done by the elected representatives.
Carl |
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
Name that guy.
Name one elected representative that hasn't been included in the process, or been excluded from a meeting, or has been isolated from infomation provided to the MEC.
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
When you're finished with your "proof", contact the Department of Labor. They'll be interested.
Your assertion is bovine excrement.
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
You keep repeating that which is false. Why? Is this what ninjas do?
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110308)
Why did I take you off my ignore list?:rolleyes:
Carl |
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110373)
I've edited my original post to change the word "rate" to "pay" with appropriate homage to your word parsing.
Originally Posted by slowplay
(Post 1110373)
Now that we're finsihed with your attempt at deflection, you asked a bunch of questions and I answered them. Your turn, bombthrower.:p
Carl |
If it were up to me, LEC reps would only get what ever the ALV is every month, and no $1,000 override for a lawn crew, every month.
Timbo, You are aware that your "LEC REPS" do not receive any sort of override whatsoever correct? They do not get trip drops for any LEC business. Representing pilots in the CP office? Off days. LEC meetings? Off days. In the larger bases you have Reps that are going to the airport 16 days a month to fly and then 8 or 9 days a month doing representations etc. This work does not get done by magic. I am sure there will be a flood of candidates for the election next year to take advantage of this really good deal. I hope that anyone who is considering running whether it be DALPA or DPA, will follow a large base rep around for a month and see if it is really such a sweet deal that some make it out to be.... If you value your free time, don't do it. |
Originally Posted by Pineapple Guy
(Post 1110415)
I just made my New Year's resolution, which is to sign off this board. It has grown tiresome and redundant
and/or "DALPA won't deliver on C2012--I better take cover and submit my application to management." Good riddance. The only thing tiresome and redundant are your asinine, company-funded-talking-points, including "commuting is a choice" at Delta. |
Originally Posted by RonRicco
(Post 1110482)
You are aware that your "LEC REPS" do not receive any sort of override whatsoever correct? They do not get trip drops for any LEC business. Representing pilots in the CP office? Off days. LEC meetings? Off days. In the larger bases you have Reps that are going to the airport 16 days a month to fly and then 8 or 9 days a month doing representations etc. |
Originally Posted by OccupyRestSeat
(Post 1110483)
Translation: "My worn out DALPA drivel is not working, so I quit."
and/or "DALPA won't deliver on C2012--I better take cover and submit my application to management." Good riddance. The only thing tiresome and redundant are your asinine, company-funded-talking-points, including "commuting is a choice" at Delta. |
Originally Posted by finis72
(Post 1110528)
A few people on here try to refute a barrage of DPA half truths and lies and he's called asinine ? I like listening to both sides, I can make up my own mind. I don't believe all of what ALPA put's out but I really dislike the DPA supporters on here that attack anything that even sounds like it's pro ALPA with usually nothing but BS. If this group is representative of the DPA then they will never get my support or vote. I'm going to try and quit this addiction also,it's become very predictable and boring.
|
Originally Posted by Carl Spackler
(Post 1110442)
Click on the link below, then in the box "Union Name by Abbreviation" select Airline Pilots Association from the dropdown menu. Then on the bottom from the box "Report Type" select LM-2, then hit submit. When the report list populates, select the last one 000-179 2010 Report.
Organization Query Page (Disclosure) Carl |
Originally Posted by Xray678
(Post 1110519)
You are wrong. They do get ALPA trip drops. I agree they work hard and if you value free time don't do it, but they do get ALPA drops.
|
Originally Posted by Reroute
(Post 1110546)
Nope, you are wrong, they don't get FPL for any of the LEC business Ron mentioned, which is what takes up most of their time. If you doubt me, call your rep and find out. They get paid what they hold and what they bid, just like every other line pilot. If they get FPL, it's for MEC business, such as an MEC meeting or lounge visit. Most of the work they do they do without any compensation.
|
Originally Posted by Xray678
(Post 1110548)
Hmm, awful lot of ALPA trip drops on their schedules for it all to be "MEC" business.
|
Originally Posted by finis72
(Post 1110528)
A few people on here try to refute a barrage of DPA half truths and lies and he's called asinine ?
A question for you: Why would anyone acting as a spokesman for DALPA (such as Pineapple Guy) parrot the company's "commuting is a choice" line? How does that further our goal of improving our QOL? More to the point: If DALPA publicly rolls over for the company on matters such as this, what must they be sandbagging behind closed doors? :confused: DALPA's track record of obstructionism, obfuscation, and a complete lack of transparency only furthers one's doubt. |
Originally Posted by Carl Spackler
(Post 1110461)
Translation: You're not really a union member if you're not ALPA. DPA support disqualifies you as someone who believes in unionism and as such, you're not entitled to PAC money from a "union" like ALPA if you decide to run for public office.
Carl |
Originally Posted by Xray678
(Post 1110548)
Hmm, awful lot of ALPA trip drops on their schedules for it all to be "MEC" business.
|
Originally Posted by sailingfun
(Post 1110671)
They work far harder then any line pilot ever does.
To make a statement like that...wow. I know it's hard for you to believe, but some of us have other jobs or other circumstances outside of flying that (gasp) might entail work. Sometimes, even hard work. For you to make such a sweeping (and utterly bogus) generalization like that only reinforces how out-of-touch the DALPA bureaucracy has grown. |
Originally Posted by OccupyRestSeat
(Post 1110676)
The absolute pinnacle of ALPA arrogance. "Here at ALPA, we work so much harder than you lazy slobs can ever begin to fathom."
To make a statement like that...wow. I know it's hard for you to believe, but some of us have other jobs or other circumstances outside of flying that (gasp) might entail work. Sometimes, even hard work. For you to make such a sweeping (and utterly bogus) generalization like that only reinforces how out-of-touch the DALPA bureaucracy has grown. Your logic chain is a non-sequitur. I took Sailings post as Reps work harder than line pilots work (for Delta air lines)...While his premise is not sound, he did not qualify the statement as work in total. He isn't part of the DALPA bureaucracy, just a DALPA defender. Is it your premise that standing up a new union will not require work - at the same level of the "DALPA bureaucracy" or is this simply a stone throwing contest? Do you hate your career so much that you just want to burn everything down? I want ALPA gone yesterday, but honestly, YOU do not represent my interests. I get Carl and agree with almost everything he says, but you are far too fringe for my taste. Your rhetoric is hollow. |
Originally Posted by Xray678
(Post 1110548)
Hmm, awful lot of ALPA trip drops on their schedules for it all to be "MEC" business.
And a fair amount of the flying that he did have (his plane is overstaffed, it wasn't a ton) had was YS, so it's not like he's trying to avoid work. In fact, he ended up with a long trip that had him flying from before Christmas and until after New Year's. Sounds cushy. :rolleyes: |
Originally Posted by OccupyRestSeat
(Post 1110676)
The absolute pinnacle of ALPA arrogance. "Here at ALPA, we work so much harder than you lazy slobs can ever begin to fathom."
To make a statement like that...wow. I know it's hard for you to believe, but some of us have other jobs or other circumstances outside of flying that (gasp) might entail work. Sometimes, even hard work. For you to make such a sweeping (and utterly bogus) generalization like that only reinforces how out-of-touch the DALPA bureaucracy has grown. |
Originally Posted by scambo1
(Post 1110700)
Your logic chain is a non-sequitur.
I took Sailings post as Reps work harder than line pilots work (for Delta air lines)...While his premise is not sound, he did not qualify the statement as work in total. He isn't part of the DALPA bureaucracy, just a DALPA defender. Is it your premise that standing up a new union will not require work - at the same level of the "DALPA bureaucracy" or is this simply a stone throwing contest? Do you hate your career so much that you just want to burn everything down? I want ALPA gone yesterday, but honestly, YOU do not represent my interests. I get Carl and agree with almost everything he says, but you are far too fringe for my taste. Your rhetoric is hollow. |
Originally Posted by sailingfun
(Post 1110671)
I don't know about your reps but mine have been in the lounge constantly for the last two month answering questions. I have known several reps over the years. They work far harder then any line pilot ever does. Most burn out on the work schedule and go back to the line for a vacation. If there is a issue with pay for our Dalpa reps and other workers its that we don't pay them enough. I am lazy enough that I would not consider union work for 150 hours pay per month.
|
Of course there are those DPA committee guys that took loans from the Delta pilot funded furlough and emergency relief fund, then refused to honor their committment to pay that back. A resolution needs to be put forward to recover the money due Delta pilots. |
Originally Posted by TheManager
(Post 1110110)
.......What Carl stated about the union is of course fact.....
"But I'm afraid our current union has already been badly compromised in some fashion by management and our union's leaders have a strong incentive to give management what THEY want....Carl" http://www.airlinepilotforums.com/im...er_offline.gif Of course it is fact...in your world (and Carl's world I suppose); and no matter how much sense the rest of Carl's post makes, it is these emotional, Ad Hominem attacks that is so detestable and reminiscent of the USAPA movement, that assures the ultimate failure of DPA....of course, that is just my opinion (not a "fact") |
Originally Posted by Elvis90
(Post 1074729)
BTW, Delta is the largest user of jet fuel in the world, according to company executives
|
Originally Posted by Xray678
(Post 1110938)
I think my reps work very hard. And I think they should get paid trip drops when they are doing union business. I was just pointing out that they do get drops.
"You are aware that your "LEC REPS" do not receive any sort of override whatsoever correct? They do not get trip drops for any LEC business. Representing pilots in the CP office? Off days. LEC meetings? Off days. In the larger bases you have Reps that are going to the airport 16 days a month to fly and then 8 or 9 days a month doing representations etc. This work does not get done by magic." Reps do get trip drops, but not for any of the above which probably takes up most of their time. Simply stating that Reps are entitled to trip drops ignores the overwhelming percent of their time they spend representing you on their off time when they are not entitled to trip drops as your LEC rep. |
Originally Posted by Gomerglideslope
(Post 1110969)
Of course it is fact...in your world (and Carl's world I suppose); and no matter how much sense the rest of Carl's post makes, it is these emotional, Ad Hominem attacks that is so detestable and reminiscent of the USAPA movement, that assures the ultimate failure of DPA....of course, that is just my opinion (not a "fact")
+++ a bunch |
Edit: Eh, Elvis said it better....
|
Originally Posted by fiveninerzero
(Post 1111101)
No it's not, the United States Government is.
Read more here: How financial speculation in oil prices ruins airline profits | McClatchy |
Originally Posted by Justdoinmyjob
(Post 1111138)
Edit: Eh, Elvis said it better....
|
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
Folks, here you have the anatomy of a well planned smear campaign. You have sensationalistic, tabloid trash that is worthy of Karl Rove or Rupert Murdoch's best efforts. Lets break down how you make a great smear campaign as evidenced above:
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
First, The Manager, Carl, 80Knots, OccupyRestSeat, and every other Delta pilot is paid by Delta Air Lines. EVERY ONE. So The Manager starts off with this bolded statement:
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
So somehow, recklessly wasting your dues money by forcing your union to pay back all the flight pay loss money has become a rallying cry for an independent union. Yes, our plan is to waste your dues money when we don't have to. Why, because your pay will come from Delta Air Lines instead of Delta Air Lines. Awesome plan.
As has been stated many times, the fix to this is take all money from flight pay loss paid by the company and give it back to the pilot group as increased salary. Then our dues would increase the exact same amount so that our union guys would still get their flight pay loss, but they would get it from dues money...not management. Next straw man argument... Carl |
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
In the sleaze ball propaganda world that is called separation and deniability. Not confirmed, see that allows him to walk away from his sleazy attack with no harm no foul. It is not confirmed, but I will throw out the mud anyway, see what sticks.
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
More masterful work. Why "debit cards" and not "credit cards." Everyone knows that an organization the size of ALPA uses corporate credit cards for purchasing and cost accounting so "credit cards" doesn't sound menacing enough. No, they use "debit cards" because that conjures up images of cash payments with no accountability. I mean who really records all the times they buy a cup of coffee at Starbucks with a debit card. Who could ever track where these mysterious debit cards are being used?
Carl |
Originally Posted by Carl Spackler
(Post 1111156)
You should be paid by the people you're supposed to be representing. It might help you move away from constant apologies for whatever management does.
Uh.. I disagree with this in a sense. If DALPA were paying representatives, you and others would be squawking about the amount of work that you are getting for your money. I think that is a slippery slope too Carl. |
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
Excellent walkback to the deniability stage. There is a reason why hearsay is not allowed in evidence in court rooms, but hey, when you are making a sleaze ball attack, why not? See, The Manager doesn't have to take responsibility for this sleaze, it is just hearsay.
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
He starts with FACT all bolded as if that proves it. Here is quick fact. C2K pay for a 767 Captain was $268 per hour. At the time he posted this a 767 Captain's pay was $182 per hour. Average pay hours during C2K was 83 hours per pilot. ALPA uses 87 hours for committee members and 92 for the Negotiating Committee which is the only committee that are designated pilots.
C2K: 268 x 83 = $22,244 Average Committee guy : 182 x 87 = $15,834 Average Delta line holder : 182 x 87 = $15,834 Negotiating Committee : 182 x 92 = $16,744 If you count the per diem of $1,000 per month you do not get to C2K pay, no matter how you slice it. It is not a fact it is pure bunk. Plus, does anyone think that working more hours after bankruptcy is a pay raise? Please, someone tell me that the DPA doesn't think we get a pay raise when we work more hours.
Originally Posted by alfaromeo
(Post 1110390)
It seems to me that DPA has morphed from being an alternative union concept to a sleazy ALPA attack machine. They have this website with no accountability and no ethics and just toss out sleazy trash to attack pilots that work for ALPA.
Carl |
| All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:55 AM. |
Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands