Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Pncl ta passed (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/72368-pncl-ta-passed.html)

CriticalMach 01-15-2013 10:17 AM

Rip pinnacle - 01/15/2013

BIGRIG 01-15-2013 10:25 AM


Originally Posted by Bartok (Post 1330844)
Lol, all these Skywest pilots crying because someone else voted them a pay cut in the future.

If you had a union maybe you would have a vote in all this.

Next up to bat ExpressJet!

Good luck guys, hope they use a little lube on you guys, at least y'all can vote no if you want.

They will vote yes and blame pinnacle.

Jamers 01-15-2013 10:29 AM


Originally Posted by BIGRIG (Post 1330858)
They will vote yes and blame pinnacle.

+1

I sincerely hope they don't have to make such a crappy choice.

PBSG 01-15-2013 10:35 AM


Originally Posted by Bartok (Post 1330844)
Next up to bat ExpressJet!

Good luck guys, hope they use a little lube on you guys, at least y'all can vote no if you want.

Sweet! My turn to bat! Burn it down.

Oh wait, I work for L-XJT. We don't do Delta flying.

Bartok 01-15-2013 10:39 AM


Originally Posted by PBSG (Post 1330868)
Sweet! My turn to bat! Burn it down.

Oh wait, I work for L-XJT. We don't do Delta flying.

I guess all those 200's ASA flys for Delta won't hurt you when they go away.

Terantious 01-15-2013 10:46 AM

What a bunch of spineless weenies!!!

PBSG 01-15-2013 10:48 AM


Originally Posted by Bartok (Post 1330874)
I guess all those 200's ASA flys for Delta won't hurt you when they go away.

ASA made it very clear they will not negotiate without Flightline PBS. Not my fault.

tom14cat14 01-15-2013 10:48 AM

I am also sure that United wants all of those 50 seater's. Maybe I am misunderstanding your intentions of your statement. But you sound like you think you are above this.

skyxbomb 01-15-2013 10:50 AM


Originally Posted by Tinpusher007 (Post 1330820)
We are? Are you taking a pay cut, together with me? Would you be paying my bills if I lost my job? Would you give me your job and your seniority at your carrier? Would you get me another job...one of those jobs that starts higher than the max pay I will get here, the same job that you dont have yourself? Or would you just be happy if I applied to your crappy regional so I'd be junior to you?

That's classic lol somebody who voted yes on this TA just called another regional crappy.

For the 15% that voted no, good for you! We all knew it would pass but at least you tried! Probably the bottom 15% of the seniority list but nonetheless kudos to you! And best luck to the rest of you. Lets all move on soon and get out of this darn rat race!

johnso29 01-15-2013 10:58 AM


Originally Posted by Terantious (Post 1330882)
What a bunch of spineless weenies!!!

Be ready to walk the walk. Skywest is next.

gojo 01-15-2013 11:06 AM


Originally Posted by Terantious (Post 1330882)
What a bunch of spineless weenies!!!


You know, it's comments like this that shows this industry's true colors. Through this whole process we never recieved one offer of help from any other MEC. So in the interest of self preservation many voted this TA in. Your comments to vote this down was not a solution to the problem we face at the regional level. What we need is solidarity between all ALPA carriers. Offers of a certain percentage integration on your seniority list would have gone a long way to show solidarity. But that wouldn't have worked either, would it? Because it would have made your company more top heavy, and delayed up-grades to selfish people like you. Your only words of encouragement were that we would be able to start over, perhaps even at your company. Well, quite frankly with the state of the industry and most of the 200's going away, that's a bigger crap shoot than what Delta offered us. Face it, we are all do contract work, and Delta is going to manage their costs for said contracts. Your comments show you as self serving, arrogant, and a person that totally lacks compassion and understanding for people going through very tough times. And then you criticize us for making this choice. I truey hope that you and your kind are the minority where you work, and that you never have to experience what we went through. But I will also say that I'm old enough to believe in karma.

BIGRIG 01-15-2013 11:07 AM


Originally Posted by Terantious (Post 1330882)
What a bunch of spineless weenies!!!

Thank you.

tom14cat14 01-15-2013 11:14 AM


Originally Posted by gojo (Post 1330909)
You know, it's comments like this that shows this industry's true colors. Through this whole process we never recieved one offer of help from any other MEC. So in the interest of self preservation many voted this TA in. Your comments to vote this down was not a solution to the problem we face at the regional level. What we need is solidarity between all ALPA carriers. Offers of a certain percentage integration on your seniority list would have gone a long way to show solidarity. But that wouldn't have worked either, would it? Because it would have made your company more top heavy, and delayed up-grades to selfish people like you. Your only words of encouragement were that we would be able to start over, perhaps even at your company. Well, quite frankly with the state of the industry and most of the 200's going away, that's a bigger crap shoot than what Delta offered us. Face it, we are all do contract work, and Delta is going to manage their costs for said contracts. Your comments show you as self serving, arrogant, and a person that totally lacks compassion and understanding for people going through very tough times. And then you criticize us for making this choice. I truey hope that you and your kind are the minority where you work, and that you never have to experience what we went through. But I will also say that I'm old enough to believe in karma.

Great post

mooney 01-15-2013 11:24 AM


Originally Posted by Terantious (Post 1330882)
What a bunch of spineless weenies!!!

translation......you messed up my upgrade because we will not be getting the new 900's or your current ones...:rolleyes:

Would you have refused to fly them for 9e guys taking one for the team and sticking it to the man?

Tinpusher007 01-15-2013 11:30 AM


Originally Posted by skyxbomb (Post 1330890)
That's classic lol somebody who voted yes on this TA just called another regional crappy.

My statement was NOT meant to imply that Pinnacle and this TA aren't beyond crappy. It was meant to imply that almost all jobs in this sector of the business are crappy by the very nature of the agreements our companies have with the majors and the conflict of interest that exists within our "national union".

skyxbomb 01-15-2013 11:48 AM

I agree 100% and like I said I wish you guys the best and hope we can all move on. Just funny there are many guys and gals out there believe their crappy regional is better than another crappy regional :)

Don't worry guys we will have a shortage soon and all regionals will shut down and we will all go to majors! I've waited 13 years, surely it won't be another 13 before the shortage begins!

LoudFastRules 01-15-2013 11:55 AM


Originally Posted by seafeye (Post 1330816)
That's the problem. You think we are just bystanders.
Actually we are all in this together.

Sure, sure we are. That's why your airline offered us all jobs at no loss of pay, right?

sinsilvia666 01-15-2013 12:06 PM


Originally Posted by MyMamma (Post 1330772)
The 1% that voted NO can still complain:D

exactly, ill still gripe.....im disappointed this passed. and i do understand both sides of the issue, however I think this sets another lower wall to the rest of the industry.
:mad:

McNugent 01-15-2013 12:18 PM

What is up with you guys thinking you should've gotten some sort of integration help from another airline? What are you smoking? Should other ALPA airlines have offered preferential interviews? Shoot yeah! But seniority and longevity??? You're nuts!

Good luck though, we're all going to need it now.

Tinpusher007 01-15-2013 12:24 PM


Originally Posted by McNugent (Post 1330978)
What is up with you guys thinking you should've gotten some sort of integration help from another airline? What are you smoking? Should other ALPA airlines have offered preferential interviews? Shoot yeah! But seniority and longevity??? You're nuts!

Good luck though, we're all going to need it now.

Because everyone likes to sling the mud on us for voting this in based how how they think it will affect them. The alternative for us would have been no job at all or starting over at another regional at less pay, both of which are worse than eating this **** sandwich IMO. No one expects their seniority and pay to transfer to another company...this is the airline industry after all.

ShyGuy 01-15-2013 12:26 PM


Originally Posted by Tinpusher007 (Post 1330984)
Because everyone likes to sling the mud on us for voting this in based how how they think it will affect them. The alternative for us would have been no job at all or starting over at another regional at less pay, both of which are worse than eating this **** sandwich IMO. No one expects their seniority and pay to transfer to another company...this is the airline industry after all.

A wind-down would have taken at least 12 months. 65% of the pilot group will be furloughed (or gone - attrition) within the next 12-24 months. It seems no matter which way this TA went, the die is already cast for 65% of the pilots.

Tinpusher007 01-15-2013 12:31 PM


Originally Posted by ShyGuy (Post 1330987)
A wind-down would have taken at least 12 months. 65% of the pilot group will be furloughed (or gone - attrition) within the next 12-24 months. It seems no matter which way this TA went, the die is already cast for 65% of the pilots.

It isnt that simple. We arent losing 140 airplanes overnight. The latest projections still have us possibly having up to 60 200s 2 years from now. The exit schedule for them is based on when the engine mx comes up. They arent all at the same time. There will be overlap between 900s arriving and 200s leaving. The latest projections accounting for the SSP, retirements and attrition is less than 100 now. At some point hiring may even be necessary. So while 65% of the pilots currently on the list may not be here in a couple of years, they will not be involuntarily furloughed most likely.

misterwl 01-15-2013 01:03 PM

Pinnacle pilots ratify agreement
 
Pinnacle Airlines pilots ratify new labor agreement | LeveragedLoan.com

the company said the new agreement’s changes, which covers pilot pay, retirement, work rules and benefits, will become effective when concessions are implemented for the airline’s other labor groups and non-union employees.”


Pinnacle Airlines pilots ratify new labor agreement | LeveragedLoan.com

johnso29 01-15-2013 01:07 PM

Already another thread with 6000+ views and 60+ responses.

PCLCREW 01-15-2013 01:20 PM


Originally Posted by Tinpusher007 (Post 1330984)
Because everyone likes to sling the mud on us for voting this in based how how they think it will affect them. The alternative for us would have been no job at all or starting over at another regional at less pay, both of which are worse than eating this **** sandwich IMO. No one expects their seniority and pay to transfer to another company...this is the airline industry after all.

In about a year and half if you want to keep flying you are going to be on the bottom of another regionals list starting over.
This is not an alternative its a delay... why oh why do you guys think this saved your job.. IT DIDNT! 65% of the pilots are gone from this company.. this seems to be forgotten in all of our mighty FOs posts.

Will 01-15-2013 01:44 PM

Well PCLCREW a lot can happen in 2 years. Believing it will be all good would be just as foolish as beleiving it will be all bad. I have been here for 15+ years, my experience in the industry leads me to believe my statement is correct.

PCLCREW 01-15-2013 01:50 PM


Originally Posted by Will (Post 1331059)
Well PCLCREW a lot can happen in 2 years. Believing it will be all good would be just as foolish as beleiving it will be all bad. I have been here for 15+ years, my experience in the industry leads me to believe my statement is correct.

I've been in for a couple of years less then you, but Im just saying what the union has posted... 100 aircraft leaving the fleet and 1000-1500 furloughs. If you are an FO or a Junior Capt your not making it thorugh this. Personally I dont care Ive been furloughed 3 times already... Im really just point out that the only jobs that have been saved are the most senior of this group... an FOs job is not saved, this TA merely postponed that happening.

Mesabah 01-15-2013 01:56 PM


Originally Posted by PCLCREW (Post 1331038)
In about a year and half if you want to keep flying you are going to be on the bottom of another regionals list starting over.
This is not an alternative its a delay... why oh why do you guys think this saved your job.. IT DIDNT! 65% of the pilots are gone from this company.. this seems to be forgotten in all of our mighty FOs posts.

I highly doubt 65% of the pilot group will be gone. I would have agreed with you and said that we would lose our jobs with certainty without the bridge agreement, but that deal and the precedent it sets changes everything. No way DAL management gives that up, not without major concessions from the mainline group to get rid of it.

Free Flyer 01-15-2013 02:08 PM

Sorry to read this information. As I see it Pinnacle has now pay rate "matched" themselves to be competitive for all of the American flying that Republic/Shuttle America is bidding for at this time.

I never like to see anyone associated with ALPA or any other airline union get threatened to take a pay cut or be done away with while the CEO's and management make off with loads of cash. When is it our time to stand up and say enough is enough?

If you look at my position underneath my avatar you'll know how I voted on our CAL/United TA. It didn't go the way I wanted, but I'm not going to have a hissy fit about it.

As far as the Pinnacle TA, it's hard to say what would you do if it happened to you. If I was at a regional it seems as though it'd be a never ending cycle of chasing the quick upgrade just to get out of the regionals and into a major.

Let me give you this one food for thought. Please look at yourself and respect yourself for all of the money spent on education, time spent away from loved ones, and effort that you have poured into your careers. Keep that fighting spirit and PLEASE bring it to the majors with you when we all start hiring heavily within a year or two. I want to stand side by side with fellow pilots that want to bring this career back to where it belongs!

I don't intend for this to be a judgmental post. Keep your heads up PNCL pilots as it will get better, it's the only direction for it to turn.

ShyGuy 01-15-2013 02:36 PM

What's the point of ALPA at regionals if you doing contract feed gives no leverage.

Lone Palm 01-15-2013 02:38 PM


Originally Posted by Free Flyer (Post 1331072)
Sorry to read this information. As I see it Pinnacle has now pay rate "matched" themselves to be competitive for all of the American flying that Republic/Shuttle America is bidding for at this time.

I never like to see anyone associated with ALPA or any other airline union get threatened to take a pay cut or be done away with while the CEO's and management make off with loads of cash. When is it our time to stand up and say enough is enough?

If you look at my position underneath my avatar you'll know how I voted on our CAL/United TA. It didn't go the way I wanted, but I'm not going to have a hissy fit about it.

As far as the Pinnacle TA, it's hard to say what would you do if it happened to you. If I was at a regional it seems as though it'd be a never ending cycle of chasing the quick upgrade just to get out of the regionals and into a major.

Let me give you this one food for thought. Please look at yourself and respect yourself for all of the money spent on education, time spent away from loved ones, and effort that you have poured into your careers. Keep that fighting spirit and PLEASE bring it to the majors with you when we all start hiring heavily within a year or two. I want to stand side by side with fellow pilots that want to bring this career back to where it belongs!

I don't intend for this to be a judgmental post. Keep your heads up PNCL pilots as it will get better, it's the only direction for it to turn.



We won't be allowed to fly for other carriers........unless we are eventually divested by Delta.

Saabs 01-15-2013 02:40 PM


Originally Posted by Lone Palm (Post 1331090)
We won't be allowed to fly for other carriers........unless we are eventually divested by Delta.

Incorrect they specifically said we could fly for other carriers. Realistic? Nope.

Lone Palm 01-15-2013 02:48 PM


Originally Posted by Saabs (Post 1331091)
Incorrect they specifically said we could fly for other carriers. Realistic? Nope.



True, the union FAQ (which I didn't see as entirely truthful on this particular question) stated we could but it is highly unlikely. I can't recall a time when a wholly owned carrier successfully won a bid to fly for another carrier.

kilofoxtrot 01-15-2013 03:03 PM


Originally Posted by paxhauler85 (Post 1330778)
FWIW, still higher than Republic and Mesa. Rates nearly mirror the ASA CA rates through year 8. CA rates are .50-.75 below industry average. Capped at year 12 which is 1.20 below industry average.

FO: rates now $25 (industry standard), 33 (1.15 below industry standard), 37 (.05 below industry standard) , and 38.50 (.20 below). Capped at that point. Higher than GJ, Mesa, RP and essentially on par with Eagle.

Vacation got destroyed as well. Most anyone gets this year or next is 2 weeks.

Um?? No, Not correct ASA(Express Jet) 200 FO 23hr 1st year 36.13 2nd 38.58 3rd 39.79 4th 41.01 5th 42.29 6th 43.59 7th

Red97Vette 01-15-2013 03:30 PM

Im just shy of 7 years, FO at ASA and I'm at 45.57/hr, not much but probably better than most regionals.

edit: Im on the 700 (pays a little more per hour than the 200)

paxhauler85 01-15-2013 03:32 PM


Originally Posted by kilofoxtrot (Post 1331108)
Um?? No, Not correct ASA(Express Jet) 200 FO 23hr 1st year 36.13 2nd 38.58 3rd 39.79 4th 41.01 5th 42.29 6th 43.59 7th

On the CA side.

What 01-15-2013 04:55 PM


Originally Posted by Saabs (Post 1331091)
Incorrect they specifically said we could fly for other carriers. Realistic? Nope.

Having pinnacle flying for united worked so well, delta had the q's parked in less than 6 months and united still doesn't have them all in the air because they ate unable to staff them!

TopNotch 01-15-2013 05:02 PM

Only a couple years ago, 99% Pinnacle pilots voted to strike. This speaks volumes for all of us.

mooney 01-15-2013 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by TopNotch (Post 1331176)
Only a couple years ago, 99% Pinnacle pilots voted to strike. This speaks volumes for all of us.

a couple of years ago, we were dealing solely with a greedy incompetent regional management team with lots of newbies and disgruntled senior guys on property who had nothing to lose at all by shutting her down (and probably only for a few days) at a time when the economy was safe and there was hiring going on until the bust in mid '08. This time, the balance sheet was really in the red and we were not negotiating with Pinnacle management, we were dealing with DL, and same said pilots have more invested in the company, and realize Spandex and co. will be replaced. Plus the odds of getting on at a major are slim until 2014. USair already said no thanks to most of our experienced guys. At least that's what I see as the reason for the 99% then to the 85% for today...

Free Flyer 01-15-2013 06:43 PM


Originally Posted by TopNotch (Post 1331176)
Only a couple years ago, 99% Pinnacle pilots voted to strike. This speaks volumes for all of us.

Sorry for trolling on your regional thread, but if it makes you feel better we are the same at the majors. We at Continental/United voted 99% in favor for strike in early 2012. Then we voted in a substandard TA at 67% in favor about 8 months later. Wow, how weak are we?!?!

Management takes note of this behavior and it propagates itself over and over and over......


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:44 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands