Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   Frontier vs. Spirit (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/89380-frontier-vs-spirit.html)

Lobaeux 07-22-2015 10:44 AM

This is true, I cannot be required to fly a junior man assignment, unless I pick up the phone and they are specifically calling me to fly. I can't be JA on a call I make to scheduling, coming off the jet bridge, walking into the crew room, etc. I don't know about our big IROP, I was never called, I don't have experience in getting JA during that event. My experience so far with JAs have been minimal, I was "offered" one, I refused, they went on to the next guy.

Don't mistake my assertion about money as indication I'd like to settle for just a small raise in our next contract. I'm just saying I'm not going to chase hourly rates (even a higher W-2) of a legacy carrier and give up the QOL l enjoy at my ULCC.

crxpilot 07-22-2015 11:14 AM


Originally Posted by CarbonCub (Post 1934926)
First off, the contract does not specifically address a requirement to fly if a pilot "accidentally" picks up their phone. The phone contact is the only legal method scheduling can use to junior man a pilot.

I am a commuter and have picked up my phone several times to hear what they have to say regarding a junior assignment needing to be filled. Not once have they required me to fly.

It would kinda hard to go flying when they call you up and you have a beer in your hand.............

Lobaeux 07-22-2015 11:42 AM


Originally Posted by crxpilot (Post 1934992)
It would kinda hard to go flying when they call you up and you have a beer in your hand.............

That's one way to get out of it. :D

Plane Ramrod 07-22-2015 11:47 AM


Originally Posted by crxpilot (Post 1934992)
It would kinda hard to go flying when they call you up and you have a beer in your hand.............

Like I said, there are ways around it, but the op said you CAN'T be ja'd which is incorrect.

HacksawDuggan 07-22-2015 06:45 PM

How to not be JA'd is a technique, not a procedure.

Some guys like to make it more complicated than it should be by answering when the phone rings.

Lobaeux 07-22-2015 06:57 PM

The point is, I don't have to be JA'd if I don't want to. The contract clearly states I cannot be JA'd unless they call my contact number and I answer, I cannot be JA'd on the jet bridge, I cannot be JA'd in the crew room, I cannot be JA'd via ACARS, and I cannot be JA'd if I call scheduling to ask a question. Maybe this isn't a big deal, maybe all the rest of the majors and legacies have this same protection, I don't know. But, in my specific case, this seems to be a good deal and something I don't want to lose.

Do the legacies and other majors have this same protection? Seems like a pretty good deal/contract provision to me.

dang 07-22-2015 10:04 PM

Sounds like the same JA policy we have at F9. Just don't answer your phone. I don't know why people are making it complicated, if you want a JA you can have one. If you don't, there isn't a way it can be forced upon you...Simple.

tom11011 07-26-2015 07:34 AM

For those who went to the DFW job fair, have any of you received a call/email from Spirit to interview? (Besides yellow suit guy) :)

Cruise 07-26-2015 10:57 AM


Originally Posted by tom11011 (Post 1937525)
For those who went to the DFW job fair, have any of you received a call/email from Spirit to interview? (Besides yellow suit guy) :)

I have a friend that went to the fair, has since interviewed and been offered a class date. I think DFW was his second job fair...although I'm not 100% on that.

IWalkJun12 07-27-2015 07:21 AM

You guys need to reread the contract.

JA is for pay purposes. 200%

When scheduling calls, they OFFER JA. You either say yes or you say no. Period. There's no excuses of why you can't. Sorry, can't help today or Naah I'm not interested.

It's nothing like junior assign anywhere else. Been like that for 9 years that I've been here, hasn't changed yet. Only way it changes is if you vote for it to change.

sulkair 07-27-2015 08:13 AM


Originally Posted by IWalkJun12 (Post 1938141)
You guys need to reread the contract.

JA is for pay purposes. 200%

When scheduling calls, they OFFER JA. You either say yes or you say no. Period. There's no excuses of why you can't. Sorry, can't help today or Naah I'm not interested.

It's nothing like junior assign anywhere else. Been like that for 9 years that I've been here, hasn't changed yet. Only way it changes is if you vote for it to change.

You're at Spirit right?

Left Handed 07-27-2015 09:56 AM


Originally Posted by IWalkJun12 (Post 1938141)
You guys need to reread the contract.

JA is for pay purposes. 200%

When scheduling calls, they OFFER JA. You either say yes or you say no. Period. There's no excuses of why you can't. Sorry, can't help today or Naah I'm not interested.

It's nothing like junior assign anywhere else. Been like that for 9 years that I've been here, hasn't changed yet. Only way it changes is if you vote for it to change.


We have been lucky at Spirit. The fact that scheduling doesn't know our contract does not mean the we can't be involuntarily junior manned. Section 25.J.4 says "The company may only attempt to junior assign a pilot by calling him on his contact number(s). The company is prohibited from involuntarily junior assigning the pilot through base operations, dispatch, flight control, phone patch to an aircraft, or on a company layover. A pilot may not be given an involuntary junior assignment when crew scheduling has contacted the pilot for a purpose other that junior assigning. A pilot will not be junior assigned solely because he has contacted crew scheduling regarding routing inquiries."

This is one time where weak wording works in our favor. The contract spells out how they can't do it, and leaves how you can be JRM'ed between the lines.

So we can be involuntarily JRMed, but only if we pick up our phone when they call. This has actually happened to me (long story). I tried the naah, I can't, and they said too bad you're going. I think with the amount of people begging for them, scheduling doesn't have a problem filling them, so they don't often have to resort to involuntarily JRM. Plus all the ways previously mentioned to avoid them if you don't want one, makes this company's JRM policy seem optional.

72215 02-18-2016 04:27 AM


Originally Posted by F9 Driver (Post 1929055)
You don't have a choice to make until you get a job offer(s).

Do your homework on both, try to get at least one and, if you're fortunate enough to be hired by both, make a "pros v cons" chart or flip a coin. With low pay QOL is everything.

Once you get to one of these ULCCs don't get comfortable. Learn as much as you can and have some fun, but if total career earnings and international widebody flying are what you're looking for - keep the applications with the Legacies current, and work your contacts.

The Air Wisconsin pilots were once very happy flying BAE-146s out of Denver for jobs that topped at just north of 100K. They were home almost every night, and had a nice niche carved out for themselves. Some of the Major airline pilots gave them grief, but $100K was enough to live on and they were happy. Nobody's business but theirs. Then UAL filed.

All of a sudden the 146 went away, and commuting to PHL on our red-eye to start work a couple of hours after landing, in a CRJ for $100K (or less), took the polish right off that apple. The #1 pilot from their list jumped to F9 almost immediately.

The moral is: Figure out what's important to you, and go for it. But try and make every stop along the way someplace you'd hang your hat for the rest of your career - in case you have to or decide to.

I've got no answer to your question. It's a matter of personal choice. I came to F9 with plenty of total & jet PIC time, but no 121 time. I figured I'd get that box checked, and go to DAL or Alaska (the only two that appealed to me for my own reasons). I got here just before we announced the Airbus order (then 9/11 & Legacy bankruptcies happened), and was off to the races with a two year upgrade, a bunch of out-of-contract pay raises / bonuses, a PS ride to/from work in my car and a fun group of people to work with. I'm not leaving now - but that's just me.

Good luck & study hard!

For new guys coming into the airlines or guys like me looking to make the jump from 135 to 121; read this post. You have to do what works for your life, situation, location... Ect. A dream job for someone else may not make you happy. I have been in the industry for 17 years now and seen most sides of commercial aviation, every path has positives and negatives. I still smile at every takeoff clearance so as long as I am still being paid enough to support my family with a schedule that allows me to see them I am happy. 80% of us have GREAT jobs, look around at the airport and realize all the other jobs out there we could be doing. Keep loving it as long as you can keep that first class medical!

minimwage4 02-18-2016 06:44 AM

As far as I've been told, the general concesus is that the last CA has already been hired at both places. Not good with a relatively young pilot group.

Guys getting on now at best will be junior CA or senior FOs unless more orders are announced. That's why mins have been dropped I guess at least for Spirit.

Some said Spirit wants to be at 300 though.

Chimpy 02-18-2016 06:50 AM


Originally Posted by minimwage4 (Post 2070764)
As far as I've been told, the general concesus is that the last CA has already been hired at both places. Not good with a relatively young pilot group.

Guys getting on now at best will be junior CA or senior FOs unless more orders are announced. That's why mins have been dropped I guess at least for Spirit.

Some said Spirit wants to be at 300 though.


Wouldn't matter if we had respectable Rates for F/Os.

I'm a 4th year CA and make less than a 2nd year UAL F/O.

How's that for depressing. Let's hope our contract Comes sooner rather than later. I've never been a CA before so makes the job kind of exciting again but I'd rather be an F/O, lol. Better schedule and less responsibility. Problem is you currently HAVE TO UPGRADE AT both NKS & F9 to make any money

Missed Appch 02-18-2016 07:19 AM

Between the two, I'd look at schedules as well. Doesn't Spirit have four days guaranteed between trips? The schedules at Frontier are bad and getting worse.

minimwage4 02-18-2016 07:23 AM


Originally Posted by Missed Appch (Post 2070808)
Between the two, I'd look at schedules as well. Doesn't Spirit have four days guaranteed between trips? The schedules at Frontier are bad and getting worse.

I've seen some strange redeye schedules on frontier but don't you get like 15 to 18 off a month even under junior schedules?

ManFlex 02-18-2016 07:28 AM


Originally Posted by Missed Appch (Post 2070808)
Between the two, I'd look at schedules as well. Doesn't Spirit have four days guaranteed between trips? The schedules at Frontier are bad and getting worse.

No less than four days off between work blocks. Work blocks can be up to six days long. This includes reserve lines as well.

Big E 757 02-18-2016 07:33 AM


Originally Posted by Window_Seat (Post 1928908)
Yeah, thats what I think. I'd rather see the growth in the high paying jobs at the legacies than LCC's and ULCC's putting cost pressures on the jobs that are actually desirable. I did the regional thing. It sucks but I think its short sighted to run off to an LCC for ****ty wages. When contact time comes around only willing to negotiate a rate that compares with other LCC's.

Window Seat, your posts make every one of us look like douche bags. If it wasn't Spirit or Frontier, it would be some other start up like skybus "flooding the market" with cheap seats. There is a never ending supply of people who, for some reason, want to own an airline. If there was a capacity void out there, someone is going to fill it.

We are all the same type of people, doing the same type of job. The guys at the LLC's and ULCC's aren't your enemy. They are your colleagues, doing the same thing you're doing. Working for a living so they can provide for their family. You are no better than them because you work for Delta. Don't ever forget that.

I just realized that this post was 7 months ago, oh well, it still applies.

NJGov 02-18-2016 10:01 AM


Originally Posted by Left Handed (Post 1938258)

So we can be involuntarily JRMed, but only if we pick up our phone when they call. This has actually happened to me (long story). I tried the naah, I can't, and they said too bad you're going. I think with the amount of people begging for them, scheduling doesn't have a problem filling them, so they don't often have to resort to involuntarily JRM. Plus all the ways previously mentioned to avoid them if you don't want one, makes this company's JRM policy seem optional.


Did you get the 10 hours of required rest before the duty start of your assignment prescribed by 117? Or was this pre-117?

Bolo 02-18-2016 10:20 PM

Let me make this simple for all of you:
1) At Spirit you get your hotel paid for during training. At Frontier you do not!
2) At Spirit no training contract. At Frontier $24,000 training contract for two years!
3) New hire pay at Republic is higher than new higher pay at Frontier!

Get the picture?

Gunga Din 02-19-2016 03:12 AM


Originally Posted by Bolo (Post 2071438)
Let me make this simple for all of you:
1) At Spirit you get your hotel paid for during training. At Frontier you do not!
2) At Spirit no training contract. At Frontier $24,000 training contract for two years!
3) New hire pay at Republic is higher than new higher pay at Frontier!

Get the picture?

Republic has better new hire pay than Spirit too. The idea we are comparing pay to regionals at all is pathetic.

ManFlex 02-19-2016 05:41 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Din (Post 2071464)
Republic has better new hire pay than Spirit too. The idea we are comparing pay to regionals at all is pathetic.

Republic has better new hire pay than UPS!!!

VegassBus 02-19-2016 05:51 AM


Originally Posted by ManFlex (Post 2071508)
Republic has better new hire pay than UPS!!!

And DELTA doesn't pay for your hotel in basic Indoc.


DELTA & UPS both offer much higher pay & retirment than F9 & NKS

Aero1900 02-19-2016 06:27 AM

Frontier has a 2 year upgrade at either Chicago or Orlando.

Both airlines are very similar and both are working on much needed new contracts. Let's wish the best for both companies as they work on bettering the career.

soill 02-19-2016 07:58 AM


Originally Posted by ShyGuy (Post 1928713)

Hahaha....nothing tickles me more than 2nd grade-level grammatical errors in an insult to someone else's English.

OHPilot213 02-19-2016 10:09 AM


Originally Posted by Bolo (Post 2071438)
Let me make this simple for all of you:
1) At Spirit you get your hotel paid for during training. At Frontier you do not!
2) At Spirit no training contract. At Frontier $24,000 training contract for two years!
3) New hire pay at Republic is higher than new higher pay at Frontier!

Get the picture?

Isn't it true that while Spirit does pay for your hotel during training you are not paid guarantee during training but instead paid a lesser amount until you finish training?

TNDeltaFlyboy 02-19-2016 11:50 AM


Originally Posted by VegassBus (Post 2071514)
And DELTA doesn't pay for your hotel past basic Indoc.


DELTA & UPS both offer much higher pay & retirment than F9 & NKS

Fixed it for you.

Macjet 02-19-2016 01:49 PM


Originally Posted by OHPilot213 (Post 2071668)
Isn't it true that while Spirit does pay for your hotel during training you are not paid guarantee during training but instead paid a lesser amount until you finish training?

Yes. $1,000/month plus $650 per diem IIRC.

DFWEMB 02-19-2016 02:17 PM

It's 1,000 / 750

Missed Appch 02-19-2016 07:25 PM


Originally Posted by minimwage4 (Post 2070814)
I've seen some strange redeye schedules on frontier but don't you get like 15 to 18 off a month even under junior schedules?

I don't remember exactly, but I think there were 10 lines with 17-18 days off. Keep in mind that FO's have to bid extra lines for every check airman scheduled to do IOE for the month. So even the number one FO has to bid 11 lines (assuming 10 check airman doing IOE) as they won't assign an FO to a line if a check airman gets it. It's a total crock.

Junior people who are line holders are looking at 13 days off.

DENpilot 02-20-2016 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by Missed Appch (Post 2071961)
I don't remember exactly, but I think there were 10 lines with 17-18 days off. Keep in mind that FO's have to bid extra lines for every check airman scheduled to do IOE for the month. So even the number one FO has to bid 11 lines (assuming 10 check airman doing IOE) as they won't assign an FO to a line if a check airman gets it. It's a total crock.

Junior people who are line holders are looking at 13 days off.

There are only 10 lines with 13 days off for March. Unless you want to fly your line as awarded and do absolutely no trading, there's no reason you can't improve that to 15 days off.

I am a fairly junior DEN lineholder and have vacation this month and last month. I still managed 159 hours credit with 16 days off after picking up a couple trips. Point is, as much as productivity sucks, if you put the time in, you can have a decent schedule as a junior pilot.

cfouriv 02-20-2016 05:39 PM


Originally Posted by DENpilot (Post 2072405)
There are only 10 lines with 13 days off for March. Unless you want to fly your line as awarded and do absolutely no trading, there's no reason you can't improve that to 15 days off.

I am a fairly junior DEN lineholder and have vacation this month and last month. I still managed 159 hours credit with 16 days off after picking up a couple trips. Point is, as much as productivity sucks, if you put the time in, you can have a decent schedule as a junior pilot.

I have my first line this month and I have 14 days off with 92 credit. I could have had 17 days off and over 75 hrs easy. Depends on what your looking for. Obviously with vacation you can rack up some pretty good credit.

VegassBus 02-20-2016 05:46 PM


Originally Posted by cfouriv (Post 2072419)
I have my first line this month and I have 14 days off with 92 credit. I could have had 17 days off and over 75 hrs easy. Depends on what your looking for. Obviously with vacation you can rack up some pretty good credit.

Yeah well both at Spirit & F9 you need to credit 200hrs a month to be on par with our Legacy Airbus peers.

ULLI 02-20-2016 05:50 PM


Originally Posted by cfouriv (Post 2072419)
I have my first line this month and I have 14 days off with 92 credit. I could have had 17 days off and over 75 hrs easy. Depends on what your looking for. Obviously with vacation you can rack up some pretty good credit.

Are you with F9 or NK? And where are you based at?

cfouriv 02-21-2016 01:22 AM


Originally Posted by ULLI (Post 2072426)
Are you with F9 or NK? And where are you based at?

F9 in Denver

azcz10 02-21-2016 03:56 AM

I was hired Thursday (F9) for the April 4 class. It looks like you are able to move things around to either have more days off when you need it or more credit if you need that. I reviewed the bid packs for all 3 bases and it looked like the average line was built with about 15 days off with about 75-76 hrs of credit. There were some 4-day trips with 20-25hrs and some with 14 hrs. I'll be commuting ATL-MCO if/when I get MCO. An MCO CA was telling me that a lot of trips end at 0830 in MCO & that's a lot like having a day off...even tho it's considered a day of work.

ULLI 02-21-2016 04:39 AM


Originally Posted by azcz10 (Post 2072563)
I was hired Thursday (F9) for the April 4 class. It looks like you are able to move things around to either have more days off when you need it or more credit if you need that. I reviewed the bid packs for all 3 bases and it looked like the average line was built with about 15 days off with about 75-76 hrs of credit. There were some 4-day trips with 20-25hrs and some with 14 hrs. I'll be commuting ATL-MCO if/when I get MCO. An MCO CA was telling me that a lot of trips end at 0830 in MCO & that's a lot like having a day off...even tho it's considered a day of work.


What did they tell you as far as upgrades go for 2016 at F9? Last i heard 90-100.
@ cfouriv, not bad for your first month, however lines can be a lot more efficient.

azcz10 02-21-2016 06:00 AM

I don't recall hearing the number of upgrades for 2016. In one of the recent upgrade classes, a couple of them were hired 2yrs and 4 days ago. Planning an increase of at least 9 new aircraft in the next year or so and a new pilot domicile. Maybe out west - PHX or LAS but possibly out east - PHL. I'm sure it'll be a surprise to everyone when it's announced & I don't blame them. I wouldn't want the competition to know.

azcz10 02-21-2016 09:07 AM


Originally Posted by azcz10 (Post 2072611)
I don't recall hearing the number of upgrades for 2016. In one of the recent upgrade classes, a couple of them were hired 2yrs and 4 days ago. Planning an increase of at least 9 new aircraft in the next year or so and a new pilot domicile. Maybe out west - PHX or LAS but possibly out east - PHL. I'm sure it'll be a surprise to everyone when it's announced & I don't blame them. I wouldn't want the competition to know.

EDIT - APC says 12 upgrades per month on the Frontier page


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:39 AM.


User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Website Copyright ©2000 - 2017 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands