Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Commuting "Etiquette" (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/68736-commuting-etiquette.html)

Atlas Shrugged 07-09-2012 05:44 PM

"It is like a nighmare. It just keeps going, and going...."

LateralFlyer 07-09-2012 05:56 PM


Originally Posted by DeltaDX (Post 1227075)
LateralFlyer, it isn't "reasoning", it's reading FARs and Opspecs.

Of course the company is going to listen to a cap if he an issue with a pax, but at the same time, that is not free rein for (nor a right) for captain to do as he wishes, with no questions asked.

Obviously the chief will get involved with any unusual circumstances (and scream "opspecs! ... pilot in command!" all you want).

Who are you trying to kid?

You keep changing the topic at hand and making contradictions within your own statements.

No one is condoning a Captain for blatantly kicking off people just for the hell of it. I know of none who would do such a thing. We are discussing when PIC authority is in effect. I don't care how that particular FAR is worded. I can assure you, regardless of the phase of flight, a Captain will be held responsible for what takes place regarding said flight. This includes before, and during the boarding process.

SnoJet440 07-09-2012 05:58 PM

Holy crap this hurts. Riding on any kind of pass, sit down and shut up. Riding on a jumpseat, "ask for forgiveness". It is that simple.

NWA320pilot 07-09-2012 06:08 PM


Originally Posted by DeltaDX (Post 1226913)
I'm not a pilot, just a humble dispatcher. According to FARs, the pilot in command is not in command until he is actually piloting the airplane. Believe it or not, during the boarding process, the company can actually dictate who gets to ride in the back of their multi-million dollar machine. Imagine.

Of course, any captain can refuse to let an authorized person board. But not without answering for it, and he'd better have a damn good reason, and just saying "PIC" won't cut it.


I assume by your screen name you work for Delta Air lines....... If so maybe you should review the FOM.

DeltaDX 07-10-2012 03:58 AM


Originally Posted by LateralFlyer (Post 1227086)
I can assure you, regardless of the phase of flight, a Captain will be held responsible for what takes place regarding said flight. This includes before, and during the boarding process.

Now it's even before! Does that authority vest when he wakes up in his hotel room? :)

And I agree with you: if the company says a person is authorized to ride on their airplane, the captain will be held responsible if he disallows it.

LateralFlyer 07-10-2012 05:58 AM


Originally Posted by DeltaDX (Post 1227209)
Now it's even before! Does that authority vest when he wakes up in his hotel room? :)

And I agree with you: if the company says a person is authorized to ride on their airplane, the captain will be held responsible if he disallows it.

It could. Especially if there are issues regarding show times as it pertains to rest issues or maintenance. He or she isn't exerting Pilot in Command over anything, but Certainly Captain Authority, by amending the aircraft report time.

To your second statement, of course he or she may have to answer for his decision. Hell, the phone rings if we push 1 minute past departure time. But whether it be a Chief Pilot, Director of Operations, Fleet Manager, VP of Flight or Santa Clause...once the words "PIC/Captain Authority" or "safety of flight" are spoken, the conversation is over. Every single time.

It is concerning to me that as a dispatcher you don't understand this. You would make a great crew scheduler though!

skypine27 07-10-2012 06:21 AM


Originally Posted by Phuz (Post 1226416)
Dude this isnt very complicated. You either listed for a jumpseat or you didnt. If you did, u must ask the captain. If you did not then its optional.. No need for a 10 page thread.

Thank you.


I too don't understand why this thread is more than 1 post long. If you filled out the little piece of paper that had the word jumpseat on it somewhere, you check in with the crew even if the gate agent gives you a boarding pass with a seat assignment on it.

If you didn't, you just board like every other passenger.

Phuz 07-10-2012 06:39 AM


Originally Posted by Senior Skipper (Post 1226978)
I just came up with it. You wouldn't call me "Mr. President" if my username was Barrack Obama, would you?

Bull.

Might as well call urself F-15_Hero or USMC_COL.. You picked a username completely contrary to what you actually are. So in my book you are immature and deceitful. Combine that with the fact that you did not respond to my inquiry about your place of employment and i think we have a pretty clear picture of your personality.

This thread really needs a lock. You really need an accurate username.

LateralFlyer 07-10-2012 06:50 AM

Sorry for helping steer this thread off course, but the tangent conversation really got under my skin.

Saabs 07-10-2012 07:23 AM


Originally Posted by Phuz (Post 1227273)
Bull.

Might as well call urself F-15_Hero or USMC_COL.. You picked a username completely contrary to what you actually are. So in my book you are immature and deceitful. Combine that with the fact that you did not respond to my inquiry about your place of employment and i think we have a pretty clear picture of your personality.

This thread really needs a lock. You really need an accurate username.

Really? Who cares cut him some slack. I don't fly a Saab anymore do I need to change my name?


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:01 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands