Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Up and Out Policies: Upgrade (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/32671-up-out-policies-upgrade.html)

BoilerUP 10-25-2008 08:34 AM


Originally Posted by de727ups
Now he's going to make 7K a year in the right seat of an RJ. What's to feel sorry for?

...per month.

rickair7777 10-25-2008 08:34 AM


Originally Posted by de727ups (Post 485326)
The fact remains. If ALPA was at Skywest, it's likely the up or out policy would have been changed and TonyW would still work there. He was rabidly anti-ALPA on this site during the vote. Now he's going to make 7K a year in the right seat of an RJ. What's to feel sorry for?

"The grossly unscientific poll I saw on the SAPA forum was that 25% supported Up-n-Out. I suspect that out of that 25%, virtually all were captains who "already got their's"

Sounds like the other 75% would like to see it changed. What other ALPA airlines have an up or out policy? I think AA does but they aren't ALPA. Personally, I think it's a dumb policy. We have lifer F/O's at UPS. Some do it for the lifestyle and some just can't make the upgrade. Either way, it should be no big deal to stay as an F/O.

I think it's $7K/month, not bad for an FO...as long as you don't have to move your family to sandland.

Although I may not agree with him on every point, I respect TW for his participation, and attempting to be part of the solution. It is ironic that a union (ANY union) probably would have put the kabosh on pass-or-out.

ebuhoner 10-25-2008 08:36 AM

Im totally shocked.. I Didn't know that a company like Skywest could have such a policy. The upgrade training must be a really stressful environment knowing that if you screw up you are fired.. for life!! and basically with no opportunity to work for a good 121 Air carrier again EVER!....

TW I wish you the Best of lucks!

de727ups 10-25-2008 08:45 AM

Oh yeah, I meant 7K per month. And TW doesn't seem to be complaining about the job too much.

And, no, I don't like cats, either...

"It is ironic that a union (ANY union) probably would have put the kabosh on pass-or-out."

Agreed. That was my point.

rickair7777 10-25-2008 08:51 AM


Originally Posted by ebuhoner (Post 485333)
Im totally shocked.. I Didn't know that a company like Skywest could have such a policy. The upgrade training must be a really stressful environment knowing that if you screw up you are fired.. for life!! and basically with no opportunity to work for a good 121 Air carrier again EVER!....

TW I wish you the Best of lucks!

It's not quit THAT bad. I don't know what underlying issues were present in TW's situation, but very, very few folks actually fail upgrade and get fired (I suspect that outside issues unrelated to training were involved in this case).

Also TW attempted to upgrade into the EMB-120 without ever having flown the aircraft. This is a KNOWN risky evolution...it might be worth doing if you have a year or less with the company and want fast PIC time. If you fail and get fired you don't lose much seniority.

In a normal hiring environment, someone in this situation would have no trouble getting a job at another regional...everyone knows that "stuff happens", especially if your training record was good otherwise.

jsled 10-25-2008 08:53 AM

Sorry TW. That policy is jacked. I knew a girl that failed her Captain upgrade at Express I (Pinnacle). She did the "walk of shame" across the ramp as an F/O for about 6 months and then got hired at FedEx!!!! She wasn't so down after that. I hope you meet a similar fate. As for up or out....at UAL we have over age 60 guys in the right seat!!! Some guys first Captain seat is the 777. Why not? That is how it should be IMO. To each his own.

ToiletDuck 10-25-2008 08:54 AM


Originally Posted by de727ups (Post 485326)
The fact remains. If ALPA was at Skywest, it's likely the up or out policy would have been changed and TonyW would still work there. He was rabidly anti-ALPA on this site during the vote. Now he's going to make 7K a year in the right seat of an RJ. What's to feel sorry for?

For accuracy sake he said $7k a month. Not a year. "What's to feel sorry for?" All I can say is wow. That's mighty big of you Mr. Moderator. How about a guy who's been working toward his career goals just had a very unfortunate thing happen? He might not have been pro-alpa but that doesn't mean he deserves what's happened. People are allowed their own opinions on matters and most of us are big enough to not try and rub their faces in it if it doesn't turn out the way they would have liked. There's nothing that says ALPA could have stopped this. It's possible and probable but to jump in and verbally slap a guy around is complete BS especially from a guy who's at a company that in fact has an in-house union.

If you're going to continue to bash people on a regular basis then you need to hang up your senior role here. You're suppose to be impartial and at least appreciative of the situations others are in.


Dear De727ups,

You have received an infraction at Airline Pilot Central Forums.

Reason:
-------
Flamebait

Please take the public bashing of an individual to PM's. Thank you.

"Please use the "good neighbor" policy when posting to this site. If you wouldn't say it to your neighbor face to face, than don't say it here"

-------
This infraction is worth 1 point(s) and may result in restricted access until it expires. Serious infractions will never expire.

paxhauler85 10-25-2008 09:42 AM


Originally Posted by HercDriver130 (Post 485255)
My personal grief is with those FO's who either NEVER attempt an upgrade or if they do and have problems ...NEVER attempt an upgrade again. The example I used above is a person who has been with the company nearly 9 years and has failed upgrade once several years ago, and is afraid of upgrading at this point.

Mine as well.

JetPipeOverht 10-25-2008 09:52 AM

Why does everyone bash the CRJ/ERJ pilots on the ' Jet vs Prop ' technicalities, then turn right around and be understanding of a prop driver failing a transistion to jet cause it's ' hard ' ? Double standard ?

paxhauler85 10-25-2008 10:51 AM


Originally Posted by Billy32 (Post 485247)
That is kinda screwed up. You go into an oral expecting aircraft questions. If they started with regs I would get thrown for a loop too. Kinda throws you off balance.

My initial and upgrade oral involved a lot of FAR/General Ops questions followed by systems questions about the airplane. 2 hours worth both times.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:36 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands