Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Mesa Airlines (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/mesa-airlines/)
-   -   Mesa Bk Countdown (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/mesa-airlines/26763-mesa-bk-countdown.html)

Scoop 05-30-2008 07:03 AM

MESA won an injunction, not the trial - big difference. In other words fella's - The Jury's still out on this one.

Scoop

Sniper 05-30-2008 07:33 AM


Originally Posted by GerBearr (Post 393687)
I would argue similar evidence is present here in regards to public opinion. When consumer satisfaction is rated according to the DOT Freedom is not reported.

Freedom Airlines doesn't report DOT #'s (Freedom doesn't meet the minimum revenue #'s to trigger required reporting). It's unlikely any author on this board knows where Freedom stands (though some post as if they do). If someone posts as if they know the #'s, than I'm asking them to speak up and substantiate their claims.


Delta has internal tracks of what is going on and what level of service is provided. They would not make that public because of the negative publicity. They just have to overcompensate for the mistakes of their DCI portfolio.
I agree, Delta knows which DCI carrier they consider 'the worst'. However, nobody on this board speaks on behalf of Delta or has access to Delta's internal #'s that I know of - and if they do, they likely wouldn't author posts on a message board divulging privileged info.


AND upon further investigation MESA Airline (I think just Air Midwest DBA "Mesa Airlines") was evaluated and didn't do so hot in 2007(not to say everyone else did that much better): http://eventplanning.about.com/gi/dy...ts/2007aqr.pdf
Mesa Airlines operates flying for US Airways Express and United Express. They don't operate flying for Delta. AirMidwest, like Freedom, doesn't report #'s to the DOT. AirMidwest is also ceasing to exist as a company in the near future. And as "STILL GROUNDED" pointed out, Mesa Airline's #'s are better than at least 2 DCI carriers. If we assume Freedom operates similarly to Mesa (most pilots who work @ Mesa Air Group say that Freedom Airlines is the operation that their management cares most about, and b/c of this attention they feel it runs the best - though this is just individual opinion, and therefore not fact), then Freedom is likely not "the worst" DCI carrier. That Delta is trying to get rid of them does offer ancillary evidence that Freedom may not be the top performing carrier, but it should also be noted Delta seeks only to eliminate Freedom's 50 seat ERJ flying, not the CRJ-705 flying Freedom does for Delta. If Freedom's operation is so undesirable, why not try to get rid of ALL of their DCI flying?

What's important to me to get across on this board is that the actions that make Freedom desirable or undesirable to Delta have very little to do with the individual contributions of the pilots who operate Freedom's flights. One can hope for the best for the pilots (or fellow brothers and sisters) without also supporting the management team or the company.

I agree with 'Scoop'. The trial is where the real action is. Furthermore, if it is true that an injunction was issued based upon Freedom's (and Mesa Air Group's) financial solvency, rather on the alleged breach of the terms of the contract enter into between Delta and Freedom, Delta may very well win @ the appellate level on the merits of the injunction.

GerBearr 05-30-2008 07:55 AM

Very well put Sniper.

Delta substantiated the cancellation due to freedom's "performance issues" as evidenced by the multitude of Press Releases related to the injunctions.

I guess we will find out more details as to the extent of these issue as the case progresses.

Of course we as pilots only have so much control of any performance issues.

I hope Mesa Pilots understand they really aren't the cause of the problem so much as they are somewhat indirectly involved. We as pilots only have so much control over a situation. And as proven with GO!! there will be a scapegoat other than JO if everything unravels.

andy171773 05-30-2008 09:47 AM


Originally Posted by Sniper (Post 393723)

If Freedom's operation is so undesirable, why not try to get rid of ALL of their DCI flying?

The CRJ9 flying that freedom does is under a different contract, their ERJ flying is separate from their CRJ stuff.

Whether that's "next" is left to be seen.

rickair7777 05-30-2008 01:56 PM


Originally Posted by andy171773 (Post 393819)
The CRJ9 flying that freedom does is under a different contract, their ERJ flying is separate from their CRJ stuff.

Whether that's "next" is left to be seen.

Since those 900's are owned by DAL, mesa had better be on their best behavior. DAL would be reluctant to fire a 900 operator who owns their own planes because those are a hot commodity (even today), and they would quickly end up flying for a competitor. But mesa is easy to get rid of (gotta give DAL some credit for setting it up that way in the first place).

PCLCREW 05-30-2008 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 393939)
Since those 900's are owned by DAL, mesa had better be on their best behavior. DAL would be reluctant to fire a 900 operator who owns their own planes because those are a hot commodity (even today), and they would quickly end up flying for a competitor. But mesa is easy to get rid of (gotta give DAL some credit for setting it up that way in the first place).


Word out of MEM a few times was that Pinnacle or Comair will get those 900's when they completely kick Freedom out in 4 years... They want to keep them out of JFK so my bet would be Comair.

hslightnin 05-30-2008 07:53 PM


Originally Posted by PCLCREW (Post 394081)
Word out of MEM a few times was that Pinnacle or Comair will get those 900's when they completely kick Freedom out in 4 years... They want to keep them out of JFK so my bet would be Comair.

yes im sure that DL hates mesa in JFK with there Block or Block pay

muushin 06-03-2008 08:43 AM

M.e.s.a.
 
M aking

E veryone


S uffer


A lways

rickair7777 06-03-2008 08:53 AM


Originally Posted by muushin (Post 395967)
M aking

E veryone


S uffer


A lways


My
Employer
Sucks
***

andy171773 06-03-2008 09:27 AM

Mexican
Enchiladas
Satisfy
Anger


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:24 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands